Free CAT library

Work Rate, Efficiency Units & The LCM Method

Master the foundational Work = Rate × Time equation, transition from fractional unitary arithmetic to the integer LCM efficiency method, and seamlessly solve segmented timelines with staggered joins, departures, and virtual work shortcuts.

1. The Story & Mental Model: The Lego Block Factory

Imagine an engineering manager assigning tasks to software engineers or factory robots. If you measure work as "11 whole project", you force yourself into fractional hell:

Daily Work=118+124+136\text{Daily Work} = \frac{1}{18} + \frac{1}{24} + \frac{1}{36}

Adding fractions with disparate denominators under exam pressure leads to transcription blunders and wasted time.

Now imagine replacing the abstract "11 project" with a tangible crate of Lego bricks or story points. If Dev A takes 1818 days, Dev B takes 2424 days, and Dev C takes 3636 days, we choose the total number of bricks to be the Least Common Multiple (LCM) of 18,24,3618, 24, 36, which is 7272 units.

  • Dev A snaps into place 7218=4\frac{72}{18} = 4 bricks every day.

  • Dev B snaps into place 7224=3\frac{72}{24} = 3 bricks every day.

  • Dev C snaps into place 7236=2\frac{72}{36} = 2 bricks every day.

Together, they assemble 4+3+2=94 + 3 + 2 = 9 bricks every day. To assemble all 7272 bricks, it takes 729=8\frac{72}{9} = 8 days. Clean, instantaneous integer arithmetic!


2. The CAT Question Blueprint: The Segmented Sprint

CAT and IPMAT exam setters disguise work-rate problems in five high-yield patterns:

  1. Parallel Teamwork: Two or three agents working simultaneously until completion.

  2. Staggered Joins: Worker A starts alone; Worker B joins after kk days.

  3. Early Exits: Worker B quits dd days before the scheduled completion.

  4. Dynamic Efficiency Throttling: A worker falls ill or a server throttles, operating at 23\frac{2}{3} or 75%75\% of normal capacity.

  5. Pairwise Overlap Equations: You are given combined rates of (A+B),(B+C),(C+A)(A+B), (B+C), (C+A) and must isolate individual times.


3. The Single Tactical Weapon: The LCM Framework & Virtual Work

A. The Master Equation:

Work=Efficiency×Time  ⟺  W=E×T\text{Work} = \text{Efficiency} \times \text{Time} \iff W = E \times T

Total Work W=LCM(T1,T2,T3,… )\text{Total Work } W = \text{LCM}(T_1, T_2, T_3, \dots)

Ei=WTi,Tcombined=W∑EiE_i = \frac{W}{T_i}, \quad T_{\text{combined}} = \frac{W}{\sum E_i}

B. The Inverse Law of Time and Efficiency:

For a fixed quantity of work WW:

E∝1T  ⟹  EAEB=TBTAE \propto \frac{1}{T} \implies \frac{E_A}{E_B} = \frac{T_B}{T_A}

If EA:EB=m:nE_A : E_B = m : n, then TA:TB=n:mT_A : T_B = n : m.

C. Percentage Shift Invariance:

  • "A is 25%25\% more efficient than B"   ⟺  EA=1.25EB=54EB  ⟺  TA=45TB\iff E_A = 1.25 E_B = \frac{5}{4} E_B \iff T_A = \frac{4}{5} T_B (A takes 20%20\% less time than B).

  • "A is x%x\% more efficient than B"   ⟹  \implies Time taken is x100+x×100%\frac{x}{100 + x} \times 100\% less.

D. The Virtual Work Shortcut (Worker Quitting kk Days Before Finish):

When worker B leaves kk days before the finish line, do NOT create complex algebraic equations with unknown time tt. Instead, pretend Worker B never left and worked the final kk days!

Virtual Work=Wactual+(EB×k)\text{Virtual Work} = W_{\text{actual}} + (E_B \times k)

Total Duration T=Wactual+(EB×k)EA+EB\text{Total Duration } T = \frac{W_{\text{actual}} + (E_B \times k)}{E_A + E_B}


4. The Classic Exam Trap & Speed Shortcut

The Percentage Trap:

"AA is 50%50\% more efficient than BB" does NOT mean "AA takes 50%50\% less time than BB".

If EA=1.5EB=32EBE_A = 1.5 E_B = \frac{3}{2} E_B, then TA=23TBT_A = \frac{2}{3} T_B, which is 3313%33\frac{1}{3}\% less time!

The Fallacy of Averaging Times:

If Dev A takes 1010 days and Dev B takes 2020 days, together they NEVER take 10+202=15\frac{10 + 20}{2} = 15 days! Parallel work reduces time: 10×2010+20=20030=6.67\frac{10 \times 20}{10 + 20} = \frac{200}{30} = 6.67 days.

Formulas

Fundamental Work Equation

W=E×T  ⟺  E=WT  ⟺  T=WEW = E \times T \iff E = \frac{W}{T} \iff T = \frac{W}{E}

Core linear relationship linking total output, rate of work, and duration.
LCM Total Work Definition

W=LCM(T1,T2,…,Tn)W = \text{LCM}(T_1, T_2, \dots, T_n)

Transforms fractional work rates into clean, non-negative integers.
Two-Worker Shortcut

TAB=TA×TBTA+TBT_{AB} = \frac{T_A \times T_B}{T_A + T_B}

Harmonic product-over-sum for two parallel workers.
Virtual Work Shortcut

Ttotal=Wactual+Edeparting×k∑ET_{\text{total}} = \frac{W_{\text{actual}} + E_{\text{departing}} \times k}{\sum E}

For a worker departing k days before completion, add virtual work and divide by combined efficiency.
Pairwise Cyclic Efficiency Sum

EA+EB+EC=EA+B+EB+C+EC+A2E_A + E_B + E_C = \frac{E_{A+B} + E_{B+C} + E_{C+A}}{2}

Divides sum of pairwise combinations by 2 to isolate individual contributions.

Traps and tips

  • Always define Total Work as the LCM of given times to eliminate fractional addition under time limits.
  • An increase of +1/n in efficiency corresponds to a reduction of -1/(n+1) in time taken.
  • For a worker leaving k days before completion, use Virtual Work: add their missing output to total work and keep them active for the full period.
  • When pairwise rates are given (A+B, B+C, C+A), sum all three rates and divide by 2 to find the combined rate of A+B+C.

Solved examples

Example 1: Legacy Monolith Refactoring (Staggered Join & Early Exit)

Three backend engineers—A, B, and C—can independently refactor an application in 18, 24, and 36 days respectively. All three start working together. After 3 days, Engineer A is pulled off to handle a production bug. Engineers B and C continue together, but Engineer B leaves the project 3 days before its actual completion. Engineer C finishes the remaining refactoring alone. Find the total number of days taken to complete the refactoring.

Show solution

Step 1: Set Total Work using LCM.

Total Work W=LCM(18,24,36)=72 units\text{Total Work } W = \text{LCM}(18, 24, 36) = 72 \text{ units}

Step 2: Calculate daily efficiencies.

  • EA=7218=4 units/dayE_A = \frac{72}{18} = 4 \text{ units/day}

  • EB=7224=3 units/dayE_B = \frac{72}{24} = 3 \text{ units/day}

  • EC=7236=2 units/dayE_C = \frac{72}{36} = 2 \text{ units/day}

Step 3: Track work completed in Phase 1 (First 3 days).

All three work together for 3 days:

EA+B+C=4+3+2=9 units/dayE_{A+B+C} = 4 + 3 + 2 = 9 \text{ units/day}

W1=3×9=27 unitsW_1 = 3 \times 9 = 27 \text{ units}

Remaining Work Wrem=72−27=45 units\text{Remaining Work } W_{\text{rem}} = 72 - 27 = 45 \text{ units}

Step 4: Use Virtual Work for remaining phase (B and C).

Engineer B leaves 3 days before completion. During those final 3 days, B missed out on producing:

Virtual Work of B=3 days×3 units/day=9 units\text{Virtual Work of B} = 3 \text{ days} \times 3 \text{ units/day} = 9 \text{ units}

Adjusted Remaining Work=45+9=54 units\text{Adjusted Remaining Work} = 45 + 9 = 54 \text{ units}

Both B and C work together at rate EB+EC=3+2=5 units/dayE_B + E_C = 3 + 2 = 5 \text{ units/day}:

T2=545=10.8 daysT_2 = \frac{54}{5} = 10.8 \text{ days}

Step 5: Calculate total duration.

Total Days=T1+T2=3+10.8=13.8 days=1345 days\text{Total Days} = T_1 + T_2 = 3 + 10.8 = 13.8 \text{ days} = 13 \frac{4}{5} \text{ days}

Takeaway: The Virtual Work method converts complicated end-of-project departures into a clean single-step division.

Example 2: AI Cluster Training with Thermal Throttling

Compute Cluster Alpha is 60%60\% more efficient than Compute Cluster Beta. Working together at full rated speed, Alpha and Beta can complete a neural network training job in 25 hours. Cluster Beta starts training alone for 10 hours. Then Cluster Alpha joins; however, due to thermal throttling, Cluster Alpha can only operate at 75%75\% of its rated efficiency, while Cluster Beta throttles to 80%80\% of its rated capacity. How many additional hours will be needed to complete the training run?

Show solution

Step 1: Express rated efficiencies as integer units.

Alpha is 60%60\% more efficient than Beta:

EαEβ=1+0.60=85\frac{E_\alpha}{E_\beta} = 1 + 0.60 = \frac{8}{5}

Let Eβ=5 units/hE_\beta = 5 \text{ units/h} and Eα=8 units/hE_\alpha = 8 \text{ units/h}.

Combined rated efficiency:

Etotal=8+5=13 units/hE_{\text{total}} = 8 + 5 = 13 \text{ units/h}

Step 2: Calculate total training work.

Total Work W=13 units/h×25 hours=325 units\text{Total Work } W = 13 \text{ units/h} \times 25 \text{ hours} = 325 \text{ units}

Step 3: Initial run by Cluster Beta.

Beta runs alone at full rated speed for 10 hours:

W1=10×5=50 unitsW_1 = 10 \times 5 = 50 \text{ units}

Remaining Work Wrem=325−50=275 units\text{Remaining Work } W_{\text{rem}} = 325 - 50 = 275 \text{ units}

Step 4: Compute throttled efficiencies.

  • Eα′=75% of 8=34×8=6 units/hE_\alpha' = 75\% \text{ of } 8 = \frac{3}{4} \times 8 = 6 \text{ units/h}

  • Eβ′=80% of 5=45×5=4 units/hE_\beta' = 80\% \text{ of } 5 = \frac{4}{5} \times 5 = 4 \text{ units/h}

Ejoint′=6+4=10 units/hE_{\text{joint}}' = 6 + 4 = 10 \text{ units/h}

Step 5: Additional hours needed.

Tadditional=27510=27.5 hoursT_{\text{additional}} = \frac{275}{10} = 27.5 \text{ hours}

Takeaway: Scale unit definitions so that fractional efficiency throttles remain clean integers throughout the solution.

Example 3: Pairwise Work Combinations (A+B, B+C, C+A)

Two cloud microservices working in pairs process a batch of financial transactions. Services A and B together take 12 minutes; Services B and C together take 15 minutes; Services C and A together take 20 minutes. Find: (1) The time taken if all three services run simultaneously, and (2) The time taken if Service A runs alone.

Show solution

Step 1: Find Total Work via LCM.

Total Work W=LCM(12,15,20)=60 units\text{Total Work } W = \text{LCM}(12, 15, 20) = 60 \text{ units}

Step 2: Calculate pairwise efficiencies.

  • EA+EB=6012=5 units/minE_A + E_B = \frac{60}{12} = 5 \text{ units/min}

  • EB+EC=6015=4 units/minE_B + E_C = \frac{60}{15} = 4 \text{ units/min}

  • EC+EA=6020=3 units/minE_C + E_A = \frac{60}{20} = 3 \text{ units/min}

Step 3: Sum all three equations to find combined efficiency.

2(EA+EB+EC)=5+4+3=122(E_A + E_B + E_C) = 5 + 4 + 3 = 12

EA+EB+EC=122=6 units/minE_A + E_B + E_C = \frac{12}{2} = 6 \text{ units/min}

Step 4: Solve for simultaneous execution.

TA+B+C=606=10 minutesT_{A+B+C} = \frac{60}{6} = 10 \text{ minutes}

Step 5: Isolate Service A's efficiency and solo time.

EA=(EA+EB+EC)−(EB+EC)=6−4=2 units/minE_A = (E_A + E_B + E_C) - (E_B + E_C) = 6 - 4 = 2 \text{ units/min}

TA=602=30 minutesT_A = \frac{60}{2} = 30 \text{ minutes}

Takeaway: Add pairwise equations to get twice the total sum, then subtract the opposing pair to isolate any individual rate in seconds.

Example 4: Double Early Departure via Virtual Work

Three artisans—X, Y, and Z—can carve an architectural installation in 10, 12, and 15 days respectively. They begin working together, but Artisan X leaves 2 days before the project is completed, and Artisan Y leaves 3 days before the project is completed. Artisan Z works until the very end. What was the total number of days taken to finish the installation?

Show solution

Step 1: Set Total Work using LCM.

Total Work W=LCM(10,12,15)=60 units\text{Total Work } W = \text{LCM}(10, 12, 15) = 60 \text{ units}

Step 2: Find individual efficiencies.

  • EX=6010=6 units/dayE_X = \frac{60}{10} = 6 \text{ units/day}

  • EY=6012=5 units/dayE_Y = \frac{60}{12} = 5 \text{ units/day}

  • EZ=6015=4 units/dayE_Z = \frac{60}{15} = 4 \text{ units/day}

Etotal=6+5+4=15 units/dayE_{\text{total}} = 6 + 5 + 4 = 15 \text{ units/day}

Step 3: Apply the Virtual Work Principle.

Let TT be the total project duration. Neither X nor Y stayed until the end:

  • X left 2 days early   ⟹  \implies missed 2×6=12 units2 \times 6 = 12 \text{ units}

  • Y left 3 days early   ⟹  \implies missed 3×5=15 units3 \times 5 = 15 \text{ units}

Add both deficits to the total work:

Wvirtual=60+12+15=87 unitsW_{\text{virtual}} = 60 + 12 + 15 = 87 \text{ units}

Step 4: Divide virtual work by full team efficiency.

Now all three workers are considered active for the entire duration TT:

T=WvirtualEtotal=8715=5.8 days=545 daysT = \frac{W_{\text{virtual}}}{E_{\text{total}}} = \frac{87}{15} = 5.8 \text{ days} = 5 \frac{4}{5} \text{ days}

Takeaway: Whenever multiple workers leave before completion, add all their missing output to create virtual work and divide by the combined team rate.

Example 5: Percentage Time Reduction & Solo Work

Senior Developer Priya takes 30%30\% less time than Junior Developer Rohan to complete a microservice integration. Working together, they can complete the integration in 21 days. How many days would Rohan take to complete the entire integration working alone?

Show solution

Step 1: Convert time percentage into efficiency ratio.

Let time taken by Rohan be TRT_R. Priya takes 30%30\% less time:

TP=(1−0.30)TR=0.7TR=710TRT_P = (1 - 0.30) T_R = 0.7 T_R = \frac{7}{10} T_R

Since efficiency is inversely proportional to time:

EPER=TRTP=107\frac{E_P}{E_R} = \frac{T_R}{T_P} = \frac{10}{7}

Let EP=10 units/dayE_P = 10 \text{ units/day} and ER=7 units/dayE_R = 7 \text{ units/day}.

Step 2: Calculate total work from combined rate.

Combined daily efficiency:

Ecombined=10+7=17 units/dayE_{\text{combined}} = 10 + 7 = 17 \text{ units/day}

Total Work W=17 units/day×21 days=357 units\text{Total Work } W = 17 \text{ units/day} \times 21 \text{ days} = 357 \text{ units}

Step 3: Compute Rohan's solo time.

TR=WER=3577=51 daysT_R = \frac{W}{E_R} = \frac{357}{7} = 51 \text{ days}

Takeaway: Always flip the time ratio to obtain the efficiency ratio before calculating total units of work.

Example 6: Dynamic Incremental Efficiency Optimization

A manufacturing contractor takes on a job of 480 units. On Day 1, the plant produces at a baseline rate of 20 units/day. Due to process optimizations, the plant's daily efficiency increases by 25%25\% after every 4 completed working days (i.e. days 1-4 at 20 units/day, days 5-8 at 25 units/day, etc.). In how many days will the entire job be completed?

Show solution

Step 1: Track work done in 4-day blocks.

  • Block 1 (Days 1 to 4):

    Rate=20 units/day  ⟹  W1=4×20=80 units\text{Rate} = 20 \text{ units/day} \implies W_1 = 4 \times 20 = 80 \text{ units}

    Cumulative Work=80 units,Remaining=480−80=400 units\text{Cumulative Work} = 80 \text{ units}, \quad \text{Remaining} = 480 - 80 = 400 \text{ units}

  • Block 2 (Days 5 to 8):

    Rate=20×1.25=25 units/day  ⟹  W2=4×25=100 units\text{Rate} = 20 \times 1.25 = 25 \text{ units/day} \implies W_2 = 4 \times 25 = 100 \text{ units}

    Cumulative Work=80+100=180 units,Remaining=480−180=300 units\text{Cumulative Work} = 80 + 100 = 180 \text{ units}, \quad \text{Remaining} = 480 - 180 = 300 \text{ units}

  • Block 3 (Days 9 to 12):

    Rate=25×1.25=31.25 units/day  ⟹  W3=4×31.25=125 units\text{Rate} = 25 \times 1.25 = 31.25 \text{ units/day} \implies W_3 = 4 \times 31.25 = 125 \text{ units}

    Cumulative Work=180+125=305 units,Remaining=480−305=175 units\text{Cumulative Work} = 180 + 125 = 305 \text{ units}, \quad \text{Remaining} = 480 - 305 = 175 \text{ units}

  • Block 4 (Days 13 to 16):

    Rate=31.25×1.25=39.0625 units/day  ⟹  W4=4×39.0625=156.25 units\text{Rate} = 31.25 \times 1.25 = 39.0625 \text{ units/day} \implies W_4 = 4 \times 39.0625 = 156.25 \text{ units}

    Cumulative Work=305+156.25=461.25 units,Remaining=480−461.25=18.75 units\text{Cumulative Work} = 305 + 156.25 = 461.25 \text{ units}, \quad \text{Remaining} = 480 - 461.25 = 18.75 \text{ units}

Step 2: Compute final partial day.

At the start of Day 17, the rate scales again:

Rate for Block 5=39.0625×1.25=48.828125 units/day\text{Rate for Block 5} = 39.0625 \times 1.25 = 48.828125 \text{ units/day}

Days needed for 18.75 units=18.7548.828125=18.7539.0625×1.25=18.7548.828125=2462.5=0.384 days\text{Days needed for 18.75 units} = \frac{18.75}{48.828125} = \frac{18.75}{39.0625 \times 1.25} = \frac{18.75}{48.828125} = \frac{24}{62.5} = 0.384 \text{ days}

Total Days=16+18.7548.828125≈16.38 days\text{Total Days} = 16 + \frac{18.75}{48.828125} \approx 16.38 \text{ days}

Takeaway: For variable-rate processes, track cumulative output block-by-block and evaluate the final fractional day using the upgraded rate.

Practice questions

Question 1 · CAT Level

Two software developers, Ananya and Brijesh, can complete a codebase migration working together in 2424 days. If Ananya works at 80%80\% of her normal efficiency and Brijesh works at 125%125\% of his normal efficiency, the migration still takes exactly 2424 days. Ananya begins the migration alone and works for 88 days, after which Brijesh and a new intern, Chetan, join her. If Chetan's efficiency is 50%50\% of Brijesh's normal efficiency, how many additional days will the team require to complete the migration?

  1. A

    1414 days

  2. B

    1616 days

  3. C

    1818 days

  4. D

    2020 days

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) 16 days

Since total time remains 2424 days under changed efficiencies, daily output is invariant: 0.80EA+1.25EB=EA+EB  ⟹  0.25EB=0.20EA  ⟹  EAEB=540.80 E_A + 1.25 E_B = E_A + E_B \implies 0.25 E_B = 0.20 E_A \implies \frac{E_A}{E_B} = \frac{5}{4}.

Let EA=5 units/dayE_A = 5\text{ units/day} and EB=4 units/dayE_B = 4\text{ units/day}, giving total work W=(5+4)×24=216 unitsW = (5 + 4) \times 24 = 216\text{ units}.

In the first 88 days, Ananya completes 8×5=40 units8 \times 5 = 40\text{ units}, leaving 216−40=176 units216 - 40 = 176\text{ units}.

Chetan's efficiency is EC=0.50×4=2 units/dayE_C = 0.50 \times 4 = 2\text{ units/day}, so the new combined efficiency is EA+B+C=5+4+2=11 units/dayE_{A+B+C} = 5 + 4 + 2 = 11\text{ units/day}.

Therefore, additional days required =17611=16 days= \frac{176}{11} = 16\text{ days}.

Question 2 · CAT Level

Working alone, developer A takes 1818 days more than the time taken by A and B working together to complete a project, while developer B takes 88 days more than the time taken by A and B working together. A third specialist, C, can complete the entire project alone in 2424 days. All three developers begin working together, but A leaves 66 days before project completion and B leaves 11 day before completion, with C working until the end. What is the total number of days taken to finish the project?

  1. A

    99 days

  2. B

    1010 days

  3. C

    11.511.5 days

  4. D

    1212 days

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) 10 days

By the excess-time formula, TA+B=18×8=144=12 daysT_{A+B} = \sqrt{18 \times 8} = \sqrt{144} = 12\text{ days}, so TA=12+18=30 daysT_A = 12 + 18 = 30\text{ days} and TB=12+8=20 daysT_B = 12 + 8 = 20\text{ days}.

Given TC=24 daysT_C = 24\text{ days}, let total work W=LCM(30,20,24)=120 unitsW = \text{LCM}(30, 20, 24) = 120\text{ units}.

Individual efficiencies are EA=12030=4E_A = \frac{120}{30} = 4, EB=12020=6E_B = \frac{120}{20} = 6, and EC=12024=5 units/dayE_C = \frac{120}{24} = 5\text{ units/day}, yielding Etotal=15 units/dayE_{\text{total}} = 15\text{ units/day}.

Using the Virtual Work method, add the work missed by early departures: Wvirtual=120+(6×4)+(1×6)=120+24+6=150 unitsW_{\text{virtual}} = 120 + (6 \times 4) + (1 \times 6) = 120 + 24 + 6 = 150\text{ units}.

Total project duration =WvirtualEtotal=15015=10 days= \frac{W_{\text{virtual}}}{E_{\text{total}}} = \frac{150}{15} = 10\text{ days}.

Question 3 · CAT Level

If worker A works for 44 days and worker B works for 99 days, they complete exactly 50%50\% of a project. If worker A works for 1010 days and worker B works for 66 days, they complete exactly 70%70\% of the project. If a third worker C joins A and B, the trio working together can complete the entire project in 66 days. How many days would worker C take to complete the entire project working alone at 80%80\% of his normal efficiency?

  1. A

    1212 days

  2. B

    1515 days

  3. C

    1818 days

  4. D

    2020 days

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) 15 days

Let WW be total work. We have 4EA+9EB=0.50W4 E_A + 9 E_B = 0.50 W and 10EA+6EB=0.70W10 E_A + 6 E_B = 0.70 W.

Multiplying the first by 22 gives 8EA+18EB=W8 E_A + 18 E_B = W, and multiplying the second by 33 gives 30EA+18EB=2.10W30 E_A + 18 E_B = 2.10 W.

Subtracting yields 22EA=1.10W  ⟹  EA=W2022 E_A = 1.10 W \implies E_A = \frac{W}{20}, and substituting back gives EB=W30E_B = \frac{W}{30}.

For W=60 unitsW = 60\text{ units}, EA=3E_A = 3, EB=2E_B = 2. With C, combined rate =606=10 units/day  ⟹  EC=10−5=5 units/day= \frac{60}{6} = 10\text{ units/day} \implies E_C = 10 - 5 = 5\text{ units/day}.

At 80%80\% efficiency, EC′=0.80×5=4 units/dayE_C' = 0.80 \times 5 = 4\text{ units/day}, so solo time =604=15 days= \frac{60}{4} = 15\text{ days}.

Question 4 · CAT Level

Technician X is 20%20\% more efficient than Technician Y, who is in turn 25%25\% more efficient than Technician Z. Working together at their baseline efficiencies, the three technicians deploy 1515 server instances per hour. They are assigned to deploy 540540 instances starting together. After 66 hours, X's efficiency drops by 1623%16\frac{2}{3}\%. After another 66 hours (hour 12), Y's efficiency drops by 20%20\%. After another 66 hours (hour 18), Z's efficiency drops by 25%25\%. All continue at these reduced rates until completion. What is the total time (in hours) to deploy all 540540 instances?

  1. A

    3838 hours

  2. B

    4040 hours

  3. C

    4242 hours

  4. D

    4545 hours

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (C) 42 hours

Efficiency ratio: EZ=100  ⟹  EY=125  ⟹  EX=1.20×125=150E_Z = 100 \implies E_Y = 125 \implies E_X = 1.20 \times 125 = 150, so EX:EY:EZ=6:5:4E_X : E_Y : E_Z = 6 : 5 : 4.

Since baseline combined rate is 6+5+4=15 units/h6 + 5 + 4 = 15\text{ units/h}, total work is 540 units540\text{ units}.

Phase 1 (Hours 1–6): Rate =15 units/h  ⟹  6×15=90 units= 15\text{ units/h} \implies 6 \times 15 = 90\text{ units}; remaining =450 units= 450\text{ units}.

Phase 2 (Hours 7–12): EX′=5E_X' = 5, rate =5+5+4=14 units/h  ⟹  6×14=84 units= 5 + 5 + 4 = 14\text{ units/h} \implies 6 \times 14 = 84\text{ units}; remaining =366 units= 366\text{ units}.

Phase 3 (Hours 13–18): EY′=4E_Y' = 4, rate =5+4+4=13 units/h  ⟹  6×13=78 units= 5 + 4 + 4 = 13\text{ units/h} \implies 6 \times 13 = 78\text{ units}; remaining =288 units= 288\text{ units}.

Phase 4 (After hour 18): EZ′=3E_Z' = 3, rate =5+4+3=12 units/h  ⟹  28812=24 hours= 5 + 4 + 3 = 12\text{ units/h} \implies \frac{288}{12} = 24\text{ hours}. Total time =18+24=42 hours= 18 + 24 = 42\text{ hours}.

Question 5 · CAT Level

Contractors P and Q working together can pave a road in 1212 days, while Q and R working together can pave it in 1616 days. To execute the work, P worked alone for 55 days, then Q worked alone for 77 days, and finally R worked alone for 1313 days to finish the road. If all three contractors were instead to work together from the very start, but P leaves 22 days before completion and Q leaves 33 days before completion (with R working till the end), how many total days would the paving take?

  1. A

    88 days

  2. B

    8.58.5 days

  3. C

    9.59.5 days

  4. D

    10.510.5 days

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (C) 9.5 days

Let total work W=LCM(12,16)=48 unitsW = \text{LCM}(12, 16) = 48\text{ units}. Then EP+EQ=4 units/dayE_P + E_Q = 4\text{ units/day} and EQ+ER=3 units/dayE_Q + E_R = 3\text{ units/day}.

Decompose the initial timeline: 5EP+7EQ+13ER=5(EP+EQ)+2(EQ+ER)+11ER=485 E_P + 7 E_Q + 13 E_R = 5(E_P + E_Q) + 2(E_Q + E_R) + 11 E_R = 48.

Substituting gives 5(4)+2(3)+11ER=48  ⟹  26+11ER=48  ⟹  ER=2 units/day5(4) + 2(3) + 11 E_R = 48 \implies 26 + 11 E_R = 48 \implies E_R = 2\text{ units/day}.

Then EQ=3−2=1 unit/dayE_Q = 3 - 2 = 1\text{ unit/day} and EP=4−1=3 units/dayE_P = 4 - 1 = 3\text{ units/day}, so combined Etotal=3+1+2=6 units/dayE_{\text{total}} = 3 + 1 + 2 = 6\text{ units/day}.

With early departures, virtual work Wvirtual=48+(2×3)+(3×1)=57 unitsW_{\text{virtual}} = 48 + (2 \times 3) + (3 \times 1) = 57\text{ units}. Total duration =576=9.5 days= \frac{57}{6} = 9.5\text{ days}.

Try real CAT questions

Study this concept with interactive practice in PrepSoc.

Open the concept library