CAT 2025 Slot 3 DILR Q13

  • Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
  • Logical Reasoning › Grids
  • Hard
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2025_SLOT3_DILR_Q13

Data set · questions 10–13

Anu, Bijay, Chetan, Deepak, Eshan, and Faruq are six friends. Each of them uses a mobile number from exactly one of the two mobile operators - Xitel and Yocel. During the last month, the six friends made several calls to each other. Each call was made by one of these six friends to another. The table below summarizes the number of minutes of calls that each of the six made to (outgoing minutes) and received from (incoming minutes) these friends, grouped by the operators. Some of the entries are missing.

Diagram

It is known that the duration of calls from Faruq to Eshan was 200 minutes.

Also, there were no calls from:

i. Bijay to Eshan,

ii. Chetan to Anu and Chetan to Deepak,

iii. Deepak to Bijay and Deepak to Faruq,

iv. Eshan to Chetan and Eshan to Deepak.

Question 13

What was the duration of calls (in minutes) from Deepak to Chetan?

  1. A

    0

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    100

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    50

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    125

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (B)

100

Solution

Concept: Directed Call Network Flows & Bipartite Graph Conservation

Master State Table

Caller ↓\downarrow \ Receiver →\rightarrowOperatorAnu (AA)Bijay (BB)Chetan (CC)Deepak (DD)Eshan (EE)Faruq (FF)Out-Xitel (\extOutX\ext{Out}_{\mathcal{X}})Out-Yocel (\extOutY\ext{Out}_{\mathcal{Y}})Total Out
Anu (AA)Xitel—002002001251250020020000525525525525
Bijay (BB)Xitel5050—000000005050005050
Chetan (CC)Yocel005050—0000005050005050
Deepak (DD)Yocel20020000100100—0000200200100100300300
Eshan (EE)Xitel00000000—00000000
Faruq (FF)Yocel1501500035035000200200—350350350350700700
In-Xitel (\extInX\ext{In}_{\mathcal{X}})—505000200200125125002002005050525525575575
In-Yocel (\extInY\ext{In}_{\mathcal{Y}})—3503505050450450002002000060060045045010501050
Total In—400400505065065012512520020020020065065097597516251625

Question Deduction

The question asks: "What was the duration of calls (in minutes) from Deepak to Chetan?"

Target=C(D,C)\text{Target} = C(D, C)

We inspect Deepak's outgoing call record to subscribers of Operator Yocel:

• Deepak's Operator & Outgoing Allowance to Yocel:

• From the operator partition, Deepak is subscribed to Operator Yocel (Y={C,D,F}\mathcal{Y} = \{C, D, F\}).

• From the baseline passage table, Deepak's outgoing minutes to subscribers of Yocel is explicitly listed as:

OutY(D)=100 minutes\text{Out}_{\mathcal{Y}}(D) = 100 \text{ minutes}

• The other members belonging to Operator Yocel are Chetan (CC) and Faruq (FF).

• Because Deepak cannot call himself, Deepak's outgoing calls to Yocel subscribers consist entirely of calls made to Chetan and Faruq:

C(D,C)+C(D,F)=OutY(D)=100C(D, C) + C(D, F) = \text{Out}_{\mathcal{Y}}(D) = 100

• Application of Passage Clue iii:

• Clue iii in the passage explicitly states: "there were no calls from Deepak to Bijay and Deepak to Faruq".

• Therefore:

C(D,F)=0C(D, F) = 0

• Direct Computation of Call Duration:

• Substituting C(D,F)=0C(D, F) = 0 into Deepak's outgoing conservation equation:

C(D,C)+0=100  ⟹  C(D,C)=100 minutesC(D, C) + 0 = 100 \implies C(D, C) = 100 \text{ minutes}

• Options Verification Matrix:

OptionStated ValueAnalytical EvaluationCorrectness Status
Option 100Incorrect; confuses with reverse call C(C,D)=0C(C, D) = 0 or C(D,F)=0C(D, F) = 0Incorrect
Option 2100100Matches exactly: OutY(D)=100\text{Out}_{\mathcal{Y}}(D) = 100 and C(D,F)=0  ⟹  C(D,C)=100C(D, F) = 0 \implies C(D, C) = 100Correct
Option 35050Incorrect; confuses with Chetan's outgoing to Bijay C(C,B)=50C(C, B) = 50Incorrect
Option 4125125Incorrect; confuses with Deepak's incoming from Anu C(A,D)=125C(A, D) = 125Incorrect

Therefore, the duration of calls from Deepak to Chetan was 100100 minutes, which corresponds to Option 2.

Topper Take

• The 15-Second Direct Kill: Notice the extraordinary structural elegance of this question: Deepak's \extOutY\ext{Out}_{\mathcal{Y}} is explicitly printed as 100100 directly in the passage table! The other two Yocel members are Chetan and Faruq. Fact iii explicitly gives C(D,F)=0C(D, F) = 0. Therefore, mathematically:

• The Directionality Inversion Trap: Many students accidentally look at calls from Chetan to Deepak (C\oDC \o D) instead of Deepak to Chetan (D\oCD \o C). Fact ii explicitly says there were no calls from Chetan to Deepak (C(C,D)=0C(C, D) = 0). An inattentive student might see "Chetan to Deepak is 0", assume reciprocity, and erroneously select Option 1 (00). In directed graphs, $C(i, j)

Other questions in this set

  1. Q10. What was the duration of calls (in minutes) from Bijay to Anu?
  2. Q11. What was the total duration of calls (in minutes) made by Anu to friends having mobile numbers from Operator Yocel?
  3. Q12. What was the total duration of calls (in minutes) made by Faruq to friends having mobile numbers from Operator Yocel?

Grids questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2024 Slot 2 DILR Q6
    One resident whose house is located at L, needs to visit the post office as well as the bank. What is the…
  2. CAT 2024 Slot 2 DILR Q7
    One person enters the gated area and decides to walk as much as possible before leaving the area without…
  3. CAT 2024 Slot 2 DILR Q8
    One resident takes a walk within the gated area starting from A and returning to A without going through any…
  4. CAT 2024 Slot 2 DILR Q9
    Visitors coming for morning walks are allowed to enter as long as they do not pass by any of the residences…
  5. CAT 2024 Slot 3 DILR Q1
    Which of the following statements is correct?

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc