CAT 2023 Slot 1 VARC Q8
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension › Culture
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2023_SLOT1_VARC_Q08
Passage · questions 5–8
RESIDENTS of Lozère, a hilly department in southern France, recite complaints familiar to many rural corners of Europe. In remote hamlets and villages, with names such as Le Bacon and Le Bacon Vieux, mayors grumble about a lack of local schools, jobs, or phone and internet connections. Farmers of grazing animals add another concern: the return of wolves. Eradicated from France last century, the predators are gradually creeping back to more forests and hillsides. "The wolf must be taken in hand," said an aspiring parliamentarian, Francis Palombi, when pressed by voters in an election campaign early this summer. Tourists enjoy visiting a wolf park in Lozère, but farmers fret over their livestock and their livelihoods.
As early as the ninth century, the royal office of the Luparii—wolf-catchers—was created in France to tackle the predators. Those official hunters (and others) completed their job in the 1930s, when the last wolf disappeared from the mainland. Active hunting and improved technology such as rifles in the 19th century, plus the use of poison such as strychnine later on, caused the population collapse. But in the early 1990s the animals reappeared. They crossed the Alps from Italy, upsetting sheep farmers on the French side of the border. Wolves have since spread to areas such as Lozère, delighting environmentalists, who see the predators' presence as a sign of wider ecological health. Farmers, who say the wolves cause the deaths of thousands of sheep and other grazing animals, are less cheerful. They grumble that green activists and politically correct urban types have allowed the return of an old enemy.
Various factors explain the changes of the past few decades. Rural depopulation is part of the story. In Lozère, for example, farming and a once-flourishing mining industry supported a population of over 140,000 residents in the mid-19th century. Today the department has fewer than 80,000 people, many in its towns. As humans withdraw, forests are expanding. In France, between 1990 and 2015, forest cover increased by an average of 102,000 hectares each year, as more fields were given over to trees. Now, nearly one-third of mainland France is covered by woodland of some sort. The decline of hunting as a sport also means more forests fall quiet. In the mid-to-late 20th century over 2m hunters regularly spent winter weekends tramping in woodland, seeking boars, birds and other prey. Today the Fédération Nationale des Chasseurs, the national body, claims 1.1m people hold hunting licences, though the number of active hunters is probably lower. The mostly protected status of the wolf in Europe—hunting them is now forbidden, other than when occasional culls are sanctioned by the state—plus the efforts of NGOs to track and count the animals, also contribute to the recovery of wolf populations.
As the lupine population of Europe spreads westwards, with occasional reports of wolves seen closer to urban areas, expect to hear of more clashes between farmers and those who celebrate the predators' return. Farmers' losses are real, but are not the only economic story. Tourist venues, such as parks where wolves are kept and the animals' spread is discussed, also generate income and jobs in rural areas.
Question 8
Which one of the following statements, if true, would weaken the author's claims?
Show answer and solution
Answer: (D)
Wolf attacks on tourists in Lozère are on the rise.
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Critical Reasoning / Weaken the Argument
-
Passage Reference:
"Tourists enjoy visiting a wolf park in Lozère, but farmers fret over their livestock and their livelihoods."
"Farmers' losses are real, but are not the only economic story. Tourist venues, such as parks where wolves are kept and the animals' spread is discussed, also generate income and jobs in rural areas."
Logical Deduction
To weaken the author's argument, an external premise must directly challenge, undermine, or invalidate the author's central claims or proposed solutions:
-
The Author's Core Claim & Resolution: In the concluding paragraph, the author balances the undisputed losses suffered by farmers by asserting that wolf presence brings a crucial economic benefit: "Farmers' losses are real, but are not the only economic story. Tourist venues, such as parks where wolves are kept and the animals' spread is discussed, also generate income and jobs in rural areas." The viability of the author's optimistic outlook relies entirely on tourists actively patronizing Lozère to visit wolf parks and rural wildlife spaces.
-
Impact of Option 4: If "Wolf attacks on tourists in Lozère are on the rise" (Option 4), several catastrophic consequences ensue for the author's argument:
-
Fear of predatory attacks would severely deter tourists from visiting Lozère's wolf parks and hiking its countryside.
-
The collapse in tourist footfall would destroy the very rural income and employment opportunities that the author presents as the redeeming economic counterbalance to agricultural losses.
-
It destroys the feasibility of peaceful human-predator coexistence, decisively weakening the author's argument that wolf presence can be an economic asset.
-
-
Evaluating Other Options:
-
Option 1 (mining sites used as sheep pastures) does not contradict depopulation or wolf spread; sheep pastures simply represent existing pastoralism.
-
Option 2 (wolves returning after migrating out) directly confirms the author's factual premise in Paragraph 2.
-
Option 3 (unemployment concerns residents) directly aligns with Paragraph 1 ("mayors grumble about a lack of... jobs").
-
Correct Answer: Option 4
- If wolf attacks on tourists were increasing, safety fears would decimate tourist footfall to wolf parks and rural venues, thereby directly destroying the rural jobs and income that the author claims counterbalance the farmers' economic losses.
Option Elimination
-
Option 1 (Out of Scope / Irrelevant Premise): Repurposing historical mining sites as grazing pastures merely describes local agricultural land use. It does not challenge the reality of rural depopulation, forest regrowth, or wolf predation.
-
Option 2 (Strengthens the Passage / Premise Affirmation): Reiterates the foundational narrative of the text—that wolves, having disappeared last century, are now recolonizing France. Confirming an explicit premise cannot weaken the author's thesis.
-
Option 3 (Corroborates the Passage / Fact Confirmation): Reinforces the author's observation in Paragraph 1 that local mayors and residents struggle with a lack of jobs. Corroborating an existing claim does not weaken the argument.
-
Option 4 (Direct Challenge to Author's Economic Counterclaim): Directly dismantles the author's primary counterweight to farmers' losses. If wolves actively attack tourists, the ecotourism economy (parks, visitors, rural jobs) collapses under public safety hazards, shattering the author's proposed economic silver lining.
Detailed explanation
📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure
Central Theme
The ecological resurgence of the wolf population in rural Europe—focusing specifically on the department of Lozère in southern France—and the resulting socioeconomic and political conflict between agrarian pastoralists and urban conservationists. The passage traces the multi-causal drivers behind the wolves' return (rural depopulation, reforestation of abandoned farmlands, the decline of recreational hunting, and EU-wide legal protections) and explores the acute clash between sheep farmers suffering devastating livestock predation and environmentalists celebrating ecological restoration. Finally, the author analyzes an emerging economic model centered on wolf-related ecotourism, suggesting that tourist facilities and wildlife education can generate vital revenue and employment to partially offset local agrarian distress.
Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary
-
Paragraph 1: Sets the scene in the rural department of Lozère, southern France. Mayors and residents vocalize long-standing grievances common to marginalized rural European communities (loss of schools, jobs, telecommunication infrastructure). Farmers face an acute, escalating threat: the return of predatory wolves targeting grazing livestock. Local politicians are pressured to take action ("The wolf must be taken in hand"), establishing an immediate tension between the economic anxieties of local farmers and the appeal of wolf parks to outside tourists.
-
Paragraph 2: Chronicles the historical trajectory of wolves in France. From the 9th-century royal office of the Luparii (official wolf-catchers) to 19th-century technological advances (rifles) and toxicological methods (strychnine), wolves were systematically eradicated by the 1930s. In the early 1990s, wolves recolonized France by crossing the Alps from Italy, spreading to Lozère. This resurgence sparks intense cultural polarization: delighted environmentalists hail the predator as an indicator of ecological vitality, while aggrieved farmers blame urban environmentalists and "politically correct urban types" for unleashing an ancient agrarian menace.
-
Paragraph 3: Systematically deconstructs the multi-faceted catalysts driving the lupine recovery over recent decades:
-
Demographic contraction: Lozère's population plummeted from over 140,000 in the mid-19th century to under 80,000 today.
-
Spontaneous rewilding / Reforestation: With human retreat, abandoned fields transformed into forests, expanding woodland cover across nearly one-third of mainland France.
-
Decline of hunting culture: Recreational sport hunting sharply diminished from over 2 million participants in the late 20th century to barely 1.1 million license holders today.
-
Legal safeguards & Conservation monitoring: European Union environmental directives granted wolves protected legal status (barring hunting except state-sanctioned culls), reinforced by NGO population tracking.
-
-
Paragraph 4: Forecasts escalating conflicts as lupine ranges expand westward toward suburban and urban fringes. The author acknowledges the genuine reality of farmers' livestock losses, but introduces an economic counterbalance: wolf-related tourism, wildlife reserves, and educational venues offer viable alternative streams of income and local employment for economically depressed rural regions.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Objective, Investigative, Analytical, Balanced, and Pragmatic.
-
Author's Perspective: The author maintains an even-handed, sociological perspective, recognizing the legitimacy of the farmers' economic devastation without demonizing the ecological success of predator recovery. By highlighting wolf-focused ecotourism as a potential economic mechanism to generate rural jobs and income, the author seeks a pragmatic synthesis between wildlife conservation and rural economic revitalization.
Other questions in this set
- Q5. Which one of the following has NOT contributed to the growing wolf population in Lozère?
- Q6. The inhabitants of Lozère have to grapple with all of the following problems, EXCEPT:
- Q7. The author presents a possible economic solution to an existing issue facing Lozère that takes into account the…
Culture questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q2
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q3
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q4
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q5
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q16
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc