CAT 2025 Slot 2 DILR Q16

  • Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
  • Data Interpretation › Bar Graphs
  • Medium
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2025_SLOT2_DILR_Q16

Data set · questions 15–18

The following charts depict details of research papers written by four authors, Arman, Brajen, Chintan, and Devon. The papers were of four types, single-author, two-author, three-author, and four-author, that is, written by one, two, three, or all four of these authors, respectively. No other authors were involved in writing these papers.

Diagram

The following additional facts are known.

  1. Each of the authors wrote at least one of each of the four types of papers.

  2. The four authors wrote different numbers of single-author papers.

  3. Both Chintan and Devon wrote more three-author papers than Brajen.

  4. The number of single-author and two-author papers written by Brajen were the same.

Question 16

Which of the following statements is/are NECESSARILY true?

i. Chintan wrote exactly three two-author papers.

ii. Chintan wrote more single-author papers than Devon.

  1. A

    Only ii

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    Both i and ii

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    Neither i nor ii

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    Only i

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (C)

Neither i nor ii

Solution

Concept: Authorship Incidence & Diophantine Constraint Satisfaction

Master State Table

Paper CategoryPaper IdentifierCo-authors IncludedOmitted Author
Four-AuthorPaper Q1Arman, Brajen, Chintan, DevonNone
Three-AuthorPaper T1Arman, Chintan, DevonBrajen
Three-AuthorPaper T2Brajen, Chintan, DevonArman

Question Deduction

We are asked to assess which of the following statements is/are NECESSARILY true:

• Statement i: Chintan wrote exactly three two-author papers.

• Statement ii: Chintan wrote more single-author papers than Devon.

Let us evaluate both statements across the two valid branches derived in the Master State Table:

• Audit of Statement i (Chintan's Two-Author Count):

• In Branch 1: Chintan wrote SC=2S_C = 2 single-author papers, which forces DC=7−2=5D_C = 7 - 2 = 5 two-author papers.

• In Branch 2: Chintan wrote SC=4S_C = 4 single-author papers, which forces DC=7−4=3D_C = 7 - 4 = 3 two-author papers.

• For a statement to be necessarily true, it must hold in all valid mathematical configurations.

• Because DC=5D_C = 5 in Branch 1, Chintan did not write exactly three two-author papers in Branch 1.

• Hence, Statement i is NOT necessarily true.

• Audit of Statement ii (Chintan vs Devon Single-Author Comparison):

• In Branch 1: Chintan wrote SC=2S_C = 2 single-author papers, while Devon wrote SD=4S_D = 4 single-author papers. Here, SC<SDS_C < S_D (2<42 < 4).

• In Branch 2: Chintan wrote SC=4S_C = 4 single-author papers, while Devon wrote SD=2S_D = 2 single-author papers. Here, SC>SDS_C > S_D (4>24 > 2).

• In Branch 1, Chintan wrote fewer single-author papers than Devon.

• Hence, Statement ii is NOT necessarily true.

• Options Comparison Matrix:

OptionStated ClaimEvaluation Against BranchesCorrectness Status
Option 1Only iiFalse in Branch 1 (SC=2<SD=4S_C = 2 < S_D = 4)Incorrect
Option 2Both i and iiBoth statements fail in Branch 1Incorrect
Option 3Neither i nor iiBoth statements fail to hold unconditionallyCorrect
Option 4Only iFalse in Branch 1 (DC=5≠3D_C = 5 \ne 3)Incorrect

Therefore, neither statement is necessarily true, corresponding to Option 3.

Topper Take

• The Confirmation Bias Trap: Candidates who arbitrarily test only one branch (often Branch 2, where SC=4,SD=2S_C = 4, S_D = 2, yielding DC=3D_C = 3 and SC>SDS_C > S_D) observe that both Statement i and Statement ii appear true, leading them to pick "Both i and ii" (Option 2). In CAT DILR, whenever an equality partition (here SC+SD=6S_C + S_D = 6) permits symmetric solutions ({2,4}\{2, 4\}), candidates must explicitly test whether both assignments remain viable under column and row constraints.

• Surgical Counterexample Technique: To disprove a "necessarily true" claim, one only needs a single valid counterexample. Showing that Branch 1 ((SC,DC)=(2,5)(S_C, D_C) = (2, 5) and (SD,DD)=(4,1)(S_D, D_D) = (4, 1)) satisfies all passage constraints immediately refutes both Statement i and Statement ii in one swift stroke, eliminating Options 1, 2, and 4 in seconds.

Other questions in this set

  1. Q15. What was the total number of two-author and three-author papers written by Brajen?
  2. Q17. Which of the following statements is/are NECESSARILY true? i. Arman wrote three-author papers only with Chintan and…
  3. Q18. If Devon wrote more than one two-author papers, then how many two-author papers did Chintan write?

Bar Graphs questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q14
    What was the total number of stars received by D?
  2. CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q15
    What was the number of stars received by D from Y?
  3. CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q16
    How many surfers distributed their stars among exactly 2 bloggers?
  4. CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q17
    Which of the following can be determined with certainty? I. The number of stars received by C from M II. The…
  5. CAT 2024 Slot 2 DILR Q10
    How many buyers gave ratings on Day 1?

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc