CAT 2021 Slot 2 DILR Q16
- Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
- Logical Reasoning › Games & Tournaments
- Hard
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2021_SLOT2_DILR_Q16
Data set · questions 15–20
Ten objects o1, o2, …, o10 were distributed among Amar, Barat, Charles, Disha, and Elise. Each item went to exactly one person. Each person got exactly two of the items, and this pair of objects is called her/his bundle.
The following table shows how each person values each object.
The value of any bundle by a person is the sum of that person's values of the objects in that bundle. A person X envies another person Y if X values Y 's bundle more than X 's own bundle.
For example, hypothetically suppose Amar's bundle consists of and , and Barat's bundle consists of and . Then Amar values his own bundle at and Barat's bundle at
. Hence Amar does not envy Barat. On the other hand, Barat values his own bundle at and Amar's bundle at . Hence Barat envies Amar.
The following facts are known about the actual distribution of the objects among the five people.
-
If someone's value for an object is , then she/he received that object.
-
Objects o1, o2, and o3 were given to three different people.
-
Objects and were given to different people.
-
Three people value their own bundles at . No one values her/his own bundle at a number higher than .
-
Disha values her own bundle at an odd number. All others value their own bundles at an even number.
-
Some people who value their own bundles less than envy some other people who value their own bundle at . No one else envies others.
Question 16
Who among the following envies someone else?
Show answer and solution
Answer: (D)
Amar
Solution
Concept: Deductive Grid Assignment, Parity & Bounded Sum Constraints, Envy Elimination
Master State Table
| Person | Assigned Bundle | Object Breakdown (Own Values) | Own Bundle Value | Parity | Envy Directed Towards |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Amar | 12 | Even () | Barat (17), Charles (16) | ||
| Barat | 16 | Even () | None | ||
| Charles | 16 | Even () | None | ||
| Disha | 13 | Odd () | Barat (15) | ||
| Elise | 16 | Even () | None |
Question Deduction
• Baseline Valuations and Allocations:
• Amar holds with an own valuation of .
• Barat holds with an own valuation of .
• Charles holds with an own valuation of .
• Disha holds with an own valuation of .
• Elise holds with an own valuation of .
• Envy Constraints Under Clue 6:
• Person envies person iff .
• Clue 6 strictly dictates that people scoring 16 cannot envy anyone.
• Hence, Barat, Charles, and Elise cannot envy anyone.
• Verifying 16-Valued Participants:
• Barat evaluates Amar at 12, Charles at 15, Disha at 10, Elise at 13; none exceed 16 Barat envies no one.
• Charles evaluates Amar at 12, Barat at 14, Disha at 11, Elise at 12; none exceed 16 Charles envies no one.
• Elise evaluates Amar at 13, Barat at 13, Charles at 12, Disha at 11; none exceed 16 Elise envies no one.
• Evaluating Amar's Valuations:
• Amar values his own bundle at 12.
• Amar evaluates Barat's bundle at Amar envies Barat!
• Amar evaluates Charles's bundle at Amar envies Charles!
• Both envied individuals score 16, fully conforming to Clue 6.
• Option Matching:
• Among the options, only Amar envies someone else.
• Matches Option 4 (Amar).
Topper Take
• Elimination Shortcut: Clue 6 bans anyone with a bundle value of 16 from envying anyone. Since Barat, Charles, and Elise all score 16, they cannot envy anyone. Only Amar (value 12) can envy, immediately pointing to Option 4.
Other questions in this set
- Q15. What BEST can be said about object o8?
- Q17. What is Amar's value for his own bundle?
- Q18. Object o4 was given to
- Q19. Object o5 was given to
- Q20. What BEST can be said about the distribution of object o1?
Games & Tournaments questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q14
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q15
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q16
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q17
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q18
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc