Pipes & Cisterns: Inlets, Outlets & Drainage Leaks
Master the hydrodynamic model of reservoirs, positive inlet filling rates, negative outlet emptying rates, concealed bottom leaks, and elevated leaks positioned at fractional tank heights.
1. The Story & Mental Model: The Hydrodynamic Reservoir
Think of a water cistern not as a math problem, but as an active liquid bank account:
-
Inlet Pipes make continuous cash deposits ().
-
Outlet Pipes & Leaks make continuous cash withdrawals ().
The volume of liquid in the tank at any minute is simply the initial balance plus the net sum of all deposits and withdrawals:
If the net rate is positive (), the tank fills up. If the net rate is negative (), an initially full tank drains toward empty.
2. The CAT Question Blueprint: The Structural Traps
CAT exam setters take standard time-and-work principles and add physical hydraulic constraints:
-
The Concealed Bottom Leak: An inlet pipe takes hours normally, but with a leak at the bottom, it takes hours (). You must isolate the leak's solo draining rate.
-
Staggered Clock Synchronizations: Pipe A opens at 8:00 AM, Pipe B opens at 9:00 AM, Drain C opens at 10:30 AM. At what exact clock time does the cistern overflow or run dry?
-
Elevated Fractional Height Leaks: A leak is situated at of the tank's height. The leak CANNOT drain the bottom of the tank! It only acts on liquid that rises above its physical level.
-
Diameter and Flow Scaling: By Poiseuille's / Torricelli's hydraulic laws, rate of flow through a circular pipe is proportional to the cross-sectional area:
3. The Single Tactical Weapon: The Master Hydraulic Balance
A. Capacity via LCM:
-
Inlet efficiency is positive:
-
Outlet efficiency is negative:
B. The Concealed Leak Formula:
If inlet fills in hours, but with leak takes hours ():
C. Elevated Leak at Height Fraction :
For a leak located at fraction of the total height (from bottom):
-
Phase 1 (Bottom fraction ): Only inlet pipe operates. Leak is inactive!
-
Phase 2 (Top fraction ): Both inlet and leak operate.
4. The Classic Exam Trap & Speed Shortcut
The Spill-Over Alternating Trap:
In alternating inlet/outlet problems (Inlet open 1 min, Outlet open 1 min), once the water reaches the tank's brim, THE TANK IS FULL! It does not wait for the outlet to pull it back down.
Rule: Subtract the single-cycle inlet rate before finding full cycles, exactly like the slipping monkey problem!
Formulas
| Net Filling Rate Equation | |
|---|---|
| Bottom Leak Solo Emptying Time | |
| Pipe Diameter Scaling Law | |
| Elevated Leak Phase Split |
Traps and tips
- Always assign a negative sign to drainage pipes and leaks before summing efficiencies.
- An elevated leak only affects the liquid volume above its physical elevation—it cannot drain liquid below itself.
- If pipe diameters are given, square the diameter ratio to find the ratio of their filling rates.
- In alternating inlet-outlet problems, subtract the inlet's one-minute capacity from total volume to avoid overcounting past the overflow point.
Solved examples
Example 1: Two Inlets and One Waste Pipe
A storage reservoir can be filled by Pipe A in 12 hours and by Pipe B in 15 hours. A drainage waste Pipe C can empty the full reservoir in 20 hours. If all three pipes are opened simultaneously when the reservoir is completely empty, how many hours will it take to fill the reservoir to brim?
Show solution
Step 1: Set Tank Capacity using LCM.
Step 2: Determine rates (with correct signs).
-
Inlet A:
-
Inlet B:
-
Drain C:
Step 3: Calculate net filling rate.
Step 4: Compute filling duration.
Takeaway: Treat inlets as positive contributions and drains as negative subtractions to find net throughput.
Example 2: The Concealed Bottom Leak
An automated inlet valve usually fills a municipal water tank in 8 hours. However, due to an unnoticed crack at the bottom of the tank, it takes 10 hours to fill the tank completely. If the tank is filled to full capacity and the inlet valve is closed, in how many hours will the crack empty the entire tank?
Show solution
Step 1: Set Tank Capacity using LCM.
Step 2: Find inlet and combined rates.
-
Normal inlet rate:
-
Net rate with crack:
Step 3: Isolate crack draining rate.
Step 4: Time for crack to empty full tank.
(Using shortcut formula: hours).
Takeaway: The leak's draining rate is simply the difference between the rated inlet speed and the observed net speed.
Example 3: Staggered Clock Opening with Overflow
Three pipes—X, Y, and Z—are connected to a cistern. Pipe X fills in 3 hours, Pipe Y fills in 4 hours, and Drain Pipe Z empties in 2 hours. The cistern is initially empty. Pipe X is opened at 6:00 AM, Pipe Y is opened at 7:00 AM, and Drain Pipe Z is opened at 8:00 AM. At what exact clock time will the cistern be completely empty again?
Show solution
Step 1: Set Tank Capacity using LCM.
-
Pipe X:
-
Pipe Y:
-
Drain Z:
Step 2: Track liquid volume accumulated up to 8:00 AM.
-
From 6:00 AM to 7:00 AM (1 hour): Only X is open.
-
From 7:00 AM to 8:00 AM (1 hour): Both X and Y are open.
At 8:00 AM, the cistern contains units of water.
Step 3: Determine net rate after 8:00 AM.
At 8:00 AM, Pipe Z opens:
Since , the tank is FILLING, not emptying! It will fill the remaining unit in hour (at 9:00 AM) and overflow!
(If Drain Z were faster, say units/h, net rate would be negative and it would empty).
To illustrate emptying, let Drain Z empty in 1 hour ( units/h):
Takeaway: Calculate accumulated volume at the exact moment the drain opens, then divide by the net rate.
Example 4: Elevated Leak at Fractional Height
A cylindrical storage tank of capacity 480 liters is fitted with an inlet pipe that can fill it in 12 hours. At a height equal to of the tank from the bottom, a leak pipe is installed that can empty the portion of the tank above it in 6 hours. If the tank is initially empty and the inlet is opened, how many total hours will it take to fill the tank completely?
Show solution
Step 1: Divide the tank into two physical zones.
Total capacity liters.
-
Zone 1 (Bottom ):
-
Zone 2 (Top ):
Step 2: Determine rates.
-
Inlet rate:
-
Leak rate: The leak empties the top liters in 6 hours:
Step 3: Compute filling times for each zone.
-
Filling Zone 1 (0 to 360 L):
The water level is below the leak, so the leak is completely inactive!
-
Filling Zone 2 (360 to 480 L):
The water level is above the leak, so both inlet and leak are active:
Step 4: Total filling time.
Takeaway: Deconstruct elevated leak problems into distinct vertical tiers: leaks can never drain liquid below their installation point.
Example 5: Alternating Minute Cycle with Overflow Threshold
Inlet Pipe A can fill an empty cistern in 6 minutes, while Outlet Pipe B can empty the full cistern in 8 minutes. Starting with an empty cistern, Pipe A is opened for the 1st minute, closed, then Pipe B is opened for the 2nd minute, closed, and this alternating 1-minute cycle continues. In how many minutes will the cistern first become full?
Show solution
Step 1: Set Capacity using LCM.
-
Inlet A:
-
Outlet B:
Step 2: 2-Minute Cycle Net Progress.
Step 3: The Overflow Threshold.
Once Pipe A fills the tank to units during its turn, the tank is FULL and the process stops immediately!
Subtract Pipe A's 1-minute capacity to find the safe cycle threshold:
To reach units of net progress:
Step 4: Final minute.
At Minute 41, Pipe A opens:
The cistern becomes full at exactly minute 41!
Takeaway: In alternating fill-drain sequences, deduct the inlet's single-minute capacity from total volume to avoid overcounting past the overflow point.
Example 6: Pipe Diameter and Cross-Sectional Flow Law
Three circular pipes of diameters 1 cm, 2 cm, and 3 cm are connected to a water tank. The rate of water flow through any pipe is directly proportional to the square of its diameter. The widest pipe running alone can fill the tank in 42 minutes. How many minutes will it take to fill the tank if all three pipes are opened simultaneously?
Show solution
Step 1: Determine flow rates from diameter squared.
-
Pipe 1 ():
-
Pipe 2 ():
-
Pipe 3 ():
Step 2: Find total tank capacity.
The widest pipe (Pipe 3, rate units/min) fills the tank in 42 minutes:
Step 3: Combined rate of all three pipes.
Step 4: Simultaneous filling time.
Takeaway: Square pipe diameters to establish flow rates, then multiply by known completion time to determine tank capacity.
Practice questions
Question 1 · CAT Level
A vertical cylindrical water reservoir of capacity is filled by an inlet pipe in . Two drainage leaks are located on the reservoir wall: Leak 1 at a height of from the bottom (which can empty the portion above it in ), and Leak 2 at a height of from the bottom (which can empty the portion above it in ). If the reservoir is initially empty and the inlet pipe is opened, how many total hours will it take to fill the reservoir completely?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (C) 19 hours
Inlet rate . Divide into three vertical zones.
Zone 1 ( to ): Neither leak active .
Leak 1 empties top in .
Zone 2 ( to ): Only Leak 1 active .
Leak 2 empties top in .
Zone 3 ( to ): Both leaks active .
Total filling duration .
Question 2 · CAT Level
A cistern is fitted with two inlet pipes, A and B, and one drainage pipe, C. Pipe A fills the cistern alone in minutes, Pipe B fills it in minutes, and Pipe C empties it in minutes. Starting from an empty cistern, the pipes are operated in a repeating -minute sequence: Pipe A alone during Minute 1, Pipe B alone during Minute 2, and Pipe C alone during Minute 3. If the cistern is considered full the instant the water level first reaches the brim, after how many minutes will the cistern become full?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (C) 281/4 minutes
Let capacity . Rates: , , .
Net progress per -minute cycle .
Peak threshold: In full cycles (), volume is .
Cycle 9: Minute 25 (A) reaches ; Minute 26 (B) reaches ; Minute 27 (C) drops to .
Cycle 10: Minute 28 (A) reaches . Remaining volume to full brim .
Minute 29 (B): Rate is , taking to fill the final unit.
Total time .
Question 3 · CAT Level
Three circular inlet pipes have diameters in the ratio . The rate of water flow through each pipe is directly proportional to the square of its diameter. Working together at rated capacity, the three pipes fill an empty cistern in minutes. An emergency drain pipe can empty the full cistern in minutes. If the largest inlet pipe operates at only of its rated capacity due to partial clogging while the other two inlets and the drain pipe operate normally, how many minutes will it take to fill the empty cistern?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (C) 36 minutes
Flow rates follow , so .
Combined normal inlet rate Capacity .
Drain rate .
Under clogged conditions, the largest inlet delivers .
New total inlet rate .
Net filling rate Time required .
Question 4 · CAT Level
A cistern has two inlet pipes, A and B, and one high-capacity drain pipe, C. Pipe A fills the cistern alone in hours, Pipe B fills it in hours, and Pipe C empties it alone in hours. The cistern is empty at 7:00 AM. Pipe A is opened at 7:00 AM, Pipe B is also opened at 9:00 AM, and Drain Pipe C is opened at 10:00 AM. At what exact clock time will the cistern be completely empty again?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (B) 1:00 PM
Let capacity . Rates: , , .
From 7:00 to 9:00 AM (, A only): Water added .
From 9:00 to 10:00 AM (, A and B): Water added .
Total water accumulated at 10:00 AM .
After 10:00 AM, all pipes are open: .
Time to completely empty .
Question 5 · CAT Level
Two inlet pipes, P and Q, can fill a reservoir in hours working together. If P runs for hours and Q runs for hours, they fill of the reservoir. A drain leak is installed at a height equal to of the reservoir from the bottom; when water rises above this level, the leak discharges at a constant rate that empties the top of the reservoir in hours. If both P and Q are opened simultaneously from an empty reservoir, how many total hours will it take to fill the reservoir completely?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (C) 21 hours
Let . Given , and .
Let capacity , (combined inlet ).
Zone 1 (bottom ): Leak is inactive .
Leak empties the top in .
Zone 2 (top ): Net rate .
Total filling time .
Try real CAT questions
Study this concept with interactive practice in PrepSoc.
Open the concept library