CAT 2023 Slot 1 VARC Q9
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension › Literature
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2023_SLOT1_VARC_Q09
Passage · questions 9–12
For early postcolonial literature, the world of the novel was often the nation. Postcolonial novels were usually concerned with national questions. Sometimes the whole story of the novel was taken as an allegory of the nation, whether India or Tanzania. This was important for supporting anti-colonial nationalism, but could also be limiting - land-focused and inward- looking.
My new book "Writing Ocean Worlds" explores another kind of world of the novel: not the village or nation, but the Indian Ocean world. The book describes a set of novels in which the Indian Ocean is at the centre of the story. It focuses on the novelists Amitav Ghosh, Abdulrazak Gurnah, Lindsey Collen and Joseph Conrad who have centred the Indian Ocean world in the majority of their novels. Their work reveals a world that is outward-looking -full of movement, border-crossing and south-south interconnection. They are all very different – from colonially inclined (Conrad) to radically anti-capitalist (Collen), but together draw on and shape a wider sense of Indian Ocean space through themes, images, metaphors and language. This has the effect of remapping the world in the reader's mind, as centred in the interconnected global south.
The Indian Ocean world is a term used to describe the very long-lasting connections among the coasts of East Africa, the Arab coasts, and South and East Asia. These connections were made possible by the geography of the Indian Ocean. For much of history, travel by sea was much easier than by land, which meant that port cities very far apart were often more easily connected to each other than to much closer inland cities. Historical and archaeological evidence suggests that what we now call globalisation first appeared in the Indian Ocean.
This is the interconnected oceanic world referenced and produced by the novels in my book. For their part Ghosh, Gurnah, Collen and even Conrad reference a different set of histories and geographies than the ones most commonly found in fiction in English. Those commonly found ones are mostly centred in Europe or the US, assume a background of Christianity and whiteness, and mention places like Paris and New York. The novels in my book highlight instead a largely Islamic space, feature characters of colour and centralise the ports of Malindi, Mombasa, Aden, Java and Bombay.
It is a densely imagined, richly sensory image of a southern cosmopolitan culture which provides for an enlarged sense of place in the world. This remapping is particularly powerful for the representation of Africa. In the fiction, sailors and travellers are not all European. African, as well as Indian and Arab characters, are traders, nakhodas (dhow ship captains), runaways, villains, missionaries and activists. This does not mean that Indian Ocean Africa is romanticised. Migration is often a matter of force; travel is portrayed as abandonment rather than adventure, freedoms are kept from women and slavery is rife. What it does mean is that the African part of the Indian Ocean world plays an active role in its long, rich history and therefore in that of the wider world.
Question 9
All of the following statements, if true, would weaken the passage's claim about the relationship between mainstream English-language fiction and Indian Ocean novels EXCEPT:
Show answer and solution
Answer: (C)
most mainstream English-language novels have historically privileged the Christian, white, male experience of travel and
adventure.
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Critical Reasoning / Weaken the Argument (Except Question)
-
Passage Reference:
"For their part Ghosh, Gurnah, Collen and even Conrad reference a different set of histories and geographies than the ones most commonly found in fiction in English. Those commonly found ones are mostly centred in Europe or the US, assume a background of Christianity and whiteness, and mention places like Paris and New York. The novels in my book highlight instead a largely Islamic space, feature characters of colour and centralise the ports of Malindi, Mombasa, Aden, Java and Bombay." (Paragraph 4)
"This does not mean that Indian Ocean Africa is romanticised. Migration is often a matter of force; travel is portrayed as abandonment rather than adventure, freedoms are kept from women and slavery is rife. What it does mean is that the African part of the Indian Ocean world plays an active role in its long, rich history and therefore in that of the wider world." (Paragraph 5)
Logical Deduction
The passage sets up a sharp contrast between mainstream English-language fiction and Indian Ocean novels:
-
Mainstream English fiction: Centered on Europe/US, assumes a background of whiteness and Christianity, and privileges metropolitan centers like Paris and New York while romanticizing travel as heroic adventure.
-
Indian Ocean novels: Centered on the Global South (East Africa, Arab coasts, South/East Asia), highlight characters of color and largely Islamic spaces, and depict Africa realistically without romanticization (highlighting forced migration, abandonment, oppression, and slavery while showcasing active agency).
The question asks for the statement that, if true, would NOT weaken (i.e., strengthens, is consistent with, or is irrelevant to) the author's claim about the relationship between these two categories of literature.
- Option 3 states: "most mainstream English-language novels have historically privileged the Christian, white, male experience of travel and adventure." This statement directly substantiates and mirrors the author's explicit characterization of mainstream fiction in English ("assume a background of Christianity and whiteness" and viewing travel as adventure rather than abandonment). Because Option 3 strengthens and corroborates the author's claim, it does not weaken it. Hence, Option 3 is the correct exception.
Correct Answer: Option 3
- Directly reinforces the passage's characterization of mainstream English-language fiction as centered on white, Christian perspectives and adventurous travel, thereby supporting rather than weakening the contrast drawn by the author.
Option Elimination
-
Option 1 (Weakens the Argument / Contradicts Passage Premise): If Indian Ocean novels were driven by "postcolonial nostalgia for an idyllic past," this would directly contradict the author's explicit assertion that Indian Ocean Africa is not romanticised (depicting forced migration, lack of freedom for women, and pervasive slavery). Thus, this statement weakens the author's claim.
-
Option 2 (Weakens the Argument / Contradicts Passage Premise): If Indian Ocean novels were driven by an "Orientalist imagination of its cultural crudeness," this would directly undermine the author's claim that these novels construct a "richly sensory image of a southern cosmopolitan culture" where Africans, Arabs, and Indians act as active agents, traders, and intellectuals. Thus, this statement weakens the author's claim.
-
Option 4 (Weakens the Argument / Direct Factual Contradiction): If very few mainstream English novels were set in American and European metropolitan centers, it would directly invalidate the author's premise that mainstream English fiction is "mostly centred in Europe or the US, assume a background of Christianity and whiteness, and mention places like Paris and New York." Thus, this statement weakens the author's claim.
Detailed explanation
📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure
Central Theme
The emergence and critical significance of "Indian Ocean literature"—novels centered on transoceanic, maritime networks across the Global South rather than land-locked, inward-looking nation-states. Drawing on novelists like Amitav Ghosh, Abdulrazak Gurnah, Lindsey Collen, and Joseph Conrad, the passage explores how maritime geography fostered the earliest forms of globalization and cosmopolitanism across East Africa, the Arab world, and South/East Asia. It demonstrates how these narratives "remap" the world in the reader's imagination, challenging Eurocentric literary conventions and portraying Africa not as a passive or romanticized space, but as a dynamic, complex historical actor.
Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary
-
Paragraph 1: Contrasts the spatial focus of early postcolonial fiction with oceanic literature. Early postcolonial novels frequently took the nation or village as their world, often constructing the plot as a national allegory (e.g., India or Tanzania). While crucial for anti-colonial nationalism, this paradigm was limiting—inward-looking and bound to territorial borders.
-
Paragraph 2: Introduces the author's book Writing Ocean Worlds, which studies novels that place the Indian Ocean at their center (Ghosh, Gurnah, Collen, and Conrad). Despite disparate political stances—from Conrad's colonial leanings to Collen's radical anti-capitalism—these authors construct an outward-looking world of border-crossing and South-South interconnections, remapping the reader's mental geography toward an interconnected Global South.
-
Paragraph 3: Defines the "Indian Ocean world" as an ancient network linking East Africa, the Arabian Peninsula, and South/East Asia. Maritime geography facilitated sea travel that connected far-flung coastal port cities more readily than closer inland settlements, establishing the Indian Ocean as the historical cradle of globalization.
-
Paragraph 4: Juxtaposes Indian Ocean literature with mainstream English-language fiction. Mainstream fiction is predominantly Euro-American, assumes a white Christian normative background, and centers metropolises like Paris and New York. By contrast, Indian Ocean novels depict a largely Islamic maritime domain, spotlight characters of color, and focus on historic port hubs like Malindi, Mombasa, Aden, Java, and Bombay.
-
Paragraph 5: Examines the powerful representation of Africa within this southern cosmopolitanism. Non-European actors—African, Arab, and Indian—populate the seas as traders, captains (nakhodas), runaways, and activists. The passage emphasizes that this world is not romanticized: migration is often coerced, travel is marked by abandonment, women face oppression, and slavery is widespread. Nevertheless, African societies are restored as active agents in regional and global history.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Academic, Scholarly, Literary-Critical, and Revisionist/Advocatory.
-
Author's Perspective: The author champions an "oceanic turn" in literary studies, arguing that oceanic networks offer a necessary corrective to both Eurocentric worldviews and inward-looking postcolonial nationalism, revealing a vibrant, decentralized, and deeply interconnected Global South.
Other questions in this set
- Q10. All of the following claims contribute to the "remapping" discussed by the passage, EXCEPT:
- Q11. Which one of the following statements is not true about migration in the Indian Ocean world?
- Q12. On the basis of the nature of the relationship between the items in each pair below, choose the odd pair out:
Literature questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 VARC Q13
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 VARC Q14
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 VARC Q15
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 VARC Q16
- CAT 2020 Slot 1 VARC Q5
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc