CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q20
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension › Economy
- Hard
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2025_SLOT1_VARC_Q20
Passage · questions 19–22
Studies showing that income inequality plays a positive role in economic growth are largely based on three arguments. The first argument focuses on investment indivisibilities wherein large sunk costs are required when implementing new fundamental innovations. Without stock markets and financial institutions to mobilize large sums of money, a high concentration of wealth is needed for individuals to undertake new industrial activities accompanied by high sunk costs . . . [One study] shows the relation between economic growth and income inequality for 45 countries during 1966-1995. [It was found] that the increase in income inequality has a significant positive relationship with economic growth in the short and medium term. Using system GMM, [another study estimated] the relation between income inequality and economic growth for 106 countries during 1965–2005 period. The results show that income inequality has a positive impact on economic growth in the short run, but the two are negatively correlated in the long run. The second argument is related to moral hazard and incentives . . . Because economic performance is determined by the unobservable level of effort that agents make, paying compensations without taking into account the economic performance achieved by individual agents will fail to elicit optimum effort from the agents. Thus, certain income inequalities contribute to growth by enhancing worker motivation . . . and by giving motivation to innovators and entrepreneurs . . . Finally, [another study] point[s] out that the concentration of wealth or stock ownership in relation to corporate governance contributes to growth. If stock ownership is distributed and owned by a large number of shareholders, it is not easy to make quick decisions due to the conflicting interests among shareholders, and this may also cause a free-rider problem in terms of monitoring and supervising managers and workers. . . .
Various studies have examined the relationships between income inequality and economic growth, and most of these assert that a negative correlation exists between the two. . . . Analyzing 159 countries for 1980–2012, they conclude that there exists a negative relation between income inequality and economic growth; when the income share of the richest 20% of population increases by 1%, the GDP decreases by 0.08%, whereas when the income share of the poorest 20% of population increases by 1%, the GDP increases by 0.38%. Some studies find that inequality has a negative impact on growth due to poor human capital accumulation and low fertility rates . . . while [others] point out that inequality creates political instability, resulting in lower investment. . . . [Some economists] argue that widening income inequality has a negative impact on economic growth because it negatively affects social consensus or social capital formation. One important research topic is the correlation between democratization and income redistribution. [Some scholars] explain that social pressure for income redistribution rises as income inequality increases in a democratic society. In other words, when democratization extends suffrage to a wider class of people, the increased political power of low- and middle-income voters results in broader support for income redistribution and social welfare expansion. However . . . if the rich have more political influence than the poor, the democratic system actually worsens income inequality rather than improving it.
Question 20
The primary function of the three-part case for a positive income inequality–economic growth link in the first half of the passage is to show that:
Show answer and solution
Answer: (B)
inequality can aid short-term growth in settings with high sunk costs, incentive alignment, and concentrated ownership.
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Rhetorical Function / Macro Purpose
-
Passage Reference:
Paragraph 1: "Studies showing that income inequality plays a positive role in economic growth are largely based on three arguments. The first argument focuses on investment indivisibilities wherein large sunk costs are required... Without stock markets and financial institutions... a high concentration of wealth is needed... [One study found] a significant positive relationship with economic growth in the short and medium term... [Another study shows] income inequality has a positive impact on economic growth in the short run, but the two are negatively correlated in the long run. The second argument is related to moral hazard and incentives... [Finally, another study points out] that the concentration of wealth or stock ownership in relation to corporate governance contributes to growth..."
Logical Deduction
The author structures the first half of the passage by outlining three distinct theoretical channels through which inequality might foster economic growth:
-
Channel 1 (Investment Indivisibilities): Wealth concentration funds large sunk-cost industrial projects in economies lacking mature financial markets.
-
Channel 2 (Incentive Alignment): Performance-contingent compensation overcomes moral hazard and motivates optimal worker and entrepreneurial effort.
-
Channel 3 (Corporate Governance): Concentrated stock ownership avoids shareholder coordination failure and free-rider problems in management oversight.
-
Crucially, the empirical evidence cited alongside these channels specifically confines the positive relationship to the "short and medium term" or "short run," while noting long-run negative correlations.
-
Therefore, the primary function of this three-part case is to demonstrate that inequality can foster growth under specific institutional conditions in the short run, rather than proving an unconditional or permanent macroeconomic benefit.
Correct Answer: Option 2
- Accurately reflects the conditional and temporal boundaries established in the text: inequality can aid short-term growth in settings characterized by high sunk costs, incentive alignment, and concentrated ownership.
Option Elimination
-
Option 1 (Extreme Generalization / Direct Contradiction): Claims inequality boosts growth "in every period and type of economy, regardless of finance or governance conditions," directly contradicted by the passage, which explicitly limits positive effects to the short/medium run and conditional institutional environments.
-
Option 3 (Factual Distortion / Out of Scope): The text notes that wealth concentration is needed in the absence of stock markets and financial institutions, but never asserts that mature stock markets are "harmful to investment."
-
Option 4 (Direct Contradiction / Scope Reversal): Directly inverts the text; the passage states that dispersed ownership makes decision-making difficult due to conflicting shareholder interests and causes a free-rider problem in monitoring managers.
Detailed explanation
📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure
Central Theme
The complex macroeconomic relationship between income inequality and economic growth, synthesizing theoretical arguments and empirical cross-country evidence. The passage balances pro-growth arguments—centered on investment indivisibilities, incentive structures, and corporate governance—against the prevailing consensus demonstrating negative long-term impacts via human capital erosion, political instability, impaired social consensus, and democratic redistributive pressures.
Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary
-
Paragraph 1: Outlines the tripartite theoretical case for inequality promoting economic growth: (1) capital concentration overcoming investment indivisibilities with high sunk costs where capital markets are underdeveloped, (2) performance-contingent income disparities mitigating moral hazard and incentivizing effort, and (3) concentrated corporate ownership preventing shareholder free-riding; notes empirical studies confirming short- to medium-term growth gains but long-run negative correlations.
-
Paragraph 2: Surveys the dominant academic literature demonstrating that inequality harms growth (e.g., higher income share for the richest 20% reduces GDP, while boosting the poorest 20% raises GDP); details negative mechanisms including underinvestment in human capital, declining fertility, political instability, and social capital decay; examines democratization where broadened suffrage amplifies redistributive demands, noting that elite political capture can conversely exacerbate inequality.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Academic, Objective, Evaluative, and Synthesis-Oriented.
-
Author's Perspective: Nuanced economic review. The author presents both sides of the inequality-growth debate rigorously, differentiating short-run capital mobilization advantages from chronic long-run structural and political-economic drags.
Other questions in this set
- Q19. The passage refers to "democratization". Choose the one option below that comes closest to the opposite of this process.
- Q21. Which one of the options below best summarises the passage?
- Q22. According to the incentive or moral hazard argument, which one of the designs below is most consistent with the claim…
Economy questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q16
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q17
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q18
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q19
- CAT 2024 Slot 2 VARC Q4
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc