CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q5
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension › Culture
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2025_SLOT1_VARC_Q05
Passage · questions 2–5
Often the well intentioned music lover or the traditionally-minded professional composer asks two basic questions when faced with the electronic music phenomena: (1) . . . is this type of artistic creation music at all? and, (2) given that the product is accepted as music of a new type or order, is not such music “inhuman”? . . . As Lejaren Hiller points out in his book Experimental Music (coauthor Leonard M. Isaacson), two questions which often arise when music is discussed are: (a) the substance of musical communication and its symbolic and semantic significance, if any, and (b) the particular processes, both mental and technical, which are involved in creating and responding to musical composition. The ever-present popular concept of music as a direct, open, emotional expression and as a subjective form of communication from the composer, is, of course still that of the nineteenth century, when composers themselves spoke of music in those terms . . . But since the third decade of our century many composers have preferred more objective definitions of music, epitomized in Stravinsky’s description of it as “a form of speculation in terms of sound and time”. An acceptance of this more characteristic twentieth-century view of the art of musical composition will of course immediately bring the layman closer to an understanding of, and sympathetic response to, electronic music, even if the forms, sounds and approaches it uses will still be of a foreign nature to him.
A communication problem however will still remain. The principal barrier that electronic music presents at large, in relation to the communication process, is that composers in this medium are employing a new language of forms . . . where terms like ‘densities’, ‘indefinite pitch relations’, ‘dynamic serialization’, ‘permutation’, etc., are substitutes (or remote equivalents) for the traditional concepts of harmony, melody, rhythm, etc. . . . When the new structural procedures of electronic music are at last fully understood by the listener the barriers between him and the work he faces will be removed. . . .
The medium of electronic music has of course tempted many kinds of composers to try their hand at it . . . But the serious-minded composer approaches the world of electronic music with a more sophisticated and profound concept of creation. Although he knows that he can reproduce and employ melodic, rhythmic patterns and timbres of a traditional nature, he feels that it is in the exploration of sui generis languages and forms that the aesthetic magic of the new medium lies. And, conscientiously, he plunges into this search.
The second objection usually levelled against electronic music is much more innocent in nature. When people speak—sometimes very vehemently—of the ‘inhuman’ quality of this music they seem to forget that the composer is the one who fires the machines, collects the sounds, manipulates them, pushes the buttons, programs the computer, filters the sounds, establishes pitches and scales, splices tape, thinks of forms, and rounds up the over-all structure of the piece, as well as every detail of it.
Question 5
The mention of Stravinsky’s description of music in the first paragraph does all the following EXCEPT:
Show answer and solution
Answer: (C)
help us determine which sounds are musical and which are not.
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Negative Detail / EXCEPT Question
-
Passage Reference:
Paragraph 1: "The ever-present popular concept of music as a direct, open, emotional expression and as a subjective form of communication from the composer, is, of course still that of the nineteenth century, when composers themselves spoke of music in those terms . . . But since the third decade of our century many composers have preferred more objective definitions of music, epitomized in Stravinsky’s description of it as “a form of speculation in terms of sound and time”. An acceptance of this more characteristic twentieth-century view of the art of musical composition will of course immediately bring the layman closer to an understanding of, and sympathetic response to, electronic music, even if the forms, sounds and approaches it uses will still be of a foreign nature to him."
Logical Deduction
The question asks to identify what the invocation of Stravinsky's description DOES NOT do:
-
Option 1 Evaluation: Stravinsky's description ("a form of speculation in terms of sound and time") is introduced in direct contrast to the nineteenth-century view ("direct, open, emotional expression"), thereby responding to and expanding upon earlier historical definitions. (Accomplished by the mention; eliminated).
-
Option 2 Evaluation: By shifting the definition of musical communication from emotional/subjective expression to an intellectual/objective speculation in sound and time, Stravinsky's formulation fundamentally complicates our understanding of what music communicates. (Accomplished by the mention; eliminated).
-
Option 4 Evaluation: The author explicitly states that adopting Stravinsky's objective formulation "will of course immediately bring the layman closer to an understanding of, and sympathetic response to, electronic music," thereby establishing the conceptual legitimacy needed to classify electronic sound creation as music. (Accomplished by the mention; eliminated).
-
Option 3 Evaluation: Stravinsky defines the nature and purpose of composition (speculation in sound and time); he does not provide an acoustic sieve, diagnostic manual, or empirical criterion to differentiate musical tones from non-musical sounds (noise). Because the passage never suggests that Stravinsky's quote delineates musical from non-musical acoustic phenomena, Option 3 is NOT supported by the text and represents the credited EXCEPT answer.
Correct Answer: Option 3
- Nowhere in the passage is Stravinsky's definition used to establish an acoustic boundary separating musical sounds from non-musical sounds; it reframes composition as objective speculation rather than classifying physical sound properties.
Option Elimination
-
Option 1 (Textually Valid Function / Invalid for EXCEPT): Validly accomplished; the passage uses Stravinsky's definition to transition beyond nineteenth-century subjective emotionalism into twentieth-century objective paradigms.
-
Option 2 (Textually Valid Function / Invalid for EXCEPT): Validly accomplished; shifting the essence of music from transparent emotional communication to formal speculation in sound and time significantly complicates the concept of musical communication.
-
Option 4 (Textually Valid Function / Invalid for EXCEPT): Validly accomplished; accepting this broader, objective definition enables lay listeners to recognize avant-garde electronic creations as legitimate music.
Detailed explanation
📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure
Central Theme
A foundational aesthetic and philosophical defense of electronic music against two recurrent traditionalist objections: first, whether electronic sound generation constitutes "music at all," and second, whether such music is intrinsically "inhuman." The author counters the first charge by contrasting nineteenth-century subjective emotionalism with twentieth-century objective paradigms—epitomized by Stravinsky's definition of music as "speculation in terms of sound and time"—arguing that initial communication barriers will dissolve once audiences comprehend electronic music's novel structural vocabulary and sui generis forms. The author rebuts the second charge by demonstrating the pervasive, indispensable human agency, intentionality, and craftsmanship governing every phase of electronic composition.
Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary
-
Paragraph 1: Outlines the two fundamental objections posed by traditionalists (is it music? and is it inhuman?), invoking Lejaren Hiller's questions on musical communication before contrasting the nineteenth-century romantic concept of music as subjective emotional expression with the twentieth-century objective definition (epitomized by Stravinsky's "speculation in terms of sound and time"), which provides the conceptual foundation for lay listeners to appreciate electronic music.
-
Paragraph 2: Analyzes the persisting "communication problem" facing electronic music, explaining that composers utilize a novel language of structural forms (densities, serialization, permutations) substituting for traditional harmony, melody, and rhythm—a perceptual barrier that will be dismantled once listeners comprehend these new structural procedures.
-
Paragraph 3: Differentiates dilettantish dabblers from serious-minded composers, asserting that the true aesthetic potential of the medium is realized not through mimicking conventional melodic or rhythmic patterns, but through dedicated exploration of sui generis (autonomous and unique) languages and forms.
-
Paragraph 4: Dismantles the charge of "inhumanity" as naive and unfounded by enumerating the exhaustive human craftsmanship involved: the composer remains in total creative control, firing machines, gathering and manipulating sounds, programming algorithms, filtering frequencies, establishing pitches, splicing tape, and designing the macro- and micro-structures of the composition.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Academic, analytical, apologetic (defensive in the classical rhetorical sense), reasoned, and persuasive.
-
Author's Perspective: An intellectual advocate and champion of avant-garde electronic music who seeks to demystify the medium, dismantle traditionalist aesthetic prejudices, and establish electronic composition as an authentic, profoundly human artistic endeavor.
Other questions in this set
- Q2. The goal of the author over the course of this passage is to:
- Q3. What relation does the “communication problem” mentioned in paragraph 2 have to the questions that the author recounts…
- Q4. From the context in which it is placed, the phrase “sui generis” in paragraph 3 suggests which one of the following?
Culture questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2024 Slot 3 VARC Q20
- CAT 2024 Slot 3 VARC Q21
- CAT 2024 Slot 3 VARC Q22
- CAT 2024 Slot 3 VARC Q23
- CAT 2023 Slot 1 VARC Q1
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc