CAT 2018 Slot 1 Quant Q2

  • Quantitative Aptitude
  • Arithmetic › Time & Work
  • Medium
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2018_SLOT1_QA_Q02

Question 2

Humans and robots can both perform a job but at different efficiencies. Fifteen humans and five robots working together take thirty days to finish the job, whereas five humans and fifteen robots working together take sixty days to finish it. How many days will fifteen humans working together (without any robot) take to finish it?

  1. A

    4545

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    3636

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    4040

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    3232

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (D)

3232

Solution

  • Equate total work:

    30(15H+5R)=60(5H+15R)  ⟹  15H+5R=10H+30R  ⟹  1H=5R30(15H + 5R) = 60(5H + 15R) \implies 15H + 5R = 10H + 30R \implies 1H = 5R

  • Substitute R=H5R = \frac{H}{5} into Scenario 1:

    Effective rate=15H+5(H5)=16H\text{Effective rate} = 15H + 5\left(\frac{H}{5}\right) = 16H

    W=16H×30=480HW = 16H \times 30 = 480H

  • Days for 1515 humans:

    Days=480H15H=32 days\text{Days} = \frac{480H}{15H} = 32\text{ days}

Detailed explanation

Concept: Work, Efficiency, and Simultaneous Linear Equations.

  1. Let hh and rr be the daily work efficiencies of one human and one robot, respectively.

  2. The total work WW is the product of total daily efficiency and time taken:

    • For 15 humans and 5 robots working for 30 days:

      W=30(15h+5r)W = 30(15h + 5r)

    • For 5 humans and 15 robots working for 60 days:

      W=60(5h+15r)W = 60(5h + 15r)

  3. Equating both expressions for total work WW:

    30(15h+5r)=60(5h+15r)30(15h + 5r) = 60(5h + 15r)

  4. Divide both sides by 30:

    15h+5r=2(5h+15r)15h + 5r = 2(5h + 15r)

    15h+5r=10h+30r15h + 5r = 10h + 30r

    5h=25r  ⟹  h=5r5h = 25r \implies h = 5r

    This implies one human does the work of 55 robots.

  5. Express total work WW entirely in terms of human efficiency hh:

    Since r=h5r = \frac{h}{5}:

    W=30(15h+5r)=30(15h+5×h5)=30(15h+h)=30×16h=480hW = 30(15h + 5r) = 30\left(15h + 5 \times \frac{h}{5}\right) = 30(15h + h) = 30 \times 16h = 480h

  6. Calculate the time TT required for 15 humans working alone:

    T=W15h=480h15h=32 daysT = \frac{W}{15h} = \frac{480h}{15h} = 32\text{ days}

Practise similar questions

Practice 1 CAT_2018_SLOT1_QA_Q02_SQ01

Master carpenters and apprentices can both assemble handcrafted dining sets but at different efficiencies. Six master carpenters and two apprentices working together take eighteen days to complete an order, whereas two master carpenters and six apprentices working together take thirty days to complete the same order. How many days will six master carpenters working together (without any apprentice) take to complete the order?

  1. A

    1818

  2. B

    2020

  3. C

    2424

  4. D

    2525

Show answer and solution

Answer: (B)

2020

Solution

  • Equate total work: 18(6C+2A)=30(2C+6A)  ⟹  3(6C+2A)=5(2C+6A)18(6C + 2A) = 30(2C + 6A) \implies 3(6C + 2A) = 5(2C + 6A).

  • Simplify to find efficiency ratio: 18C+6A=10C+30A  ⟹  8C=24A  ⟹  C=3A18C + 6A = 10C + 30A \implies 8C = 24A \implies C = 3A.

  • Compute total work in terms of CC: W=18(6C+2C3)=18×20C3=120CW = 18\left(6C + \frac{2C}{3}\right) = 18 \times \frac{20C}{3} = 120C.

  • Time for 6 carpenters alone: T=120C6C=20 daysT = \frac{120C}{6C} = 20\text{ days} (Option 2).

Practice 2 CAT_2018_SLOT1_QA_Q02_SQ02

Senior software developers and junior interns can both refactor modules in a legacy codebase but at different efficiencies. Eight senior developers and four junior interns working together take twenty-four days to refactor the entire codebase, whereas four senior developers and eight junior interns working together take thirty-six days to finish the same task. How many days will eight senior developers working together (without any junior intern) take to finish refactoring the codebase?

  1. A

    2525

  2. B

    3030

  3. C

    2727

  4. D

    3232

Show answer and solution

Answer: (C)

2727

Solution

  • Equate work: 24(8D+4I)=36(4D+8I)  ⟹  2(8D+4I)=3(4D+8I)24(8D + 4I) = 36(4D + 8I) \implies 2(8D + 4I) = 3(4D + 8I).

  • Solve ratio: 16D+8I=12D+24I  ⟹  4D=16I  ⟹  D=4I16D + 8I = 12D + 24I \implies 4D = 16I \implies D = 4I.

  • Express work in DD: W=24(8D+D)=24×9D=216DW = 24(8D + D) = 24 \times 9D = 216D.

  • Time for 8 developers: T=216D8D=27 daysT = \frac{216D}{8D} = 27\text{ days} (Option 3).

Time & Work questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2025 Slot 1 Quant Q16
    Arun, Varun and Tarun, if working alone, can complete a task in 24, 21, and 15 days, respectively. They…
  2. CAT 2025 Slot 2 Quant Q10
    Ankita is twice as efficient as Bipin, while Bipin is twice as efficient as Chandan. All three of them start…
  3. CAT 2025 Slot 3 Quant Q7
    Teams A, B, and C consist of five, eight, and ten members, respectively, such that every member within a…
  4. CAT 2025 Slot 3 Quant Q13
    The rate of water flow through three pipes A, B and C are in the ratio 4 : 9 : 36. An empty tank can be…
  5. CAT 2024 Slot 1 Quant Q21
    Renu would take 15 days working 4 hours per day to complete a certain task whereas Seema would take 8 days…

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc