CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q14
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension › Philosophy
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2025_SLOT3_VARC_Q14
Passage · questions 11–14
Imagine a world in which artificial intelligence is entrusted with the highest moral responsibilities: sentencing criminals, allocating medical resources, and even mediating conflicts between nations. This might seem like the pinnacle of human progress: an entity unburdened by emotion, prejudice or inconsistency, making ethical decisions with impeccable precision. . . .
Yet beneath this vision of an idealised moral arbiter lies a fundamental question: can a machine understand morality as humans do, or is it confined to a simulacrum of ethical reasoning? AI might replicate human decisions without improving on them, carrying forward the same biases, blind spots and cultural distortions from human moral judgment. In trying to emulate us, it might only reproduce our limitations, not transcend them. But there is a deeper concern. Moral judgment draws on intuition, historical awareness and context – qualities that resist formalisation. Ethics may be so embedded in lived experience that any attempt to encode it into formal structures risks flattening its most essential features. If so, AI would not merely reflect human shortcomings; it would strip morality of the very depth that makes ethical reflection possible in the first place.
Still, many have tried to formalise ethics, by treating certain moral claims not as conclusions, but as starting points. A classic example comes from utilitarianism, which often takes as a foundational axiom the principle that one should act to maximise overall wellbeing. From this, more specific principles can be derived, for example, that it is right to benefit the greatest number, or that actions should be judged by their consequences for total happiness. As computational resources increase, AI becomes increasingly well-suited to the task of starting from fixed ethical assumptions and reasoning through their implications in complex situations.
But what, exactly, does it mean to formalise something like ethics? The question is easier to grasp by looking at fields in which formal systems have long played a central role. Physics, for instance, has relied on formalisation for centuries. There is no single physical theory that explains everything. Instead, we have many physical theories, each designed to describe specific aspects of the Universe: from the behaviour of quarks and electrons to the motion of galaxies. These theories often diverge. Aristotelian physics, for instance, explained falling objects in terms of natural motion toward Earth’s centre; Newtonian mechanics replaced this with a universal force of gravity. These explanations are not just different; they are incompatible. Yet both share a common structure: they begin with basic postulates – assumptions about motion, force or mass – and derive increasingly complex consequences. . . .
Ethical theories have a similar structure. Like physical theories, they attempt to describe a domain – in this case, the moral landscape. They aim to answer questions about which actions are right or wrong, and why. These theories also diverge and, even when they recommend similar actions, such as giving to charity, they justify them in different ways. Ethical theories also often begin with a small set of foundational principles or claims, from which they reason about more complex moral problems.
Question 14
The passage compares ethics to physics, where different theories apply to different aspects of a domain and says AI can reason from fixed starting points in complex cases. Which one of the assumptions below must hold for that comparison to guide practice?
Show answer and solution
Answer: (B)
There is a principled way to decide which ethical framework applies to which class of cases, so the system can select the relevant starting points before deriving a recommendation.
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Necessary Assumption / Methodological Bridge
-
Passage Reference:
Paragraph 4: "There is no single physical theory that explains everything. Instead, we have many physical theories, each designed to describe specific aspects of the Universe... These theories often diverge... incompatible. Yet both share a common structure: they begin with basic postulates... and derive increasingly complex consequences."
Paragraph 5: "Ethical theories have a similar structure. Like physical theories, they attempt to describe a domain – in this case, the moral landscape. They aim to answer questions about which actions are right or wrong, and why. These theories also diverge..."
Logical Deduction
The question asks what underlying assumption must hold for the physics-ethics analogy to guide practical AI decision-making:
-
The passage establishes two central ideas:
-
Physics and ethics both contain multiple divergent, mutually incompatible theoretical frameworks that each govern specific aspects of their respective domains.
-
AI is capable of taking fixed foundational principles (axioms) and systematically deducing ethical conclusions in complex situations.
-
-
If ethical theories diverge and recommend different or conflicting actions in practical dilemmas, a real-world AI system cannot simply deduce conclusions in a vacuum. Before the AI can execute its deductive reasoning, it must know which ethical framework's foundational axioms apply to the specific case at hand.
-
Therefore, for this multi-framework analogy to be actionable in practice, there must exist a principled, reliable meta-method for determining which ethical framework governs which class of cases, allowing the system to select the relevant starting axioms before generating an action recommendation.
-
Option 2 articulates this indispensable enabling assumption.
Correct Answer: Option 2
- An AI system cannot practically apply divergent ethical frameworks unless there is a principled method to determine which framework governs which category of cases, enabling the system to select the proper foundational axioms before calculating recommendations.
Option Elimination
-
Option 1 (Direct Contradiction / Eliminates Plurality): Contradicts the passage's core thesis that ethical theories diverge and justify decisions differently; if all frameworks yielded identical recommendations, maintaining multiple frameworks would be pointless.
-
Option 3 (Opposite Meaning / Monistic Distortion): Asserts that a single master framework replaces all others, directly violating the physics analogy of distinct, coexisting frameworks tailored to specific aspects of a domain.
-
Option 4 (Extreme Claim / Unwarranted Rigidity): Employs unwarranted absolutist criteria ("never straddle", "without any overlap whatsoever"); practical guidance requires a principled selection rule, not an impossible world devoid of overlapping or complex cases.
Detailed explanation
📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure
Central Theme
An epistemological and philosophical inquiry into the formalisation of ethics for artificial intelligence. The author examines the seduction of an impartial algorithmic moral judge against the grave risk that formalisation strips morality of its lived, contextual depth, while drawing an analogy to theoretical physics to demonstrate how ethics operates as a structured plurality of divergent axiomatic frameworks.
Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary
-
Paragraph 1: Introduces the enticing hypothetical vision of an artificial intelligence entrusted with high-stakes moral arbitration (sentencing, medical triage, diplomacy), ostensibly free from emotion, prejudice, and human inconsistency.
-
Paragraph 2: Subverts this ideal by questioning whether machines merely generate an ethical simulacrum, warning that AI risks reproducing human biases and, more critically, that formalizing ethics into rigid systems flattens indispensable intuitive, contextual, and lived dimensions.
-
Paragraph 3: Examines historical efforts to formalize ethics by treating principles as axiomatic starting points (e.g., utilitarianism maximizing total wellbeing), a mode of deduction that expanding computational resources makes AI uniquely suited to execute.
-
Paragraph 4: Clarifies formalization through an analogy to physics, where diverse and mutually incompatible theories (e.g., Aristotelian vs. Newtonian mechanics) nonetheless share a common structure of deriving complex consequences from basic postulates.
-
Paragraph 5: Maps this structural insight back onto ethics, demonstrating that divergent ethical frameworks each begin with a small set of foundational axioms to navigate the moral landscape, showing that formalization models structured plurality rather than a single unified code.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Philosophical, analytical, interrogative, and nuanced.
-
Author's Perspective: Meta-ethical and epistemological. The author adopts a cautious stance toward automated morality, recognizing computational aptitude for axiomatic deduction while highlighting the irreducibility of human context and the enduring coexistence of pluralistic moral frameworks.
Other questions in this set
- Q11. All of the following can reasonably be inferred from the passage EXCEPT:
- Q12. Choose the one option below that comes closest to being the opposite of “utilitarianism”.
- Q13. Which one of the options below best summarises the passage?
Philosophy questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2023 Slot 2 VARC Q1
- CAT 2023 Slot 2 VARC Q2
- CAT 2023 Slot 2 VARC Q3
- CAT 2023 Slot 2 VARC Q4
- CAT 2023 Slot 3 VARC Q1
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc