Group Work & The Man-Day-Hour Variation Chain (MDHE / W)
Master the unified Man-Day-Hour (MDH) proportionality chain, workforce demographic equivalences (Men, Women, Children), and tactical contractor renegotiations when deadlines are threatened.
1. The Story & Mental Model: Energy as Currency
Think of human labor in terms of pure physics. A single human worker is an engine generating a specific power output:
Work Done=Total Energy Consumed=Power×Time
If one worker produces E units of work per hour, and you employ M workers running for H hours each day across D days, the total work output W delivered is:
W=M×D×H×E
Notice that Work is directly proportional to each factor (M,D,H,E). Therefore, the ratio of total energy to output produced is invariant:
WM×D×H×E=Constant
This single universal law handles every question involving teams of construction workers, factory lines, garrison rations, or excavators.
2. The CAT Question Blueprint: The Three Archetypes
CAT questions on group work test three distinct structural scenarios:
-
The Pure Proportionality Chain: Changing team size, hours per day, and work dimensions simultaneously (e.g. digging a ditch of length L1 vs L2).
-
Workforce Demographic Equivalence: Statements like "4 men or 6 women or 10 children can complete a job in 20 days". You must find the rate of a mixed composite crew (2 men +3 women +5 children).
-
The Contractor Deadline Crisis: A contractor commits to completing a project in Dtarget days with M men. At an audit on Day Daudit, only a fraction of the work is complete. How many additional workers must be hired to avoid penalties?
3. The Single Tactical Weapon: The Master Proportionality Ratio
A. The Master Chain:
W1M1⋅D1⋅H1⋅E1=W2M2⋅D2⋅H2⋅E2
Where:
-
M: Number of workers
-
D: Number of days
-
H: Working hours per day
-
E: Relative efficiency per worker
-
W: Quantity of work (meters of trench, number of shirts, volume of earth moved)
B. The Demographic Equivalence Rule:
When given "a Men =b Women =c Children":
-
Find the LCM of a,b,c.
-
Express individual daily efficiencies as integers:
EM=aLCM,EW=bLCM,EC=cLCM
-
Replace any composite workforce with equivalent daily efficiency units:
Ecrew=m⋅EM+w⋅EW+k⋅EC
C. The Contractor Audit Shortcut:
In contractor problems, NEVER restart calculations from Day 0! Treat the audit day as the starting point:
WdoneMcurrent×Dpast=WremainingMnew×Dremaining
Solve for Mnew, then:
Additional Workers=Mnew−Mcurrent
4. The Classic Exam Trap & Speed Shortcut
The Inverted Work Trap:
The most frequent student mistake is writing M1D1H1W1=M2D2H2W2. Work W is the output, so it goes in the denominator!
The Dimensional Work Trap:
If a trench's dimensions double in length, width, and depth, the work does NOT double—it increases by 2×2×2=8 times! Always multiply all physical dimensions to find work W.
Formulas
| Master MDH Variation Chain | W1M1D1H1E1=W2M2D2H2E2 Universal proportionality relation connecting workforce, time, efficiency, and physical output. |
|---|
| Demographic Equivalence Efficiency | aEM=bEW=cEC⟹EM:EW:EC=a1:b1:c1 Transforms mixed gender/age workforces into unified efficiency units. |
|---|
| Contractor Remaining Work Balance | Mnew=M1×DremDpast×WdoneWrem Directly calculates required final team size from the audit date onwards. |
|---|
| Garrison Ration Balance | M1×D1=M2×D2 For constant total food supply, worker headcount is inversely proportional to surviving days. |
|---|
Traps and tips
- Always put the work quantity (or volume/mass/distance) in the denominator of the MDH fraction.
- When trench or wall dimensions change, multiply length × width × depth to find the total work volume.
- For contractor problems, isolate the past work and future work into two separate phases—never calculate from Day 0.
- In food ration problems, subtract elapsed days from the initial supply before altering the soldier count.
Solved examples
Example 1: Canal Excavation with Changing Dimensions & Hours
A team of 36 excavators working 7 hours a day can dig a drainage canal 140 meters long, 4 meters wide, and 2.5 meters deep in 18 days. How many days will it take for a team of 45 excavators working 8 hours a day to dig another canal that is 280 meters long, 5 meters wide, and 3 meters deep, assuming the soil composition is identical?
Show solution
Step 1: Calculate the work volume for both canals.
-
W1=140×4×2.5=1,400 m3
-
W2=280×5×3=4,200 m3
Notice that W1W2=1,4004,200=3.
Step 2: Apply the MDH formula.
W1M1⋅D1⋅H1=W2M2⋅D2⋅H2
1,40036×18×7=4,20045×D2×8
Step 3: Simplify and solve for D2.
136×18×7=345×D2×8
4536=15×D2×8=120D2
D2=1204536=37.8 days
Takeaway: Always compute the 3D volume of earth moved before applying MDH to avoid missing geometric scale factors.
Example 2: Demographic Equivalence (Men, Women, Boys)
A manufacturing unit can complete an export garment quota with either 6 men, 9 women, or 12 boys in 30 days. In how many days will the same quota be completed by a composite team consisting of 4 men, 6 women, and 8 boys working together?
Show solution
Step 1: Determine daily efficiency units using LCM.
6M=9W=12B
LCM(6,9,12)=36
-
Daily efficiency of 1 Man: EM=636=6 units/day
-
Daily efficiency of 1 Woman: EW=936=4 units/day
-
Daily efficiency of 1 Boy: EB=1236=3 units/day
Step 2: Calculate Total Work.
Using the 6 men benchmark:
Total Work W=(6×6)×30=36×30=1,080 units
(Verification using 12 boys: (12×3)×30=1,080 units).
Step 3: Calculate composite team efficiency.
Team Rate=(4×EM)+(6×EW)+(8×EB)
=(4×6)+(6×4)+(8×3)=24+24+24=72 units/day
Step 4: Compute completion days.
Days Required=721,080=15 days
Takeaway: Equate demographic groups to their LCM to convert mixed workforces into pure integer efficiency units.
Example 3: The Contractor Deadline Crisis
A highway contractor undertakes to pave a 24-kilometer stretch of expressway in 120 days and employs 80 workers. After 75 days, an engineering audit reveals that only 10 kilometers of the expressway have been paved. How many additional workers must the contractor hire immediately to finish the expressway strictly on schedule?
Show solution
Step 1: Segment into Past Work and Remaining Work.
-
Past Phase:
-
Workers: M1=80
-
Days worked: D1=75
-
Work done: W1=10 km
-
Future Phase:
-
Days remaining: D2=120−75=45 days
-
Work remaining: W2=24−10=14 km
-
Workers needed: M2=?
Step 2: Equate work-rate ratios for the two phases.
W1M1×D1=W2M2×D2
1080×75=14M2×45
Step 3: Solve for M2.
106,000=600=1445M2
M2=45600×14=458,400=3560≈186.67
Since human workers must be integers, the contractor must deploy at least 187 workers.
Step 4: Additional workers required.
Additional Workers=187−80=107 workers
Takeaway: Treat the audit point as a new starting line: compare past output rate directly against future requirements.
Example 4: Fort Garrison Rations with Reinforcements
A military outpost has food provisions sufficient for 600 soldiers for 45 days. After 15 days, a detachment of 300 additional soldiers arrives at the outpost. Assuming daily consumption per soldier remains constant, for how many more days will the remaining provisions last?
Show solution
Step 1: Calculate remaining food supply after 15 days.
Originally, the outpost had provisions for 600 soldiers for 45 days.
After 15 days, the remaining food would sustain the original 600 soldiers for:
Drem=45−15=30 days
Remaining Food Supply=600×30=18,000 soldier-days
Step 2: Adjust headcount.
300 additional soldiers arrive:
Mnew=600+300=900 soldiers
Step 3: Find days remaining.
D=MnewRemaining Soldier-Days=90018,000=20 days
Takeaway: In ration problems, immediately deduct elapsed days from total supply before modifying the headcount.
Example 5: Mixed Workforce Algebraic Equations
A boutique artisanal workshop employs men and women. 3 men and 4 women can complete a complex weaving order in 16 days. Meanwhile, 4 men and 3 women can complete the same order in 14 days. Find: (1) The ratio of the daily work done by a man to that of a woman, and (2) The number of days taken by 1 man and 1 woman working together to complete the order.
Show solution
Step 1: Set up the total work equality.
Total Work W=(3M+4W)×16=(4M+3W)×14
48M+64W=56M+42W
64W−42W=56M−48M
22W=8M⟹11W=4M
WM=411
Thus, the daily work ratio of 1 man to 1 woman is 11:4.
Step 2: Assign unit efficiencies.
Let EM=11 units/day and EW=4 units/day.
Step 3: Compute Total Work.
W=(3×11+4×4)×16=(33+16)×16=49×16=784 units
Step 4: Find time for 1 man and 1 woman.
Epair=11+4=15 units/day
T=15784=52154 days≈52.27 days
Takeaway: Equate two given team descriptions to derive the fundamental individual efficiency ratio M : W .
Example 6: Automated Assembly Line with Machine Downtime
In an automated electronic assembly plant, 12 robotic arms operating 7 hours per day assemble 4,200 microprocessors in 10 days. The plant upgrades to newer models that have 20% higher efficiency, but due to factory power rationing, each arm can only run for 6 hours per day. How many such upgraded robotic arms are required to assemble 7,560 microprocessors in 15 days?
Show solution
Step 1: Define relative efficiencies.
Let the baseline efficiency of the original robotic arm be E1=1.0.
The upgraded arm is 20% more efficient: E2=1.20=56.
Step 2: Apply the full MDHE / W formula.
W1M1⋅D1⋅H1⋅E1=W2M2⋅D2⋅H2⋅E2
4,20012×10×7×1.0=7,560M2×15×6×1.2
Step 3: Simplify both sides.
Left Hand Side=4,200840=51=0.2
7,560M2×108=0.2
M2×108=0.2×7,560=1,512
M2=1081,512=14 robotic arms
Takeaway: When machine efficiency scales alongside time and output, insert the multiplier factor directly into MDHE/W.
Practice questions
Question 1 · CAT Level
A infrastructure contractor undertakes to complete a project in 100 days using 60 skilled workers working 8 hours per day. After 50 days, an audit reveals that only 31 of the project is completed. To finish the remaining 32 strictly on schedule (in the remaining 50 days), the daily shift is increased to 10 hours per day, and the existing skilled workers are augmented by hiring additional semi-skilled workers whose individual efficiency is 75% of a skilled worker. How many semi-skilled workers must be hired?
- A
- B
- C
- D
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (C) 48
Work completed in the first 50 days: W1=60×50×8×1.0=24,000 units.
Since W1=31Wtotal, remaining work W2=32Wtotal=48,000 units.
In the next 50 days at 10 h/day, the 60 skilled workers produce: 60×50×10×1.0=30,000 units.
The deficit to be covered by semi-skilled workers is 48,000−30,000=18,000 units.
Each semi-skilled worker produces 50×10×0.75=375 units over the remaining period.
Therefore, number of semi-skilled workers required =37518,000=48.
Question 2 · CAT Level
A production order can be completed by 2 men and 3 women in 10 days, or by 3 men and 2 women in 8 days. A boy's daily working efficiency is exactly 50% of that of a woman. If 2 men and 1 woman start working on the order and work for 5 days, after which 1 man leaves and 3 boys join the remaining workforce, in how many additional days will the entire order be completed?
- A
- B
- C
- D
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (B) 10 days
Equating total work: (2M+3W)×10=(3M+2W)×8⟹20M+30W=24M+16W⟹4M=14W⟹WM=27.
Let EM=7 units/day, EW=2 units/day, and EB=0.5×2=1 unit/day.
Total work W=(2×7+3×2)×10=20×10=200 units.
Phase 1 (5 days): Rate =2(7)+1(2)=16 units/day⟹Work done=5×16=80 units; remaining =120 units.
Phase 2: Workforce is 1M+1W+3B⟹Rate=1(7)+1(2)+3(1)=12 units/day.
Additional days required =12120=10 days.
Question 3 · CAT Level
A military outpost has provisions sufficient for 1,200 soldiers for 70 days, with each soldier consuming 900 grams daily. After 20 days, 300 additional soldiers arrive at the fort, and the daily ration per soldier is simultaneously reduced to 750 grams. After 20 days under this new regime, 500 soldiers are evacuated to another post. If rations remain at 750 grams per soldier, for how many further days from the evacuation date will the remaining food supply last?
- A
- B
- C
- D
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (C) 42 days
At Day 20, remaining food for 1,200 soldiers is for 50 days at 900 g/day: 1,200×50×900=54,000,000 g.
Under 1,500 soldiers at 750 g/day, daily burn is 1,125,000 g/day, so food would last 1,125,00054,000,000=48 days.
After 20 days of this regime, food remaining for 1,500 soldiers equals 48−20=28 days of consumption.
When 500 soldiers are evacuated, the surviving garrison becomes 1,500−500=1,000 soldiers.
By inverse proportionality: D=28×1,0001,500=28×1.5=42 days.
Question 4 · CAT Level
A fleet of 24 automated paving machines operating 8 hours per day can lay a road of length 18 km, width 12 m, and thickness 15 cm in 25 days. A second contract requires laying a road of length 27 km, width 16 m, and thickness 20 cm in 32 days. If upgraded paving machines with 25% higher individual efficiency are deployed and operated for 10 hours per day, how many upgraded machines are required?
- A
- B
- C
- D
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (C) 32
Calculate volume ratio: W1W2=18×12×1527×16×20=23×34×34=38.
Given efficiency ratio E1E2=1.25=45, apply the universal variation chain: W1M1D1H1E1=W2M2D2H2E2.
Rearranging: M2=M1×(D2D1)×(H2H1)×(E2E1)×(W1W2).
Substituting: M2=24×(3225)×(108)×(54)×(38).
Simplifying: M2=24×(3225×2516)×38=24×21×38=32 machines.
Question 5 · CAT Level
A software firm estimates that a group of developers can build an enterprise platform in 30 days working standard 8-hour shifts. However, at the end of every 10 days, exactly 8 developers leave the project. To compensate for the shrinking team, starting from Day 21, the remaining developers increase their daily shift length by 20% (from 8 hours to 9.6 hours). If the entire platform is completed in exactly 40 days, how many developers originally started the project on Day 1?
- A
- B
- C
- D
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (C) 40
Let N be the initial developers. Total work W=30N developer-days at the standard 8 h/day rate.
Days 1–10 (1.0× rate): W1=10N units.
Days 11–20 (1.0× rate): N−8 developers work ⟹W2=10(N−8)=10N−80 units.
Days 21–30 (1.2× rate): N−16 developers work ⟹W3=10×1.2(N−16)=12N−192 units.
Days 31–40 (1.2× rate): N−24 developers work ⟹W4=10×1.2(N−24)=12N−288 units.
Summing work done: 10N+(10N−80)+(12N−192)+(12N−288)=44N−560=30N⟹14N=560⟹N=40.
Try real CAT questions