CAT 2023 Slot 3 Quant Q9

  • Quantitative Aptitude
  • Arithmetic › Time & Work
  • Hard
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2023_SLOT3_QA_Q09

Question 9

Rahul, Rakshita and Gurmeet, working together, would have taken more than 77 days to finish a job. On the other hand, Rahul and Gurmeet, working together would have taken less than 1515 days to finish the job. However, they all worked together for 66 days, followed by Rakshita, who worked alone for 33 more days to finish the job. If Rakshita had worked alone on the job then the number of days she would have taken to finish the job, cannot be

  1. A

    1717

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    1616

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    2121

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    2020

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (C)

2121

Solution

  • Let combined rate of Rahul and Gurmeet be yy, and Rakshita's rate be xx.

  • Equation for total work: 6(y+x)+3x=1  ⟹  6y+9x=1  ⟹  y=1−9x66(y + x) + 3x = 1 \implies 6y + 9x = 1 \implies y = \frac{1-9x}{6}.

  • Condition 1: All three take >7>7 days   ⟹  y+x<17\implies y + x < \frac{1}{7}. Substituting yy: 1−3x6<17  ⟹  x>121\frac{1-3x}{6} < \frac{1}{7} \implies x > \frac{1}{21}.

  • Condition 2: Rahul & Gurmeet take <15<15 days   ⟹  y>115\implies y > \frac{1}{15}. Substituting yy: 1−9x6>115  ⟹  x<115\frac{1-9x}{6} > \frac{1}{15} \implies x < \frac{1}{15}.

  • Rakshita's time T=1xT = \frac{1}{x}. Thus, 15<T<2115 < T < 21.

  • TT cannot be 2121 as it is strictly less than 2121.

Detailed explanation

Concept: Time and Work

Let the rates of work of Rahul, Rakshita, and Gurmeet be r,x,gr, x, g respectively.

We are given:

  1. r+x+g<17r + x + g < \frac{1}{7} (since together they take more than 7 days)

  2. r+g>115r + g > \frac{1}{15} (since Rahul and Gurmeet take less than 15 days)

  3. They worked together for 6 days, then Rakshita worked alone for 3 days to finish the job:

6(r+x+g)+3x=1  ⟹  6(r+g)+9x=16(r + x + g) + 3x = 1 \implies 6(r + g) + 9x = 1.

From (3), we can express (r+g)(r + g) in terms of xx:

r+g=1−9x6r + g = \frac{1 - 9x}{6}.

Substitute this into inequalities (1) and (2).

From (1): r+g+x<17  ⟹  1−9x6+x<17  ⟹  1−3x6<17  ⟹  7−21x<6  ⟹  21x>1  ⟹  x>121r + g + x < \frac{1}{7} \implies \frac{1 - 9x}{6} + x < \frac{1}{7} \implies \frac{1 - 3x}{6} < \frac{1}{7} \implies 7 - 21x < 6 \implies 21x > 1 \implies x > \frac{1}{21}.

Since x>121x > \frac{1}{21}, the number of days Rakshita takes alone, which is 1x\frac{1}{x}, must be strictly less than 2121.

From (2): r+g>115  ⟹  1−9x6>115  ⟹  15−135x>6  ⟹  135x<9  ⟹  x<9135=115r + g > \frac{1}{15} \implies \frac{1 - 9x}{6} > \frac{1}{15} \implies 15 - 135x > 6 \implies 135x < 9 \implies x < \frac{9}{135} = \frac{1}{15}.

Since x<115x < \frac{1}{15}, the number of days Rakshita takes alone, 1x\frac{1}{x}, must be strictly greater than 1515.

So 15<1x<2115 < \frac{1}{x} < 21.

Rakshita's time must be between 1515 and 2121 days (exclusive of 21). Therefore, it cannot be 2121.

Practise similar questions

Practice 1 CAT_2023_SLOT3_QA_Q09_SQ01

Aarav, Bhavna and Chirag, working together, would have taken more than 66 days to complete a software project. On the other hand, Aarav and Chirag, working together, would have taken less than 1414 days to complete the project. However, all three worked together for 55 days, followed by Bhavna, who worked alone for 44 more days to complete the project. If Bhavna had worked alone on the project, then the number of days she would have taken to finish the project cannot be

  1. A

    1818

  2. B

    2424

  3. C

    2020

  4. D

    1616

Show answer and solution

Answer: (B)

2424

Solution

  • Total work equation: 5(y+b)+4b=1  ⟹  5y+9b=1  ⟹  y=1−9b55(y + b) + 4b = 1 \implies 5y + 9b = 1 \implies y = \frac{1-9b}{5}.

  • All three take >6> 6 days: y+b<16  ⟹  1−4b5<16  ⟹  b>124  ⟹  T<24y + b < \frac{1}{6} \implies \frac{1-4b}{5} < \frac{1}{6} \implies b > \frac{1}{24} \implies T < 24.

  • Aarav & Chirag take <14< 14 days: y>114  ⟹  1−9b5>114  ⟹  b<114  ⟹  T>14y > \frac{1}{14} \implies \frac{1-9b}{5} > \frac{1}{14} \implies b < \frac{1}{14} \implies T > 14.

  • Bhavna solo time TT must satisfy 14<T<2414 < T < 24.

  • Since TT is strictly less than 2424, it cannot be 2424 (Option 2).

Practice 2 CAT_2023_SLOT3_QA_Q09_SQ02

Priya, Qasim and Ritu, working together, would have taken more than 55 days to draft an architectural plan. On the other hand, Priya and Ritu, working together, would have taken less than 1111 days to draft the plan. However, all three worked together for 44 days, followed by Qasim, who worked alone for 33 more days to finish the plan. If Qasim had worked alone on the plan, then the number of days he would have taken to finish the plan cannot be

  1. A

    1212

  2. B

    1313

  3. C

    1515

  4. D

    1414

Show answer and solution

Answer: (C)

1515

Solution

  • Work completed: 4(y+q)+3q=1  ⟹  4y+7q=1  ⟹  y=1−7q44(y + q) + 3q = 1 \implies 4y + 7q = 1 \implies y = \frac{1-7q}{4}.

  • All three >5> 5 days: y+q<15  ⟹  1−3q4<15  ⟹  q>115  ⟹  T<15y + q < \frac{1}{5} \implies \frac{1-3q}{4} < \frac{1}{5} \implies q > \frac{1}{15} \implies T < 15.

  • Two together <11< 11 days: y>111  ⟹  1−7q4>111  ⟹  q<111  ⟹  T>11y > \frac{1}{11} \implies \frac{1-7q}{4} > \frac{1}{11} \implies q < \frac{1}{11} \implies T > 11.

  • Range for Qasim: 11<T<1511 < T < 15.

  • Hence, TT cannot be 1515 (Option 3).

Time & Work questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2025 Slot 1 Quant Q16
    Arun, Varun and Tarun, if working alone, can complete a task in 24, 21, and 15 days, respectively. They…
  2. CAT 2025 Slot 2 Quant Q10
    Ankita is twice as efficient as Bipin, while Bipin is twice as efficient as Chandan. All three of them start…
  3. CAT 2025 Slot 3 Quant Q7
    Teams A, B, and C consist of five, eight, and ten members, respectively, such that every member within a…
  4. CAT 2025 Slot 3 Quant Q13
    The rate of water flow through three pipes A, B and C are in the ratio 4 : 9 : 36. An empty tank can be…
  5. CAT 2024 Slot 1 Quant Q21
    Renu would take 15 days working 4 hours per day to complete a certain task whereas Seema would take 8 days…

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc