Alternate Working Days & Cyclic Step Sequencing
Master cyclic work scheduling where agents work on alternating days, compute complete repeating blocks, handle delicate final-day remainders, and analyze sensitivity to the starting worker.
1. The Story & Mental Model: The Repeating Carousel
Imagine two painters, Vikram and Anita, sharing a single specialized paintbrush. Vikram paints on Day 1, Anita paints on Day 2, Vikram returns on Day 3, Anita on Day 4, and so on.
Instead of analyzing each day individually, group the days into Repeating Super-Cycles:
-
In a 2-day cycle, the total work completed is:
Wcycle=EVikram+EAnita
-
A 2-day cycle acts as a single predictable engine. If the project requires 50 units and one 2-day cycle delivers 7 units, you know that 7 complete cycles (14 days) will deliver 49 units without any doubt.
The only critical thinking required is on the final residual unit. Who paints on Day 15? Vikram does! Since Vikram paints 4 units/day, he knocks out that final 1 unit in exactly 41 of a day. Total time: 14.25 days.
2. The CAT Question Blueprint: The Traps Exam Setters Lay
Exam setters design alternating day problems around three specific pressure points:
-
Starting Person Sensitivity: Answering whether the task finishes faster if Worker A starts versus Worker B.
-
Three-Person Rotations: Cyclic order A→B→C→A… where the remainder spills across multiple partial days.
-
The Slipping Monkey / Demolition Variant: Worker A builds on Day 1 (+E), but Worker B demolishes on Day 2 (−E). If the target height is reached at any point on an odd day, the job is DONE—Worker B never gets to demolish!
3. The Single Tactical Weapon: The 4-Step Cyclic Algorithm
Step 1: Compute Total Work via LCM:
W=LCM(TA,TB,TC)
Determine individual integer daily efficiencies EA,EB,EC.
Step 2: Determine Cycle Period and Output:
-
For two workers alternating: Cycle length L=2 days, Wcycle=EA+EB.
-
For three workers alternating: Cycle length L=3 days, Wcycle=EA+EB+EC.
Step 3: Find Complete Cycles:
k=⌊WcycleW⌋
Work Completed in Full Cycles=k×Wcycle
Time Elapsed in Full Cycles=k×L days
Remainder Work R=W−(k×Wcycle)
Step 4: Step-by-Step Remainder Exhaustion:
Step through the remaining work unit by unit in the exact assigned order:
-
If R≤Efirst, then additional time =EfirstR days.
-
If R>Efirst, first worker works 1 full day; new remainder =R−Efirst, handed to the second worker.
4. The Classic Exam Trap & Speed Shortcut
The Demolition Reversal Trap:
If Builder A builds +4 units/day and Demolisher B removes −2 units/day, net progress is +2 units every 2 days.
To reach a target of 20 units, do NOT simply say 220×2=20 days!
On Day 17, the work reaches 16 units. On Day 18, Demolisher brings it to 16. But on Day 17 morning, progress was 16+4=20 units! Once the job completes, it stops.
Rule: Subtract the maximum positive daily rate before calculating complete cycles:
Wtarget−Epositive
Formulas
| Cycle Work Output | Wcycle=∑i=1nEi Total work completed in one full cyclic rotation of n workers. |
|---|
| Number of Full Cycles | k=⌊WcycleWtotal⌋ Integer floor of complete cycles before remainder handling. |
|---|
| Residual Time Division | Tresidual=EactiveR Fraction of a day needed by the active worker to finish residual units R. |
|---|
| Demolition / Slipping Peak Threshold | Wthreshold=Wtarget−Ebuilder Guarantees that builder finishing the task on an upswing is not subjected to subsequent destruction. |
|---|
Traps and tips
- Never divide the final remainder by the average cycle rate—always assign it step-by-step to the specific worker on duty.
- Calculate the difference in completion time if worker B starts instead of worker A—CAT loves testing this delta.
- For construction/demolition problems, subtract the builder's single-day rate from total work before calculating full cycles.
- In three-worker rotations, check if the remainder requires more than one worker to finish.
Solved examples
Example 1: Classic Two-Worker Alternation (Start Sensitivity)
Worker A can complete a landscaping project in 12 days, and Worker B can complete it in 16 days. They work on alternate days. (1) How many days will the project take if Worker A starts on Day 1? (2) How many days will it take if Worker B starts on Day 1?
Show solution
Step 1: Set Total Work using LCM.
Total Work W=LCM(12,16)=48 units
Step 2: Define a 2-day cycle.
Wcycle=EA+EB=4+3=7 units every 2 days
Case 1: Worker A starts on Day 1.
Full Cycles k=⌊748⌋=6
-
Work in 6 cycles: 6×7=42 units
-
Time elapsed: 6×2=12 days
-
Remainder: R=48−42=6 units
On Day 13, Worker A works:
- A produces 4 units ⟹ Remainder =6−4=2 units. (1 full day added, now 13 days).
On Day 14, Worker B works:
- B produces 3 units/day, needs 2 units ⟹32 day.
Total Time (A starts)=12+1+32=1332 days
Case 2: Worker B starts on Day 1.
- Work in 6 cycles: 42 units in 12 days. Remainder =6 units.
On Day 13, Worker B works:
- B produces 3 units ⟹ Remainder =6−3=3 units. (1 full day added, now 13 days).
On Day 14, Worker A works:
- A produces 4 units/day, needs 3 units ⟹43 day.
Total Time (B starts)=12+1+43=1343 days
(Notice that when the faster worker A starts first, the project finishes 43−32=121 day faster).
Takeaway: Starting with the more efficient worker consistently yields a faster or equal completion time.
Example 2: Three-Worker Cyclic Rotation (A -> B -> C)
Three automated sorting systems—Alpha, Beta, and Gamma—can clear a fulfillment warehouse in 15, 20, and 30 hours respectively. To prevent overheating, only one system runs at a time, switching every hour in the sequence: Alpha in Hour 1, Beta in Hour 2, Gamma in Hour 3, Alpha in Hour 4, and so on. Exactly how many hours and minutes will it take to clear the entire warehouse?
Show solution
Step 1: Set Total Work using LCM.
Total Work W=LCM(15,20,30)=60 units
-
Eα=1560=4 units/hour
-
Eβ=2060=3 units/hour
-
Eγ=3060=2 units/hour
Step 2: 3-Hour Cycle Output.
Wcycle=4+3+2=9 units every 3 hours
Step 3: Complete Cycles.
k=⌊960⌋=6
-
Work in 6 cycles: 6×9=54 units
-
Time in 6 cycles: 6×3=18 hours
-
Remainder: R=60−54=6 units
Step 4: Step through remainder.
-
Hour 19 (Alpha runs): Alpha does 4 units ⟹ Remainder =6−4=2 units. (1 full hour).
-
Hour 20 (Beta runs): Beta does 3 units/hour, but only 2 units remain:
Time needed=32 hours=40 minutes
Total Time=18 hours+1 hour+40 minutes=19 hours 40 minutes
Takeaway: In a 3-agent cyclic process, always exhaust the remainder step-by-step through the respective agents in rotation.
Example 3: Constant Worker with Staggered Assistants
Lead Engineer Dev can complete a module alone in 20 days. Associate Anuj takes 30 days alone, and Associate Charu takes 60 days alone. Dev works every single day, but is assisted by Anuj on every second day (Days 2, 4, 6...) and by Charu on every third day (Days 3, 6, 9...). In how many days will the module be completed?
Show solution
Step 1: Set Total Work using LCM.
Total Work W=LCM(20,30,60)=60 units
-
EDev=2060=3 units/day
-
EAnuj=3060=2 units/day
-
ECharu=6060=1 unit/day
Step 2: Determine repeating cycle length.
Anuj helps every 2 days; Charu helps every 3 days. The repeating cycle length is LCM(2,3)=6 days.
Step 3: Track daily work across a 6-day cycle:
-
Day 1: Dev alone =3 units
-
Day 2: Dev + Anuj =3+2=5 units
-
Day 3: Dev + Charu =3+1=4 units
-
Day 4: Dev + Anuj =3+2=5 units
-
Day 5: Dev alone =3 units
-
Day 6: Dev + Anuj + Charu =3+2+1=6 units
Work per 6-day cycle=3+5+4+5+3+6=26 units
Step 4: Find complete 6-day cycles.
k=⌊2660⌋=2
-
Work in 2 cycles: 2×26=52 units
-
Time elapsed: 2×6=12 days
-
Remainder: R=60−52=8 units
Step 5: Step through next days.
-
Day 13 (Day 1 of cycle 3): Dev alone does 3 units ⟹R=8−3=5 units.
-
Day 14 (Day 2 of cycle 3): Dev + Anuj do 5 units ⟹R=5−5=0 units! Exactly finishes!
Total Time=12+2=14 days
Takeaway: When helpers join on different periodicities, find the LCM of their periods to construct the master super-cycle.
Example 4: The Demolition / Slipping Peak Threshold
Mason A can build a boundary wall in 15 days working alone. Due to subsidence, poor weather damages and reduces the wall at a rate that would demolish a completed wall in 20 days. Mason A builds on Day 1, weather damage occurs on Day 2, A builds on Day 3, damage occurs on Day 4, and so forth. In how many days will the wall first reach its full required height?
Show solution
Step 1: Set Total Work using LCM.
Total Work W=LCM(15,20)=60 units
-
Building rate EA=+1560=+4 units/day
-
Damage rate ED=−2060=−3 units/day
Step 2: 2-Day Cycle Net Progress.
Wcycle=+4−3=+1 unit every 2 days
Step 3: The Peak Threshold Rule.
Once the wall reaches 60 units on any building day, the wall is complete—the subsequent demolition never happens!
Subtract Mason A's single-day building rate to find the cycle threshold:
Wthreshold=60−4=56 units
To achieve 56 units of net progress:
Number of cycles=156=56 cycles
Time for 56 cycles=56×2=112 days
Wall height at end of Day 112=56 units
Step 4: Final Building Day.
On Day 113, Mason A works:
Progress on Day 113=56+4=60 units
The wall reaches 60 units on Day 113!
Total Days=113 days
Takeaway: In positive/negative alternating problems, subtract the positive single-day step from total work before computing cycles to capture the peak.
Example 5: Alternating Half-Shift Industrial Production
Assembly Line 1 can complete a batch of electric scooters in 8 hours, and Assembly Line 2 takes 12 hours. The factory runs 1-hour shifts alternating between Line 1 and Line 2. However, whenever a line starts a new shift, there is a 10-minute recalibration delay where no scooters are produced (effectively working 50 minutes per hour). If Line 1 starts first, find the total time taken to finish the batch.
Show solution
Step 1: Set Total Work using LCM.
Total Work W=LCM(8,12)=24 units
-
Line 1 rated speed: 824=3 units/hour=0.05 units/min
-
Line 2 rated speed: 1224=2 units/hour=301 units/min
Step 2: Effective production per 1-hour shift (50 active minutes).
-
Line 1 shift output: 50 mins×0.05=2.5 units
-
Line 2 shift output: 50 mins×301=35≈1.667 units
Step 3: 2-Hour Cycle Output.
Wcycle=2.5+35=37.5+5=312.5=625 units every 2 hours
Step 4: Complete Cycles.
k=⌊25/624⌋=⌊25144⌋=5
-
Work in 5 cycles: 5×625=6125=20.833 units
-
Time in 5 cycles: 5×2=10 hours
-
Remainder: R=24−20.833=3.167 units=619 units
Step 5: Step through remainder.
-
Hour 11 (Line 1 runs):
Line 1 recalibrates for 10 mins, then works for 50 mins producing 2.5 units.
Remaining Work=619−2.5=3.167−2.5=0.667=32 units
(Time so far: 11 full hours).
-
Hour 12 (Line 2 runs):
Line 2 recalibrates for 10 mins.
Then works at 301 units/min:
Active minutes needed=1/302/3=32×30=20 minutes
Total time in Hour 12=10 min (recalibration)+20 min (production)=30 minutes
Total Duration=11 hours 30 minutes
Takeaway: Account for recalibration or startup friction by deducting it before calculating productive minutes in each shift.
Example 6: Optimal Scheduling of Three Workers
Three consultants—X, Y, and Z—can complete an audit in 12, 18, and 24 days respectively. They must work alone on successive days in a fixed cyclic pattern. Determine which starting consultant (X, Y, or Z) minimizes the total completion time, and calculate the exact difference between the fastest and slowest schedules.
Show solution
Step 1: Set Total Work using LCM.
Total Work W=LCM(12,18,24)=72 units
-
EX=1272=6 units/day
-
EY=1872=4 units/day
-
EZ=2472=3 units/day
Step 2: 3-Day Cycle Output.
Wcycle=6+4+3=13 units every 3 days
Full cycles k=⌊1372⌋=5
-
Work in 5 cycles: 5×13=65 units
-
Time in 5 cycles: 5×3=15 days
-
Remainder: R=72−65=7 units
Step 3: Evaluate Order 1: X -> Y -> Z.
Total Time1=15+1+0.25=16.25 days
Step 4: Evaluate Order 2: Y -> Z -> X.
Total Time2=15+1+1=17.0 days
Step 5: Evaluate Order 3: Z -> X -> Y.
Total Time3=15+1+32=16.67 days
Conclusion:
Difference=17.0−16.25=0.75 days=18 hours
Takeaway: Front-loading the highest daily efficiencies always achieves the fastest resolution of remainder work.
Practice questions
Question 1 · CAT Level
Three software engineers A, B, and C can complete a migration project individually in 15, 20, and 30 days respectively. Management evaluates two cyclic 4-day scheduling models:
In Scheme 1, Day 1 is worked by A alone, Day 2 by B alone, Day 3 by C alone, and Day 4 by all three working together, with this 4-day cycle repeating.
In Scheme 2, Day 1 is worked by C alone, Day 2 by B alone, Day 3 by A alone, and Day 4 by all three working together, repeating.
What is the positive difference in total completion time between the two schemes?
- A
- B
- C
- D
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (C) 14 hours
Let total work W=LCM(15,20,30)=60 units, so EA=4, EB=3, EC=2 units/day.
In both schemes, a 4-day cycle yields Wcycle=4+3+2+(4+3+2)=18 units.
In 3 complete cycles (12 days), both complete 3×18=54 units, leaving a remainder of 6 units.
Scheme 1 remainder: Day 13 (A) does 4 units (rem 2), Day 14 (B) needs 32 day⟹T1=1332 days=13 d 16 h.
Scheme 2 remainder: Day 13 (C) does 2 units (rem 4), Day 14 (B) does 3 units (rem 1), Day 15 (A) needs 41 day⟹T2=1441 days=14 d 6 h.
Difference =1441−1332=127 days=14 hours.
Question 2 · CAT Level
Two construction automata, A and B, assemble a modular tower while a demolition drone C dismantles it. Working alone continuously, A can build the tower in 10 hours, B can build it in 15 hours, and C can completely dismantle it in 20 hours. They operate in a strict 3-hour repeating rotation: A builds alone during Hour 1, B builds alone during Hour 2, and C dismantles alone during Hour 3. If the assembly is deemed complete the instant the tower first reaches its full height, after how many hours and minutes does the work finish?
- A
24 hours 20 minutes
- B
24 hours 40 minutes
- C
25 hours 15 minutes
- D
25 hours 40 minutes
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (B) 24 hours 40 minutes
Let total work W=LCM(10,15,20)=60 units, with EA=+6, EB=+4, and EC=−3 units/hour.
Net progress per 3-hour cycle =+6+4−3=+7 units.
Peak threshold rule: After 7 full cycles (21 hours), net progress is 7×7=49 units.
During Cycle 8: Hour 22 (A) brings height to 49+6=55 units; Hour 23 (B) brings height to 55+4=59 units (short of 60); Hour 24 (C) drops height to 59−3=56 units.
During Cycle 9: Hour 25 (A) needs 60−56=4 units at 6 units/h, taking 64 hour=40 minutes.
Total elapsed time =24 hours 40 minutes.
Question 3 · CAT Level
Master artisan P can complete a sculpture alone in 12 days, apprentice Q alone takes 24 days, and apprentice R alone takes 36 days. Artisan P works on the sculpture every single day. Apprentice Q assists P on all odd-numbered days (Days 1, 3, 5...), while apprentice R assists P on every third day starting from Day 2 (Days 2, 5, 8, 11...). In how many days will the sculpture be completed?
- A
- B
- C
- D
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (C) 82/3 days
Let total work W=LCM(12,24,36)=72 units, so EP=6, EQ=3, ER=2 units/day.
The assistance pattern repeats every LCM(2,3)=6 days.
Daily output across the 6-day cycle: Day 1 (P+Q): 9; Day 2 (P+R): 8; Day 3 (P+Q): 9; Day 4 (P): 6; Day 5 (P+Q+R): 11; Day 6 (P): 6.
Work in one 6-day cycle =9+8+9+6+11+6=49 units.
Remaining work after Day 6 =72−49=23 units.
Day 7 (P+Q) does 9 units (rem 14); Day 8 (P+R) does 8 units (rem 6); Day 9 (P+Q) takes 96=32 day.
Total time =8+32=832 days.
Question 4 · CAT Level
Two database replication processes, D1 and D2, can sync an entire dataset alone in 16 hours and 24 hours of continuous runtime respectively. The system runs them in alternating 2-hour shifts (D1 for 2 hours, then D2 for 2 hours, repeating). However, whenever a process begins its shift, the first 15 minutes are consumed by cache warm-up with 0% throughput, after which it operates at full rated speed for the remaining 1 hour 45 minutes. If D1 begins the first shift, what is the total elapsed time to sync the dataset?
- A
21 hours 20 minutes
- B
21 hours 30 minutes
- C
21 hours 40 minutes
- D
22 hours 15 minutes
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (C) 21 hours 40 minutes
Let total work W=LCM(16,24)=48 units. Rated speeds: E1=3 units/h, E2=2 units/h.
Each 2-hour shift has 1.75 hours of active work: D1 produces 1.75×3=5.25 units; D2 produces 1.75×2=3.50 units.
One 4-hour cycle yields 5.25+3.50=8.75 units. In 5 cycles (20 hours), work done =5×8.75=43.75 units.
Remaining work =48−43.75=4.25 units.
D1 starts shift 11: 15 minutes warm-up produces 0 units; producing 4.25 units at 3 units/h takes 34.25 h=85 minutes=1 h 25 m.
Total elapsed time =20 hours+15 min+1 hour 25 min=21 hours 40 minutes.
Question 5 · CAT Level
Three engineers A, B, and C can complete a codebase refactoring alone in 12, 15, and 20 days respectively. To ensure continuous peer review, they work in pairs on successive days: Pair (A and B) on Day 1, Pair (B and C) on Day 2, Pair (C and A) on Day 3, and this 3-day cyclic pattern repeats until completion. What is the total time (in days) required to complete the refactoring?
- A
- B
- C
- D
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (B) 73/7 days
Let total work W=LCM(12,15,20)=60 units. Individual efficiencies: EA=5, EB=4, EC=3 units/day.
Daily pair rates: Day 1 (A+B) =5+4=9; Day 2 (B+C) =4+3=7; Day 3 (C+A) =3+5=8 units/day.
Work per 3-day cycle =9+7+8=24 units.
In 2 full cycles (6 days), work completed =2×24=48 units, leaving 60−48=12 units.
Day 7 (Pair A+B) completes 9 units, leaving 12−9=3 units.
Day 8 (Pair B+C) works at 7 units/day, taking 73 day to finish the remaining 3 units.
Total time =6+1+73=773 days.
Try real CAT questions