CAT 2024 Slot 3 VARC Q19

  • Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
  • Reading Comprehension › Politics
  • Medium
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2024_SLOT3_VARC_Q19

Passage · questions 16–19

There is a group in the space community who view the solar system not as an opportunity to expand human potential but as a nature preserve, forever the provenance of an elite group of scientists and their sanitary robotic probes. These planetary protection advocates call for avoiding “harmful contamination" of celestial bodies. Under this regime, NASA incurs great expense sterilizing robotic probes in order to prevent the contamination of entirely theoretical biospheres.


Transporting bacteria would matter if Mars were the vital world once imagined by astronomers who mistook optical illusions for canals. Nobody wants to expose Martians to measles, but sadly, robotic exploration reveals a bleak, rusted landscape, lacking oxygen and flooded with radiation ready to sterilize any Earthly microbes. Simple life might exist underground, or down at the bottom of a deep canyon, but it has been very hard to find with robots. The upsides from human exploration and development of Mars clearly outweigh the welfare of purely speculative Martian fungi.


The other likely targets of human exploration, development, and settlement, our moon and the asteroids, exist in a desiccated, radiation-soaked realm of hard vacuum and extreme temperature variations that would kill nearly anything. It's also important to note that many international competitors will ignore the demands of these protection extremists in any case. For example, China recently sent a terrarium to the moon and germinated a plant seed—with, unsurprisingly, no protest from its own scientific community. In contrast, when it was recently revealed that a researcher had surreptitiously smuggled super-resilient microscopic tardigrades aboard the ill-fated Israeli Beresheet lunar probe, a firestorm was unleashed within the space community.


NASA's previous human exploration efforts made no serious attempt at sterility, with little notice. As the Mars expert Robert Zubrin noted in the National Review, U.S. lunar landings did not leave the campsites cleaner than they found it. Apollo's bacteria-infested litter included bags of feces. Forcing NASA's proposed Mars exploration to do better, scrubbing everything and hauling out all the trash, would destroy NASA's human exploration budget and encroach on the agency's other directorates, too. Getting future astronauts off Mars is enough of a challenge, without trying to tote weeks of waste along as well.


A reasonable compromise is to continue on the course laid out by the U.S. government and the National Research Council, which proposed a system of zones on Mars, some for science only, some for habitation, and some for resource exploitation. This approach minimizes contamination, maximizes scientific exploration. Mars presents a stark choice of diverging human futures. We can turn inward, pursuing ever more limited futures while we await whichever natural or manmade disaster will eradicate our species and life on Earth. Alternatively, we can choose to propel our biosphere further into the solar system, simultaneously protecting our home planet and providing a backup plan for the only life we know exists in the universe. Are the lives on Earth worth less than some hypothetical microbe lurking under Martian rocks?

Question 19

The author is unlikely to disagree with any of the following EXCEPT:

  1. A

    the proposal for a zonal segregation of the Martian landscape into regions for different purposes.

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    that while NASA's earlier missions were not ideal in their approach to space contamination, they likely did no grave damage.

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    the exorbitant costs of continuing to keep the space environment pristine may be unsustainable.

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    space contamination should be minimised until the possibility of life on the astronomical body being explored is ruled out.

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (D)

space contamination should be minimised until the possibility of life on the astronomical body being explored is ruled out.

Solution

🎯 Question Analysis & Solution

  • Question Type: Author's Position / Double-Negative Logical Evaluation (EXCEPT)

  • Passage Reference:

"The upsides from human exploration and development of Mars clearly outweigh the welfare of purely speculative Martian fungi."

"Forcing NASA's proposed Mars exploration to do better, scrubbing everything and hauling out all the trash, would destroy NASA's human exploration budget and encroach on the agency's other directorates, too."

"A reasonable compromise is to continue on the course laid out by the U.S. government and the National Research Council, which proposed a system of zones on Mars, some for science only, some for habitation, and some for resource exploitation."

"Are the lives on Earth worth less than some hypothetical microbe lurking under Martian rocks?"

Logical Deduction

The phrasing "unlikely to disagree with any of the following EXCEPT" is a double-negative construction equivalent to: "With which of the following statements WOULD the author DISAGREE?"

Throughout the text, the author vigorously champions human expansion and resource exploitation, arguing that these goals must not be paralyzed by hypothetical extraterrestrial life:

  1. In paragraph 2, the author asserts that the upsides of human exploration "clearly outweigh the welfare of purely speculative Martian fungi."

  2. In paragraph 5, the author rhetorically asks whether terrestrial life is "worth less than some hypothetical microbe lurking under Martian rocks."

Demanding that space contamination be strictly minimized until all possibilities of alien life are ruled out represents the exact dogmatic "planetary protection" orthodoxy that the author explicitly condemns as extremist and economically ruinous. Consequently, the author would unequivocally disagree with Option 4.

Correct Answer: Option 4

  • The author directly rejects the position that human exploration and development should be deferred or constrained to minimize contamination until extraterrestrial life is completely ruled out.

Option Elimination

  • Option 1 (Passage Alignment / Non-Contradictory): The author explicitly agrees with this proposal, praising the National Research Council's zonal segregation plan as a "reasonable compromise."

  • Option 2 (Passage Alignment / Non-Contradictory): The author agrees with this premise, noting that Apollo missions deposited unsterilized litter and feces on the Moon with "little notice" and no severe ecological consequences.

  • Option 3 (Passage Alignment / Non-Contradictory): The author explicitly agrees, arguing that enforcing absolute sterility would "destroy NASA's human exploration budget and encroach on the agency's other directorates.

Detailed explanation

📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure

Central Theme

A critique of dogmatic planetary protection protocols that mandate exorbitant sterilization procedures to protect speculative extraterrestrial biospheres, contending that humanity's broader imperative for exploration, space development, and existential species survival outweighs the preservation of purely hypothetical Martian microbes.

Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary

  • Paragraph 1: Introduces planetary protection advocates who view celestial bodies as inviolable nature preserves, criticizing NASA's expensive probe sterilization procedures designed to protect purely theoretical alien biospheres.

  • Paragraph 2: Emphasizes that Mars is an arid, radiation-soaked, oxygen-deprived environment where terrestrial microbes would naturally perish, arguing that the tangible benefits of human exploration far outweigh the preservation of speculative Martian organisms.

  • Paragraph 3: Highlights the extreme sterility of the Moon and asteroids, noting the pragmatic futility and unequal enforcement of protectionism as demonstrated by China's uncontested lunar germination experiment versus the uproar over tardigrades aboard Israel's Beresheet lander.

  • Paragraph 4: Cites historical precedent from Apollo missions that deposited non-sterile debris and human waste on the Moon without adverse consequences, arguing that enforcing absolute sterility on future Mars expeditions would impose ruinous financial and logistical burdens on NASA.

  • Paragraph 5: Endorses a balanced zoning framework (allocating zones for science, habitation, and resource exploitation) proposed by the National Research Council, concluding that expanding humanity's footprint into the solar system is an existential necessity to protect Earth's biosphere from extinction.

Tone and Author's Perspective

  • Tone: Critical, pragmatic, argumentative, assertive, and polemical.

  • Author's Perspective: The author adopts a utilitarian and anthropocentric stance, viewing strict planetary protection mandates as counterproductive elitism and asserting that bounded, managed contamination is fully justified by the civilizational necessity of space exploration and species survival.

Other questions in this set

  1. Q16. The author mentions all of the following reasons to dismiss concerns about contaminating Mars EXCEPT:
  2. Q17. The author’s overall tone in the first paragraph can be described as
  3. Q18. The contrasting reactions to the Chinese and Israeli “contaminations” of lunar space

Politics questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q5
    The word “instantiation” is used in the first paragraph. Which one of the following pairs of terms would be…
  2. CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q6
    Which one of the following sets of terms is closest to mapping the key arguments of the passage?
  3. CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q7
    What does the author wish to communicate by referring to the Hoover and Aswan dams in the first paragraph?
  4. CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q8
    All of the following statements may be considered valid inferences from the passage EXCEPT that:
  5. CAT 2023 Slot 2 VARC Q5
    The author of the passage faults Deneen's conclusions for all of the following reasons, EXCEPT:

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc