CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q23

  • Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
  • Reading Comprehension › History
  • Medium
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2025_SLOT3_VARC_Q23

Passage · questions 21–24

In 1982, a raging controversy broke out over a forest act drafted by the Government of India. This act sought to strengthen the already extensive powers enjoyed by the forest bureaucracy in controlling the extraction, disposal and sale of forest produce. It also gave forest officials greater powers to strictly regulate the entry of any person into reserved forest areas. While forest officials justified the act on the grounds that it was necessary to stop the continuing deforestation, it was bitterly opposed by representatives of grassroots organisations, who argued that it was a major violation of the rights of peasants and tribals living in and around forest areas. . . .

The debate over the draft forest act fuelled a larger controversy over the orientation of state forest policy. It was pointed out, for example, that the draft act was closely modelled on its predecessor, the Forest Act of 1878. The earlier Act rested on a usurpation of rights of ownership by the colonial state which had little precedent in precolonial history. It was further argued that the system of forestry introduced by the British—and continued, with little modification, after 1947—emphasised revenue generation and commercial exploitation, while its policing orientation excluded villagers who had the most longstanding claim on forest resources. Critics called for a complete overhaul of forest administration, pressing the government to formulate policy and legislation more appropriate to present needs. . . .

That debate is not over yet. The draft act was shelved, though it has not as yet been formally withdrawn. Meanwhile, the 1878 Act (as modified by an amendment in 1927) continues to be in operation. In response to its critics, the government has made some important changes in forest policy, e.g., no longer treating forests as a source of revenue, and stopping ecologically hazardous practices such as the clearfelling of natural forests. At the same time, it has shown little inclination to meet the major demand of the critics of forest policy—namely, abandoning the principle of state monopoly over forest land by handing over areas of degraded forests to individuals and communities for afforestation.

. . . [The] 1878 Forest Act itself was passed only after a bitter and prolonged debate within the colonial bureaucracy, in which protagonists put forward arguments strikingly similar to those being advanced today. As is well known, the Indian Forest Department owes its origin to the requirements of railway companies. The early years of the expansion of the railway network, c. 1853 onwards, led to tremendous deforestation in peninsular India owing to the railway’s requirements of fuelwood and construction timber. Huge quantities of durable timbers were also needed for use as sleepers across the newly laid tracks. Inexperienced in forestry, the British called in German experts to commence systematic forest management. The Indian Forest Department was started in 1864, with Dietrich Brandis, formerly a Lecturer at Bonn, as the first Inspector General of Forests. The new department needed legislative backing to function effectively, and in the following year, 1865, the first forest act was passed. . . .

Question 23

All of the following, if true, would weaken the narrative presented in the passage EXCEPT that:

  1. A

    certain tribal groups in India are responsible for climate change because their sustenance has historically depended on mass scale deforestation.

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    before British rule, peasants and tribal groups were denied access to forest resources by Indian rulers and their administrations.

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    nineteenth century German forestry experts were infamous for violating the rights of indigenous communities that lived in forest regions.

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    the timber requirement for railway works in nineteenth century India was met through import from China, in exchange for spices.

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (C)

nineteenth century German forestry experts were infamous for violating the rights of indigenous communities that lived in forest regions.

Solution

🎯 Question Analysis & Solution

  • Question Type: Argument Evaluation / Weaken Except Question

  • Passage Reference:

Paragraph 1 & 2: Grassroots critics argue that British and post-colonial forestry usurped the customary rights of peasants and tribals, who have the "most longstanding claim on forest resources."

Paragraph 2: "The earlier Act rested on a usurpation of rights of ownership by the colonial state which had little precedent in precolonial history."

Paragraph 4: "As is well known, the Indian Forest Department owes its origin to the requirements of railway companies. The early years of the expansion of the railway network, c. 1853 onwards, led to tremendous deforestation in peninsular India owing to the railway’s requirements of fuelwood and construction timber. Huge quantities of durable timbers were also needed for use as sleepers across the newly laid tracks. Inexperienced in forestry, the British called in German experts to commence systematic forest management."

Logical Deduction

  1. The question stem requires identifying the claim that, if true, does NOT weaken the passage's narrative. Three choices will undermine key empirical or historical premises of the author's argument, whereas the correct choice will support, corroborate, or remain consistent with it.

  2. The author's central narrative contends that:

    • Peasants and tribals are customary, sustainable custodians whose rights were unjustly usurped;

    • State usurpation had no precedent in precolonial Indian history;

    • Massive deforestation was driven by British railway construction demanding timber and sleepers;

    • German experts were recruited by the colonial administration to establish this exclusionary, state-controlled forestry apparatus.

  3. Evaluating Option 3: "nineteenth century German forestry experts were infamous for violating the rights of indigenous communities that lived in forest regions."

    • Paragraph 4 notes that British authorities recruited German experts (Dietrich Brandis) to institute systematic forestry in India.

    • If German forestry experts had an established reputation for violating the rights of forest-dwelling indigenous peoples, this fact directly bolsters the author's narrative that the bureaucratic forestry system they erected in India was intrinsically anti-indigenous and rights-violating.

    • Because this premise reinforces the author's central critique of colonial forestry, it does not weaken the narrative. Hence, Option 3 is the correct exception.

Correct Answer: Option 3

  • Bolsters the author's core thesis by demonstrating that the foreign experts imported to design India's forestry apparatus had a recognized history of violating indigenous rights, thereby strengthening rather than weakening the passage's critique of colonial forestry.

Option Elimination

  • Option 1 (Weakens Narrative / Subverts Moral Baseline): The passage presents tribals as victims with legitimate claims whose exclusion was unwarranted. If tribals were historically responsible for mass deforestation causing climate change, it would validate bureaucratic claims that tribals must be strictly excluded to preserve forests, dismantling the author's argument.

  • Option 2 (Weakens Narrative / Direct Historical Falsification): Paragraph 2 explicitly asserts that the British usurpation of forest ownership "had little precedent in precolonial history." Demonstrating that precolonial Indian rulers routinely excluded peasants and tribals would directly falsify this foundational premise.

  • Option 4 (Weakens Narrative / Collapses Causal Chain): Paragraph 4 attributes 19th-century deforestation and the subsequent creation of the Forest Department to domestic railway timber requirements. If railway timber was imported from China, the central historical catalyst linking railway expansion to Indian deforestation and forest legislation would collapse.

Detailed explanation

📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure

Central Theme

The historical continuity and structural contestation of Indian state forest policy, tracing the 1982 draft forest act back to its colonial roots in the 1878 Forest Act and 19th-century railway expansion. The author critiques how the modern post-colonial state perpetuated British colonial principles of bureaucratic monopoly, resource extraction, and the systematic exclusion of peasants and tribals. While contemporary environmental resistance compelled the state to stop revenue-focused clearfelling, the government steadfastly refuses to relinquish its territorial monopoly or transfer degraded forests to community-led afforestation.

Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary

  • Paragraph 1: Chronicles the 1982 uproar over the Government of India's draft forest act, which aimed to expand bureaucratic powers over forest produce and reserved areas, inciting fierce resistance from grassroots advocates defending the customary rights of peasants and tribals.

  • Paragraph 2: Explains how the specific 1982 dispute widened into a systemic critique of state forest policy, exposing how the draft replicated the colonial 1878 Act's historical usurpation of ownership rights, commercial extraction priorities, and exclusionary policing apparatus.

  • Paragraph 3: Outlines the unresolved status of the debate: though the 1982 draft was shelved and revenue-driven clearfelling halted, the state steadfastly preserves its colonial territorial monopoly by refusing to transfer degraded forest lands to local communities for afforestation.

  • Paragraph 4: Traces the historical origin of Indian state forestry to British railway expansion in the 1850s, which caused massive deforestation for sleepers and fuelwood, prompting the British to recruit German experts like Dietrich Brandis and enact the foundational 1865 and 1878 legislative frameworks.

Tone and Author's Perspective

  • Tone: Critical, Historical-Analytical, Evaluative, and Scholarly.

  • Author's Perspective: Critical of bureaucratic inertia and neo-colonial state monopolies. The author highlights the legitimate customary claims of forest-dwelling communities, demonstrating that modern Indian forest governance remains heavily burdened by colonial commercial and policing frameworks.

Other questions in this set

  1. Q21. According to the passage, which one of the following reforms is yet to happen in India’s forest policies?
  2. Q22. According to the passage, which one of the following is not common to the 1878 Forest Act and the 1982 draft forest act?
  3. Q24. Which one of the following best encapsulates the reason for the “raging controversy” developing into a “larger…

History questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2023 Slot 3 VARC Q13
    On the basis of information in the passage, which one of the following is NOT a reason for the failure of…
  2. CAT 2023 Slot 3 VARC Q14
    Which one of the following, if true, would make the reviewer's choice of the pronoun "who" for Gaia…
  3. CAT 2023 Slot 3 VARC Q15
    Which one of the following best explains the primary purpose of the discussion of the colonisation of the…
  4. CAT 2023 Slot 3 VARC Q16
    All of the following can be inferred from the reviewer's discussion of "The Nutmeg's Curse", EXCEPT:
  5. CAT 2021 Slot 3 VARC Q9
    Which one of the following statements best describes what the passage is about?

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc