CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q17

  • Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
  • Data Interpretation › Bar Graphs
  • Easy
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2024_SLOT1_DILR_Q17

Data set · questions 14–17

Six web surfers M, N, O, P, X, and Y each had 30 stars which they distributed among four bloggers A, B, C, and D. The number of stars received by A and B from the six web surfers is shown in the figure below.

Diagram

The following additional facts are known regarding the number of stars received by the bloggers from the surfers.

  1. The numbers of stars received by the bloggers from the surfers were all multiples of 5 (including 0).

  2. The total numbers of stars received by the bloggers were the same.

  3. Each blogger received a different number of stars from M.

  4. Two surfers gave all their stars to a single blogger. 5. D received more stars than C from Y.

Question 17

Which of the following can be determined with certainty?


I. The number of stars received by C from M


II. The number of stars received by D from O

  1. A

    Neither I nor II

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    Both I and II

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    Only I

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    Only II

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (C)

Only I

Solution

Concept: Combinatorial Grid Allocation & Rating Matrix Deductions

Master State Table

Web SurferBlogger ABlogger BBlogger CBlogger DRow TotalPositive Recipients Count
M100155303 (A, C, D)
N25005302 (A, D)
O0030 / 00 / 30301 (C or D)
P52500302 (A, B)
X000 / 3030 / 0301 (D or C)
Y52005303 (A, B, D)
Column Total45454545180—

Question Deduction

• Target Statements Evaluation:

• Statement I: The number of stars received by CC from MM (SM,CS_{M,C}).

• Statement II: The number of stars received by DD from OO (SO,DS_{O,D}).

• Rigorous Proof for Statement I (SM,CS_{M,C}):

• Surfer MM gave 1010 to AA and 00 to BB, leaving C+D=20C + D = 20.

• By Clue 3, all allocations from MM are distinct multiples of 55, meaning {SM,C,SM,D}={15,5}\{S_{M,C}, S_{M,D}\} = \{15, 5\} in some order.

• From Blogger DD's total constraint:

SM,D+SN,D+(SO,D+SX,D)+SP,D+SY,D=45S_{M,D} + S_{N,D} + (S_{O,D} + S_{X,D}) + S_{P,D} + S_{Y,D} = 45

SM,D+SN,D+30+0+5=45  ⟹  SM,D+SN,D=10S_{M,D} + S_{N,D} + 30 + 0 + 5 = 45 \implies S_{M,D} + S_{N,D} = 10

• Since SN,D≥0S_{N,D} \ge 0, SM,DS_{M,D} cannot exceed 1010. This strictly rules out SM,D=15S_{M,D} = 15 and uniquely fixes:

SM,D=5  ⟹  SM,C=15S_{M,D} = 5 \implies S_{M,C} = 15

• This value holds identically in every valid configuration of the set. Thus, Statement I can be determined with certainty.

• Rigorous Proof for Statement II (SO,DS_{O,D}):

• From Clue 4, surfers OO and XX are the two surfers who gave all 3030 stars to a single blogger (CC or DD).

• In Configuration 1: Surfer OO gives 3030 stars to CC and 00 stars to DD (SO,D=0S_{O,D} = 0).

• In Configuration 2: Surfer OO gives 00 stars to CC and 3030 stars to DD (SO,D=30S_{O,D} = 30).

• Both configurations fully satisfy all passage constraints without contradiction.

• Therefore, SO,D∈{0,30}S_{O,D} \in \{0, 30\} cannot be uniquely determined.

• Option Matching: Statement I can be determined with certainty, while Statement II cannot. Thus, the correct choice is "Only I", corresponding to Option 3.

Topper Take

• Symmetric Indeterminacy Insight: Notice the structural symmetry between surfers OO and XX: both have identical chart footprints (A=0,B=0A = 0, B = 0), identical row totals (3030), and no asymmetric clues distinguishing them. Recognizing this inherent symmetry instantly informs you that SO,DS_{O,D} is indeterminate between 00 and 3030, eliminating "Both I and II" and "Only II" in under 5 seconds.

• Premature Surrender on Statement I: Some candidates observe the ambiguity in OO and XX and incorrectly assume that the entire bottom half of the table is indeterminate, leading them to pick "Neither I nor II" (Option 1). Elite toppers understand that column marginal totals (TD=45,TC=45T_D = 45, T_C = 45) tightly bind (SM,D+SN,D=10)(S_{M,D} + S_{N,D} = 10), creating an asymmetric boundary condition that forces SM,C=15S_{M,C} = 15 with absolute mathematical certainty.

Other questions in this set

  1. Q14. What was the total number of stars received by D?
  2. Q15. What was the number of stars received by D from Y?
  3. Q16. How many surfers distributed their stars among exactly 2 bloggers?

Bar Graphs questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2025 Slot 2 DILR Q15
    What was the total number of two-author and three-author papers written by Brajen?
  2. CAT 2025 Slot 2 DILR Q16
    Which of the following statements is/are NECESSARILY true? i. Chintan wrote exactly three two-author papers.…
  3. CAT 2025 Slot 2 DILR Q17
    Which of the following statements is/are NECESSARILY true? i. Arman wrote three-author papers only with…
  4. CAT 2025 Slot 2 DILR Q18
    If Devon wrote more than one two-author papers, then how many two-author papers did Chintan write?
  5. CAT 2022 Slot 3 DILR Q6
    In 2000, what was the ratio of the number of dead males to dead females among those being tracked?

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc