CAT 2018 Slot 2 Quant Q4

  • Quantitative Aptitude
  • Arithmetic › Time & Work
  • Hard
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2018_SLOT2_QA_Q04

Question 4

A tank is emptied everyday at a fixed time point. Immediately thereafter, either pump AA or pump BB or both start working until the tank is full. On Monday, AA alone completed filling the tank at 8pm8 \mathrm{pm}. On Tuesday, B alone completed filling the tank at 6pm6 \mathrm{pm}. On Wednesday, AA alone worked till 5pm5 \mathrm{pm}, and then B worked alone from 5pm5 \mathrm{pm} to 7pm7 \mathrm{pm}, to fill the tank. At what time was the tank filled on Thursday if both pumps were used simultaneously all along?

  1. A

    4:364:36 pm

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    4:244:24 pm

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    4:124:12 pm

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    4:484:48 pm

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (B)

4:244:24 pm

Solution

  • Stopping AA at 5 pm leaves 3 hours of AA's work, which BB completes in 2 hours (5 pm to 7 pm)   ⟹  3A=2B  ⟹  RateARateB=23\implies 3A = 2B \implies \frac{\text{Rate}_A}{\text{Rate}_B} = \frac{2}{3}.

  • The ratio of individual times is 3:23:2, with difference =8 pm−6 pm=2 hours= 8\text{ pm} - 6\text{ pm} = 2\text{ hours}.

  • Thus, tA=6 hrst_A = 6\text{ hrs}, tB=4 hrst_B = 4\text{ hrs}, meaning the daily start time is 8 pm−6 hrs=2 pm8\text{ pm} - 6\text{ hrs} = 2\text{ pm}.

  • Together: tAB=6×46+4=2.4 hrs=2 h 24 mt_{AB} = \frac{6 \times 4}{6 + 4} = 2.4\text{ hrs} = 2\text{ h } 24\text{ m}.

  • Finish time=2:00 pm+2:24=4:24 pm\text{Finish time} = 2:00\text{ pm} + 2:24 = 4:24\text{ pm}.

Detailed explanation

Concept: Work-Rate Proportionality, Combined Time, and Shift Analysis.

  1. Define baseline parameters:

    • Let the fixed starting time each day be T0T_0.

    • Let tAt_A be the time taken by pump AA alone to fill the entire tank.

    • Let tBt_B be the time taken by pump BB alone to fill the entire tank.

  2. Relate completion times on Monday and Tuesday:

    • Monday: AA alone finishes at 8 pm   ⟹  tA=8−T0\implies t_A = 8 - T_0.

    • Tuesday: BB alone finishes at 6 pm   ⟹  tB=6−T0\implies t_B = 6 - T_0.

    • Difference: tA−tB=(8−T0)−(6−T0)=2 hourst_A - t_B = (8 - T_0) - (6 - T_0) = 2\text{ hours}.

    • Thus, pump AA takes 2 hours longer than pump BB to fill the tank.

  3. Analyze Wednesday's work distribution:

    • Pump AA works until 5 pm, which is 3 hours before its normal finish time of 8 pm.

    • The remaining work for pump AA equals 3 hours of AA's effort.

    • Pump BB completes this remaining work between 5 pm and 7 pm (duration of 2 hours).

    • Equating work done:

      3×RA=2×RB  ⟹  RARB=233 \times R_A = 2 \times R_B \implies \frac{R_A}{R_B} = \frac{2}{3}

  4. Find individual filling times:

    • Filling time is inversely proportional to rate:

      tAtB=RBRA=32\frac{t_A}{t_B} = \frac{R_B}{R_A} = \frac{3}{2}

    • Since tA−tB=2 hourst_A - t_B = 2\text{ hours}:

      3k−2k=2  ⟹  k=23k - 2k = 2 \implies k = 2

      tA=3(2)=6 hours,tB=2(2)=4 hourst_A = 3(2) = 6\text{ hours}, \quad t_B = 2(2) = 4\text{ hours}

  5. Determine fixed start time T0T_0:

    T0=8 pm−6 hours=2 pmT_0 = 8\text{ pm} - 6\text{ hours} = 2\text{ pm}

  6. Calculate combined filling time on Thursday:

    • Working together, the time taken is:

      tAB=tA×tBtA+tB=6×46+4=2410=2.4 hours=2 hours 24 minutest_{AB} = \frac{t_A \times t_B}{t_A + t_B} = \frac{6 \times 4}{6 + 4} = \frac{24}{10} = 2.4\text{ hours} = 2\text{ hours } 24\text{ minutes}

    • Completion time:

      2:00 pm+2 hours 24 minutes=4:24 pm2:00\text{ pm} + 2\text{ hours } 24\text{ minutes} = 4:24\text{ pm}

    This corresponds to Option 2.

Practise similar questions

Practice 1 CAT_2018_SLOT2_QA_Q04_SQ01

A coolant reservoir in a manufacturing plant is drained every day at a fixed time. Immediately afterwards, either supply line AA or supply line BB or both start pumping coolant until the reservoir is completely full. On Monday, line AA alone finished filling the reservoir at 7 pm7\text{ pm}. On Tuesday, line BB alone finished filling the reservoir at 4 pm4\text{ pm}. On Wednesday, line AA alone worked until 4 pm4\text{ pm}, and then line BB worked alone from 4 pm4\text{ pm} to 6 pm6\text{ pm} to complete filling the reservoir. At what time was the reservoir filled on Thursday if both supply lines operated simultaneously from the start?

  1. A

    1:48 pm

  2. B

    1:36 pm

  3. C

    1:24 pm

  4. D

    2:12 pm

Show answer and solution

Answer: (B)

1:36 pm

Solution

  • Stopping AA at 4 pm4\text{ pm} leaves 3 hours of AA's work, which BB completes in 2 hours (4 pm4\text{ pm} to 6 pm6\text{ pm})   ⟹  3RA=2RB  ⟹  RARB=23\implies 3R_A = 2R_B \implies \frac{R_A}{R_B} = \frac{2}{3}.

  • The ratio of individual times is 3:23:2, and the difference is 7 pm−4 pm=3 hours7\text{ pm} - 4\text{ pm} = 3\text{ hours}.

  • Thus, tA=9 ht_A = 9\text{ h} and tB=6 ht_B = 6\text{ h}, giving daily start time 7 pm−9 h=10 am7\text{ pm} - 9\text{ h} = 10\text{ am}.

  • Together: tAB=9×69+6=3.6 h=3 h 36 mt_{AB} = \frac{9 \times 6}{9 + 6} = 3.6\text{ h} = 3\text{ h } 36\text{ m}.

  • Finish time =10:00 am+3:36=1:36 pm  ⟹  = 10:00\text{ am} + 3:36 = 1:36\text{ pm} \implies Option 2.

Practice 2 CAT_2018_SLOT2_QA_Q04_SQ02

A commercial swimming pool is drained every morning at a fixed time. Immediately thereafter, either inlet pipe PP or inlet pipe QQ or both operate to refill the pool. On Monday, pipe PP alone completely refilled the pool at 5 pm5\text{ pm}. On Tuesday, pipe QQ alone completely refilled the pool at 2 pm2\text{ pm}. On Wednesday, pipe PP alone operated until 3 pm3\text{ pm}, after which pipe QQ worked alone from 3 pm3\text{ pm} to 4 pm4\text{ pm} to finish refilling the pool. At what time was the pool refilled on Thursday if both pipes operated simultaneously throughout?

  1. A

    1:00 pm

  2. B

    12:45 pm

  3. C

    1:15 pm

  4. D

    1:30 pm

Show answer and solution

Answer: (A)

1:00 pm

Solution

  • Stopping pipe PP at 3 pm3\text{ pm} leaves 2 hours of PP's work, which pipe QQ finishes in 1 hour (3 pm3\text{ pm} to 4 pm4\text{ pm})   ⟹  2RP=1RQ  ⟹  RPRQ=12\implies 2R_P = 1R_Q \implies \frac{R_P}{R_Q} = \frac{1}{2}.

  • The time ratio is 2:12:1, with difference =5 pm−2 pm=3 hours= 5\text{ pm} - 2\text{ pm} = 3\text{ hours}.

  • Hence, tP=6 ht_P = 6\text{ h} and tQ=3 ht_Q = 3\text{ h}, so start time =5 pm−6 h=11 am= 5\text{ pm} - 6\text{ h} = 11\text{ am}.

  • Together: tPQ=6×36+3=2 hourst_{PQ} = \frac{6 \times 3}{6 + 3} = 2\text{ hours}.

  • Finish time =11:00 am+2 hours=1:00 pm  ⟹  = 11:00\text{ am} + 2\text{ hours} = 1:00\text{ pm} \implies Option 1.

Time & Work questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2025 Slot 1 Quant Q16
    Arun, Varun and Tarun, if working alone, can complete a task in 24, 21, and 15 days, respectively. They…
  2. CAT 2025 Slot 2 Quant Q10
    Ankita is twice as efficient as Bipin, while Bipin is twice as efficient as Chandan. All three of them start…
  3. CAT 2025 Slot 3 Quant Q7
    Teams A, B, and C consist of five, eight, and ten members, respectively, such that every member within a…
  4. CAT 2025 Slot 3 Quant Q13
    The rate of water flow through three pipes A, B and C are in the ratio 4 : 9 : 36. An empty tank can be…
  5. CAT 2024 Slot 1 Quant Q21
    Renu would take 15 days working 4 hours per day to complete a certain task whereas Seema would take 8 days…

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc