CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q18
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension › Economy
- Hard
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2024_SLOT1_VARC_Q18
Passage · questions 16–19
Oftentimes, when economists cross borders, they are less interested in learning from others than in invading their garden plots. Gary Becker, for instance, pioneered the idea of human capital. To do so, he famously tackled topics like crime and domesticity, applying methods honed in the study of markets to domains of nonmarket life. He projected economics outward into new realms: for example, by revealing the extent to which humans calculate marginal utilities when choosing their spouses or stealing from neighbors. At the same time, he did not let other ways of thinking enter his own economic realm: for example, he did not borrow from anthropology or history or let observations of nonmarket economics inform his homo economicus. Becker was a picture of the imperial economist in the heyday of the discipline’s bravura.
Times have changed for the once almighty discipline. Economics has been taken to task, within and beyond its ramparts. Some economists have reached out, imported, borrowed, and collaborated—been less imperial, more open. Consider Thomas Piketty and his outreach to historians. The booming field of behavioral economics—the fusion of economics and social psychology—is another case. Having spawned active subfields, like judgment, decision-making and a turn to experimentation, the field aims to go beyond the caricature of Rational Man to explain how humans make decisions.
It is important to underscore how this flips the way we think about economics. For generations, economists have presumed that people have interests—‘preferences,” in the neoclassical argot—that get revealed in the course of peoples’ choices. Interests come before actions and determine them. If you are hungry, you buy lunch; if you are cold, you get a sweater. If you only have so much money and can't afford to deal with both your growling stomach and your shivering, which need you choose to meet using your scarce savings reveals your preference.
Psychologists take one look at this simple formulation and shake their heads. Increasingly, even some mainstream economists have to admit that homo economicus doesn’t always behave like the textbook maximizer; irrational behavior can’t simply be waved away as extra-economic expressions of passions over interests, and thus the domain of other disciplines... .This is one place where the humanist can help the economist. If narrative economics is going to help us understand how rivals duke it out, who wins and who loses, we are going to need much more than lessons from epidemiological studies of viruses or intracranial stimuli.
Above all, we need politics and institutions. Shiller (the Nobel Prize–winning economist) connects perceptions of narratives to changes in behavior and thence to social outcomes. He completes a circle that was key to behavioral economics and brings in storytelling to make sense of how perceptions get framed. This cycle (perception to behavior to society) was once mediated or dominated by institutions: the political parties, lobby groups, and media organizations that played a vital role in legitimating, representing, and excluding interests. Yet institutions have been stripped from Shiller's account, to reveal a bare dynamic of emotions and economics, without the intermediating place of politics.
Question 18
The author critiques Schiller's approach to behavioural economics for
Show answer and solution
Answer: (B)
linking emotions and rational behaviour without considering the mediation of social institutions.
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Detail-Oriented / Author's Critique
-
Passage Reference:
"Above all, we need politics and institutions. Shiller (the Nobel Prize–winning economist) connects perceptions of narratives to changes in behavior and thence to social outcomes... This cycle (perception to behavior to society) was once mediated or dominated by institutions: the political parties, lobby groups, and media organizations that played a vital role in legitimating, representing, and excluding interests. Yet institutions have been stripped from Shiller's account, to reveal a bare dynamic of emotions and economics, without the intermediating place of politics."
Logical Deduction
The author's critique of Robert Shiller in Paragraph 5 is explicit:
-
Shiller incorporates storytelling and perceptions of narratives into behavior and social outcomes.
-
However, the author emphasizes that this cycle was historically shaped and mediated by institutional structures (political parties, lobbies, media).
-
The fatal flaw in Shiller's model is that "institutions have been stripped from Shiller's account, to reveal a bare dynamic of emotions and economics, without the intermediating place of politics."
-
Thus, Shiller connects emotional narratives directly to economic behavior while omitting the indispensable mediating role of social and political institutions.
Correct Answer: Option 2
- Accurately identifies the author's critique: Shiller connects emotions, narratives, and economic behaviors directly while failing to account for the crucial mediating role played by social and political institutions.
Option Elimination
-
Option 1 (Factual Distortion): Shiller does not actively "denigrate" institutions; he simply neglects or omits them ("institutions have been stripped from Shiller's account").
-
Option 3 (Opposite Meaning / Scope Reversal): Inverts the author's assessment of media and politics; the author considers their role vital ("played a vital role"), not "marginal."
-
Option 4 (Factual Distortion): The author does not fault Shiller for using storytelling per se; storytelling is recognized as a valuable insight, but Shiller is critiqued for divorcing stories from political institutions.
Detailed explanation
📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure
Central Theme
A critical critique of economic methodology tracing the discipline's shift from Gary Becker's unilateral "economic imperialism" to interdisciplinary behavioural and narrative economics, while exposing how contemporary models (such as Robert Shiller's) still dangerously neglect mediating political and institutional structures.
Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary
-
Paragraph 1: Analyzes the imperial era of neoclassical economics personified by Gary Becker, who aggressively projected economic models of marginal utility onto non-market phenomena (crime, marriage) while dogmatically refusing to allow history or anthropology to influence the rigid construct of homo economicus.
-
Paragraph 2: Explores the modern disciplinary retreat from imperialism: facing internal and external critiques, economists have embraced interdisciplinary collaboration (e.g., Piketty's outreach to historians and behavioral economics' integration of social psychology to transcend the caricature of Rational Man).
-
Paragraph 3: Details the orthodox neoclassical foundation where innate preferences precede and dictate actions, with choices under resource scarcity serving merely to reveal pre-existing individual utility.
-
Paragraph 4: Contrasts orthodox preference theory with psychological realities of irrationality, arguing that narrative economics and humanistic perspectives are essential to explain economic behavior beyond narrow neurological or epidemiological models.
-
Paragraph 5: Critiques Robert Shiller's narrative economics: while Shiller insightfully integrates storytelling into how perceptions shape behavior, his model strips away vital political and social institutions (parties, lobbies, media), reducing complex social realities to a bare, unmediated interaction of raw emotions and economic choices.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Academic, critical, incisive, and interdisciplinary.
-
Author's Perspective: An institutionalist and humanist critic advocating for genuine disciplinary reciprocity, urging economics to incorporate institutional, sociological, and political realities rather than relying on desocialized behavioral models.
Other questions in this set
- Q16. In the first paragraph the author is making the point that economists like Becker
- Q17. “Times have changed for the once almighty discipline.” We can infer from this statement and the associated paragraph…
- Q19. We can infer from the passage that the term “homo economic us" refers to someone
Economy questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q19
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q20
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q21
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q22
- CAT 2020 Slot 1 VARC Q15
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc