CAT 2019 Slot 1 DILR Q32

  • Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
  • Data Interpretation › Other Charts
  • Easy
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2019_SLOT1_DILR_Q32

Data set · questions 29–32

Five vendors are being considered for a service. The evaluation committee evaluated each vendor on six aspects – Cost, Customer Service, Features, Quality, Reach, and Reliability. Each of these evaluations are on a scale of 0 (worst) to 100 (perfect). The evaluation scores on these aspects are shown in the radar chart. For example, Vendor 1 obtains a score of 52 on Reliability, Vendor 2 obtains a score of 45 on Features and Vendor 3 obtains a score of 90 on Cos

Diagram

Question 32

List of all the vendors who are among the top three vendors on all six aspects is:

  1. A

    Vendor 1

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    None of the Vendors

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    Vendor 3

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    Vendor 1 and Vendor 3

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (C)

Vendor 3

Solution

Concept: Universal Quantifier Verification, Top-3 Boundary Conditions & Elimination Triage

Master State Table

Evaluation AspectVendor 1Vendor 2Vendor 3Vendor 4Vendor 5Aspect Extremes
Reliability5240752660Min: 26 (V4), Max: 75 (V3)
Reach8058634670Min: 46 (V4), Max: 80 (V1)
Quality7269624048Min: 40 (V4), Max: 72 (V1)
Features4045569075Min: 40 (V1), Max: 90 (V4)
Customer Service5541507028Min: 28 (V5), Max: 70 (V4)
Cost7781907150Min: 50 (V5), Max: 90 (V3)

Question Deduction

• Analytical Framework for Universal Top-Three Membership:

• We must identify all vendors VkV_k satisfying the universal property:

$$\forall j \in \{\text{Reliability, Reach, Quality, Features, Customer Service, Cost}\}, \quad \text{Rank}(V_k, j) \le 3$$

• A vendor ranking 4th or 5th (bottom two) on even a single aspect is immediately disqualified by counterexample.

• Aspect-Wise Top-Three Scorers:

• Reliability: Top 3 are Vendor 3 (7575), Vendor 5 (6060), Vendor 1 (5252). (V2: 40, V4: 26 excluded).

• Reach: Top 3 are Vendor 1 (8080), Vendor 5 (7070), Vendor 3 (6363). (V2: 58, V4: 46 excluded).

• Quality: Top 3 are Vendor 1 (7272), Vendor 2 (6969), Vendor 3 (6262). (V5: 48, V4: 40 excluded).

• Features: Top 3 are Vendor 4 (9090), Vendor 5 (7575), Vendor 3 (5656). (V2: 45, V1: 40 excluded).

• Customer Service: Top 3 are Vendor 4 (7070), Vendor 1 (5555), Vendor 3 (5050). (V2: 41, V5: 28 excluded).

• Cost: Top 3 are Vendor 3 (9090), Vendor 2 (8181), Vendor 1 (7777). (V4: 71, V5: 50 excluded).

• Disqualification Audit & Vendor 3 Validation:

• Vendor 1: Scores in top 3 on 5 aspects, but on Features scores 4040 (5th)   ⟹  \implies Disqualified.

• Vendor 2: Ranks 4th on Reliability (4040), Reach (5858), Features (4545), Customer Service (4141)   ⟹  \implies Disqualified.

• Vendor 4: Ranks 5th on Reliability (2626), Reach (4646), Quality (4040), and 4th on Cost (7171)   ⟹  \implies Disqualified.

• Vendor 5: Ranks 4th on Quality (4848), 5th on Customer Service (2828), 5th on Cost (5050)   ⟹  \implies Disqualified.

• Vendor 3 Full Verification:

• Reliability ($75$, 1st), Reach ($63$, 3rd), Quality ($62$, 3rd), Features ($56$, 3rd), Customer Service ($50$, 3rd), Cost ($90$, 1st).

• In all six aspects, $\text{Rank}(V_3, j) \le 3$, satisfying the condition without exception.

• Option Matching / Numerical Answer:

• Matches Option 3 ("Vendor 3").

• Distractors fail: Option 1 and Option 4 fail due to Vendor 1's 5th place on Features; Option 2 fails as Vendor 3 satisfies all criteria.

Topper Take

• Fail-fast elimination principle: do not verify all 6 aspects for every vendor. Check the options, find one weakness (rank 4 or 5) for candidate vendors, and disqualify immediately.

• Vendor 1 scores 40 on Features (tied for lowest on the entire grid), eliminating Option 1 and Option 4 in 5 seconds. Verifying Vendor 3 takes under 15 seconds.

Other questions in this set

  1. Q29. On which aspect is the median score of the five vendors the least?
  2. Q30. A vendor's final score is the average of their scores on all six aspects. Which vendor has the highest final score?
  3. Q31. List of all the vendors who are among the top two scorers on the maximum number of aspects is:

Other Charts questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q1
    How much is Japan's export to India worth?
  2. CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q2
    Which among the following is the highest?
  3. CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q3
    What is the trade surplus/trade deficit of India with UK?
  4. CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q4
    Among France and UK, who has/have trade surplus(es) with US?
  5. CAT 2025 Slot 3 DILR Q6
    Who had solved the largest number of puzzles by the 20-th minute from the start of the competition?

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc