CAT 2023 Slot 2 VARC Q2
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension › Philosophy
- Hard
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2023_SLOT2_VARC_Q02
Passage · questions 1–4
The Positivists, anxious to stake out their claim for history as a science, contributed the weight of their influence to the cult of facts. First ascertain the facts, said the positivists, then draw your conclusions from them. This is what may be called the common-sense view of history. History consists of a corpus of ascertained facts. The facts are available to the historian in documents, inscriptions, and so on. Sir George Clark contrasted the "hard core of facts" in history with the surrounding pulp of disputable interpretation forgetting perhaps that the pulpy part of the fruit is more rewarding than the hard core. It recalls the favourite dictum of the great liberal journalist C. P. Scott: "Facts are sacred, opinion is free."
What is a historical fact? According to the common-sense view, there are certain basic facts which are the same for all historians and which form, so to speak, the backbone of history-the fact, for example, that the Battle of Hastings was fought in 1066. But this view calls for two observations. In the first place, it is not with facts like these that the historian is primarily concerned. It is no doubt important to know that the great battle was fought in 1066 and not in 1065 or 1067, and that it was fought at Hastings and not at Eastbourne or Brighton. The historian must not get these things wrong. But to praise a historian for his accuracy is like praising an architect for using well-seasoned timber or properly mixed concrete in his building. It is a necessary condition of his work, but not his essential function. It is precisely for matters of this kind that the historian is entitled to rely on what have been called the "auxiliary sciences" of history—archaeology, epigraphy, numismatics, chronology, and so forth.
The second observation is that the necessity to establish these basic facts rests not on any quality in the facts themselves, but on an apriori decision of the historian. In spite of C. P. Scott's motto, every journalist knows today that the most effective way to influence opinion is by the selection and arrangement of the appropriate facts. It used to be said that facts speak for themselves. This is, of course, untrue. The facts speak only when the historian calls on them: it is he who decides to which facts to give the floor, and in what order or context. The only reason why we are interested to know that the battle was fought at Hastings in 1066 is that historians regard it as a major historical event. Professor Talcott Parsons once called science "a selective system of cognitive orientations to reality." It might perhaps have been put more simply. But history is, among other things, that. The historian is necessarily selective. The belief in a hard core of historical facts existing objectively and independently of the interpretation of the historian is a preposterous fallacy, but one which it is very hard to eradicate.
Question 2
All of the following, if true, can weaken the passage's claim that facts do not speak for themselves, EXCEPT:
Show answer and solution
Answer: (B)
facts, like truth, can be relative: what is fact for person X may not be so for person Y.
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Critical Reasoning / Weaken-Except (Logical Negation)
-
Passage Reference:
"It used to be said that facts speak for themselves. This is, of course, untrue. The facts speak only when the historian calls on them: it is he who decides to which facts to give the floor, and in what order or context... The historian is necessarily selective. The belief in a hard core of historical facts existing objectively and independently of the interpretation of the historian is a preposterous fallacy, but one which it is very hard to eradicate."
Logical Deduction
The passage's central thesis is that facts do not speak for themselves:
-
The author argues that facts lack independent, autonomous meaning; they become meaningful only when selected, ordered, and framed by a historian.
-
The question stem asks for the statement that can weaken this claim, EXCEPT.
-
A statement that weakens the author's claim must prove that facts do speak for themselves—i.e., that facts are objective, autonomous, universally meaningful, or unaffected by the historian's narrative ordering.
-
The EXCEPT option will be a statement that does NOT weaken the author's claim (i.e., one that supports the claim, is consistent with it, or is neutral).
Let us evaluate the options:
-
Option 1: Asserts that the truth value of a fact is independent of the historian who expresses it. If facts possess autonomous, objective truth value independent of the historian, facts possess an inherent reality that does not rely on the historian's subjectivity. This weakens the author's claim.
-
Option 3: Asserts that a fact is objective and universal, irrespective of context. If facts have universal, objective meaning regardless of context, they speak for themselves without needing contextual framing. This directly weakens the author's claim.
-
Option 4: Asserts that the order in which facts are presented has no bearing on meaning. The author explicitly claims facts speak based on "what order or context" the historian arranges them in. If narrative ordering has no impact on meaning, the historian's curation does not determine meaning, which weakens the author's claim.
-
Option 2: Asserts that facts, like truth, can be relative (what is fact for X may not be fact for Y). If facts are relative and contingent upon the individual observer, then facts certainly do not possess universal, objective, self-evident authority. This reinforces the author's constructivist stance that facts do not possess an autonomous voice independent of subjective perception. Since it supports rather than weakens the claim, it is the credited exception.
Correct Answer: Option 2
- If facts are relative to individual perceivers, they inherently lack an objective, self-evident voice; thus, this statement supports (or fails to weaken) the author's argument that facts do not speak for themselves.
Option Elimination
-
Option 1 (Valid Weakener): By establishing that a fact's validity is completely autonomous and independent of the historian, it undermines the author's premise that facts depend on the historian's intervention.
-
Option 3 (Valid Weakener): Claiming that facts are inherently objective and universal across all contexts asserts that facts possess intrinsic meaning that speaks for itself, directly contradicting the passage.
-
Option 4 (Valid Weakener): If the arrangement and sequencing of facts do not influence the generation of meaning, it refutes the author's argument that historians create meaning through selective arrangement.
Detailed explanation
📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure
Central Theme
A foundational epistemological critique of historical positivism and the nineteenth-century "cult of facts." Drawing upon E. H. Carr's classic historiographical inquiry (What is History?), the passage refutes the common-sense empiricist assumption that history consists of an objective, autonomous corpus of facts awaiting discovery in documents. Instead, the author contends that facts are inherently mute and devoid of independent meaning until a historian selects, arranges, and interprets them within a chosen context.
Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary
-
Paragraph 1: Traces the genesis of the "cult of facts" to nineteenth-century Positivism, which sought to establish history's scientific legitimacy by prioritizing empirical data over subjective interpretation. Contrasts Sir George Clark's metaphor of the "hard core of facts" surrounded by disputable interpretation with the author's counter-assertion that the interpretive "pulp" is far more rewarding. Invokes C. P. Scott's famous journalistic maxim ("Facts are sacred, opinion is free") to exemplify the pervasive cultural reverence for raw empirical data.
-
Paragraph 2: Interrogates the nature of a "historical fact," noting that basic empirical data (e.g., the date and location of the Battle of Hastings in 1066) form merely the mechanical skeleton of history. The author argues that factual accuracy is merely a necessary condition of the historian's trade—comparable to an architect using sound timber or well-mixed concrete—rather than their essential intellectual function. Establishing such baseline facts is the proper domain of the "auxiliary sciences" (archaeology, epigraphy, numismatics, chronology).
-
Paragraph 3: Delivers the author's primary philosophical argument: facts do not speak for themselves, nor does their historical status derive from intrinsic properties; they speak only when the historian grants them the floor. Citing sociologist Talcott Parsons' characterization of science as a "selective system of cognitive orientations to reality," the author demonstrates that history is fundamentally selective. Believing in an objective "hard core" of facts independent of interpretation is condemned as a stubborn, preposterous fallacy.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Critical, Scholarly, Polemical, and Analytical.
-
Author's Perspective: The author adopts an anti-positivist, constructivist historiographical perspective. Naive empiricism is rigorously rejected in favor of recognizing that historical understanding is an active intellectual synthesis forged by the historian's deliberate selection, contextual framing, and interpretive judgment.
Other questions in this set
- Q1. According to this passage, which one of the following statements best describes the significance of archaeology for…
- Q3. If the author of the passage were to write a book on the Battle of Hastings along the lines of his/her own reasoning,…
- Q4. All of the following describe the "common-sense view" of history, EXCEPT:
Philosophy questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q11
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q12
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q13
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q14
- CAT 2022 Slot 1 VARC Q1
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc