CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q18
- Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
- Logical Reasoning › Games & Tournaments
- Hard
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2025_SLOT1_DILR_Q18
Data set · questions 14–18
At InnovateX, six employees, Asha, Bunty, Chintu, Dolly, Eklavya, and Falguni, were split into two groups of three each: Elite led by Manager Kuku, and Novice led by Manager Lalu.
At the end of each quarter, Kuku and Lalu handed out ratings to all members in their respective groups. In each group, each employee received a distinct integer rating from 1 to 3.
The score for an employee at the end of a quarter is defined as their cumulative rating from the beginning of the year. At the end of each quarter the employee in Novice with the highest score was promoted to Elite, and the employee in Elite with the minimum score was demoted to Novice. If there was a tie in scores, the employee with a higher rating in the latest quarter was ranked higher.
-
Asha, Bunty, and Chintu were in Elite at the beginning of Quarter 1. All of them were in Novice at the beginning of Quarter 4.
-
Dolly and Falguni were the only employees who got the same rating across all the quarters.
-
The following is known about ratings given by Lalu:
• Bunty received a rating of 1 in Quarter 2.
• Asha and Dolly received ratings of 1 and 2, respectively, in Quarter 3.
Question 18
Which of the following statements is/are NECESSARILY true?
I. Asha received a rating of 2 in Quarter 1.
II. Asha received a rating of 1 in Quarter 2.
Show answer and solution
Answer: (C)
Only II
Solution
Concept: Dynamic Group Partitioning & Rating Invariants
Master State Table
| Employee | Q1 Group | Q1 Rating | Q2 Group | Q2 Rating | Q3 Group | Q3 Rating | Score End Q1 | Score End Q2 | Score End Q3 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Asha | Elite | 2 or 3 | Elite | 1 | Novice | 1 | 2 or 3 | 3 or 4 | 4 or 5 |
| Bunty | Elite | 1 | Novice | 1 | Novice | 3 | 1 | 2 | 5 |
| Chintu | Elite | 3 or 2 | Elite | 2 | Elite | 1 | 3 or 2 | 5 or 4 | 6 or 5 |
| Dolly | Novice | 2 | Novice | 2 | Novice | 2 | 2 | 4 | 6 |
| Eklavya | Novice | 1 | Novice | 3 | Elite | 2 | 1 | 4 | 6 |
| Falguni | Novice | 3 | Elite | 3 | Elite | 3 | 3 | 6 | 9 |
Question Deduction
We evaluate the necessity of Statements I and II individually:
• Evaluation of Statement I: "Asha received a rating of 2 in Quarter 1."
• In Q1, Elite comprised Asha, Bunty, and Chintu. Bunty received rating 1 (lowest score in Elite, demoted at end of Q1).
• The remaining available ratings in Elite are split between Asha and Chintu.
• Let us verify whether Asha receiving 3 in Q1 (and Chintu receiving 2) is logically consistent:
• Assume and .
• In Q2 Elite (Asha, Chintu, Falguni): Falguni has rating 3. If Asha has rating 1 and Chintu has rating 2, their cumulative scores at the end of Q2 are:
• Asha and Chintu tie on cumulative score at 4. Applying the tie-break rule: "the employee with a higher rating in the latest quarter was ranked higher."
• In Q2, Chintu's rating was 2 and Asha's rating was 1. Thus, Chintu ranks higher, meaning Asha is ranked lower and suffers demotion to Novice at the end of Q2.
• In Q3 Elite (Chintu, Eklavya, Falguni): Falguni has rating 3, Eklavya has rating 2, Chintu has rating 1. Cumulative scores at the end of Q3 are:
• Chintu holds the strictly lowest score (5) and is demoted to Novice at the end of Q3.
• Furthermore, Asha's ratings across quarters are and Chintu's are ; neither has identical ratings across all quarters, upholding Clue 2.
• Because a completely valid world exists in which Asha received a rating of 3 in Quarter 1, Statement I is NOT necessarily true.
• Evaluation of Statement II: "Asha received a rating of 1 in Quarter 2."
• In Q2, Elite comprised Asha, Chintu, and Falguni. Falguni received her invariant rating of 3.
• The remaining ratings in Elite must be partitioned between Asha and Chintu.
• Asha is demoted at the end of Q2, so Asha must be ranked lower than Chintu.
• Suppose for contradiction that Asha received rating 2 in Q2 (so Chintu received rating 1):
• Sub-case A: and .
• End of Q2 scores: , .
• Tied at 4 points. Latest quarter ratings: Asha has 2, Chintu has 1. Asha is ranked higher than Chintu.
• Chintu would be demoted instead of Asha. Contradiction!
• Sub-case B: and .
• End of Q2 scores: , .
• Chintu holds the strictly lower score (3 < 5).
• Chintu would be demoted instead of Asha. Contradiction!
• Under both possibilities for Q1, assigning rating 2 to Asha forces Chintu to be demoted at the end of Q2.
• Therefore, Asha MUST receive a rating of 1 in Q2 (and Chintu receives 2).
• Hence, Statement II is NECESSARILY true.
• Conclusion:
• Statement I is not necessarily true, whereas Statement II is necessarily true.
• This corresponds strictly to Option 3 ("Only II").
Topper Take
• The "Necessarily True" vs. "Could Be True" Distinction: CAT frequently tests the modal logic distinction between necessarily true (true in 100% of valid configurations) and could be true (true in at least one valid configuration). Statement I is could be true (50% probability across valid worlds), which tempts candidates into incorrectly picking "Both I and II" (Option 4).
• Contradiction-Driven Deduction for Statement II: When asked if a rating is necessarily a specific value, assume the alternative and test both branches. Showing that the alternative causes a contradiction in all branches guarantees necessity in seconds.
Other questions in this set
- Q14. What was Eklavya’s score at the end of Quarter 2?
- Q15. How many employees changed groups more than once up to the beginning of Quarter 4?
- Q16. What was Bunty’s score at the end of Quarter 3?
- Q17. For how many employees can the scores at the end of Quarter 3 be determined with certainty?
Games & Tournaments questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q1
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q2
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q3
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q4
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q5
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc