CAT 2023 Slot 3 VARC Q14

  • Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
  • Reading Comprehension › History
  • Medium
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2023_SLOT3_VARC_Q14

Passage · questions 13–16

The biggest challenge [The Nutmeg’s Curse by Ghosh] throws down is to the prevailing understanding of when the climate crisis started. Most of us have accepted... that it started with the widespread use of coal at the beginning of the Industrial Age in the 18th century and worsened with the mass adoption of oil and natural gas in the 20th. Ghosh takes this history at least three centuries back, to the start of European colonialism in the 15th century. He [starts] the book with a 1621 massacre by Dutch invaders determined to impose a monopoly on nutmeg cultivation and trade in the Banda islands in today’s Indonesia. Not only do the Dutch systematically depopulate the islands through genocide, they also try their best to bring nutmeg cultivation into plantation mode. These are the two points to which Ghosh returns through examples from around the world. One, how European colonialists decimated not only indigenous populations but also indigenous understanding of the relationship between humans and Earth. Two, how this was an invasion not only of humans but of the Earth itself, and how this continues to the present day by looking at nature as a ‘resource’ to exploit...

We know we are facing more frequent and more severe heatwaves, storms, floods, droughts and wildfires due to climate change. We know our expansion through deforestation, dam building, canal cutting - in short, terraforming, the word Ghosh uses - has brought us repeated disasters... Are these the responses of an angry Gaia who has finally had enough? By using the word ‘curse’ in the title, the author makes it clear that he thinks so. I use the pronoun ‘who’ knowingly, because Ghosh has quoted many non-European sources to enquire into the relationship between humans and the world around them so that he can question the prevalent way of looking at Earth as an inert object to be exploited to the maximum.

As Ghosh’s text, notes and bibliography show once more, none of this is new. There have always been challenges to the way European colonialists looked at other civilisations and at Earth. It is just that the invaders and their myriad backers in the fields of economics, politics, anthropology, philosophy, literature, technology, physics, chemistry, biology have dominated global intellectual discourse...

There are other points of view that we can hear today if we listen hard enough. Those observing global climate negotiations know about the Latin American way of looking at Earth as Pachamama (Earth Mother). They also know how such a framing is just provided lip service and is ignored in the substantive portions of the negotiations. In The Nutmeg’s Curse, Ghosh explains why. He shows the extent of the vested interest in the oil economy - not only for oil-exporting countries, but also for a superpower like the US that controls oil drilling, oil prices and oil movement around the world. Many of us know power utilities are sabotaging decentralised solar power generation today because it hits their revenues and control. And how the other points of view are so often drowned out.

Question 14

Which one of the following, if true, would make the reviewer's choice of the pronoun "who" for Gaia Inappropriate?

  1. A

    There is a direct cause-effect relationship between human activities and global climate change.

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    Ghosh's book has a different title: “The Nutmeg's Revenge”.

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    Modem western science discovers new evidence for the Earth being an inanimate object.

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    Non-European societies have perceived the Earth as a non-living source of all resources.

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (D)

Non-European societies have perceived the Earth as a non-living source of all resources.

Solution

🎯 Question Analysis & Solution

  • Question Type: Critical Reasoning / Assumption & Invalidation

  • Passage Reference:

"Are these the responses of an angry Gaia who has finally had enough? By using the word ‘curse’ in the title, the author makes it clear that he thinks so. I use the pronoun ‘who’ knowingly, because Ghosh has quoted many non-European sources to enquire into the relationship between humans and the world around them so that he can question the prevalent way of looking at Earth as an inert object to be exploited to the maximum."

Logical Deduction

The reviewer explicitly justifies their deliberate choice of the animate pronoun "who" for Gaia on a specific premise: Ghosh draws upon "many non-European sources" to challenge the dominant Western view of the Earth as an "inert object to be exploited to the maximum." The choice of "who" is thus explicitly rooted in non-European ecological traditions that personify the Earth as a living, animate subject.

If Option 4 is true—that non-European societies historically perceived the Earth as a non-living source of all resources—then the foundational rationale supplied by the reviewer collapses entirely. There would be no basis in non-European thought to challenge the "inert object" paradigm, making the reviewer's justification invalid and the choice of the pronoun "who" inappropriate.

Correct Answer: Option 4

  • Option 4 is correct because the reviewer explicitly defends using "who" by appealing to non-European worldviews that reject the idea of Earth as an inert object; if non-European societies actually viewed Earth as non-living, the justification for personifying Gaia with "who" is completely invalidated.

Option Elimination

  • Option 1 (Irrelevant / Out of Scope): A direct cause-effect link between human activity and climate disasters confirms anthropogenic environmental degradation; it does not invalidate conceiving of Gaia as a living entity reacting to that devastation.

  • Option 2 (Opposite Effect / Reinforcing Detail): Titling the book "The Nutmeg's Revenge" would ascribe even greater personal agency and active retaliation to nature, making the animate pronoun "who" even more fitting.

  • Option 3 (Inconsequential / Existing Premise): The passage already acknowledges that Western science and colonial thought historically view the Earth as an inert object. Additional Western evidence merely reaffirms the exact viewpoint that the reviewer and Ghosh are deliberately rejecting.

Detailed explanation

📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure

Central Theme

A critical analysis of Amitav Ghosh's The Nutmeg's Curse, which reconceptualizes the history of the climate crisis by tracing its origins back three centuries earlier than the Industrial Revolution—to 15th-century European colonialism, the violent decimation of indigenous populations and their holistic nature-centric worldviews, and the systemic commodification of the Earth into an exploitable resource backed by Western intellectual and economic hegemony.

Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary

  • Paragraph 1: Details Amitav Ghosh's primary thesis, which challenges the conventional timeline attributing climate change solely to 18th-century fossil fuel use during the Industrial Revolution. Ghosh dates the crisis to 15th-century European colonialism, using the 1621 Dutch massacre in the Banda Islands to exemplify two central dynamics: the violent annihilation of indigenous populations alongside their ecocentric worldviews, and the colonial invasion of nature itself through extractive plantation economies that reduced the Earth to a resource.

  • Paragraph 2: Explores the modern consequences of terraforming and escalating environmental disasters. The reviewer defends using the animate pronoun "who" for Gaia (Earth), drawing on Ghosh's non-European sources to challenge the dominant Western paradigm that regards the Earth as an inert, inanimate object fit for unbridled exploitation.

  • Paragraph 3: Argues that resistance to the European extractive worldview is not historically unprecedented. Rather, alternative perspectives were systematically marginalized because colonial invaders and their institutional allies across disciplines—ranging from economics and politics to anthropology, literature, and the physical sciences—dominated global intellectual discourse.

  • Paragraph 4: Connects historical critique to modern multilateral climate diplomacy, highlighting how indigenous concepts like the Latin American Pachamama (Earth Mother) are relegated to superficial lip service while substantive negotiations are governed by vested fossil-fuel interests (e.g., US geopolitical control over global oil) and traditional power utilities sabotaging decentralized solar power to protect revenue streams.

Tone and Author's Perspective

  • Tone: Academic, Critical, Analytical, and Concurring.

  • Author's Perspective: The reviewer strongly aligns with Ghosh's postcolonial ecological critique, endorsing his revisionist historiography and affirming the necessity of reviving indigenous, animate understandings of the Earth to overcome corporate and geopolitical climate inertia.

Other questions in this set

  1. Q13. On the basis of information in the passage, which one of the following is NOT a reason for the failure of policies…
  2. Q15. Which one of the following best explains the primary purpose of the discussion of the colonisation of the Banda…
  3. Q16. All of the following can be inferred from the reviewer's discussion of "The Nutmeg's Curse", EXCEPT:

History questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q21
    According to the passage, which one of the following reforms is yet to happen in India’s forest policies?
  2. CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q22
    According to the passage, which one of the following is not common to the 1878 Forest Act and the 1982 draft…
  3. CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q23
    All of the following, if true, would weaken the narrative presented in the passage EXCEPT that:
  4. CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q24
    Which one of the following best encapsulates the reason for the “raging controversy” developing into a…
  5. CAT 2021 Slot 3 VARC Q9
    Which one of the following statements best describes what the passage is about?

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc