CAT 2023 Slot 2 VARC Q5
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension › Politics
- Hard
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2023_SLOT2_VARC_Q05
Passage · questions 5–8
Over the past four centuries liberalism has been so successful that it has driven all its opponents off the battlefield. Now it is disintegrating, destroyed by a mix of hubris and internal contradictions, according to Patrick Deneen, a professor of politics at the University of Notre Dame. Equality of opportunity has produced a new meritocratic aristocracy that has all the aloofness of the old aristocracy with none of its sense of noblesse oblige. Democracy has degenerated into a theatre of the absurd. And technological advances are reducing ever more areas of work into meaningless drudgery. "The gap between liberalism's claims about itself and the lived reality of the citizenry" is now so wide that "the lie can no longer be accepted," Mr Deneen writes. What better proof of this than the vision of 1,000 private planes whisking their occupants to Davos to discuss the question of "creating a shared future in a fragmented world"?
Deneen does an impressive job of capturing the current mood of disillusionment, echoing left- wing complaints about rampant commercialism, right-wing complaints about narcissistic and bullying students, and general worries about atomisation and selfishness. But when he concludes that all this adds up to a failure of liberalism, is his argument convincing? He argues that the essence of liberalism lies in freeing individuals from constraints. In fact, liberalism contains a wide range of intellectual traditions which provide different answers to the question of how to trade off the relative claims of rights and responsibilities, individual expression and social ties. Liberals experimented with a range of ideas from devolving power from the centre to creating national education systems.
Mr Deneen's fixation on the essence of liberalism leads to the second big problem of his book: his failure to recognise liberalism's ability to reform itself and address its internal problems. The late 19th century saw America suffering from many of the problems that are reappearing today, including the creation of a business aristocracy, the rise of vast companies, the corruption of politics and the sense that society was dividing into winners and losers. But a wide variety of reformers, working within the liberal tradition, tackled these problems head on. Theodore Roosevelt took on the trusts. Progressives cleaned up government corruption. University reformers modernised academic syllabuses and built ladders of opportunity. Rather than dying, liberalism reformed itself.
Mr Deneen is right to point out that the record of liberalism in recent years has been dismal. He is also right to assert that the world has much to learn from the premodern notions of liberty as self-mastery and self-denial. The biggest enemy of liberalism is not so much atomisation but old-fashioned greed, as members of the Davos elite pile their plates ever higher with perks and share options. But he is wrong to argue that the only way for people to liberate themselves from the contradictions of liberalism is "liberation from liberalism itself". The best way to read "Why Liberalism Failed" is not as a funeral oration but as a call to action: up your game, or else.
Question 5
The author of the passage faults Deneen's conclusions for all of the following reasons, EXCEPT:
Show answer and solution
Answer: (C)
its repeated harking back to premodern notions of liberty.
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Negative Detail / Author's Critique ('Except' Question)
-
Passage Reference:
"He argues that the essence of liberalism lies in freeing individuals from constraints. In fact, liberalism contains a wide range of intellectual traditions which provide different answers to the question of how to trade off the relative claims of rights and responsibilities, individual expression and social ties."
"Mr Deneen's fixation on the essence of liberalism leads to the second big problem of his book: his failure to recognise liberalism's ability to reform itself and address its internal problems. The late 19th century saw America suffering from many of the problems that are reappearing today... Rather than dying, liberalism reformed itself."
"Mr Deneen is right to point out that the record of liberalism in recent years has been dismal. He is also right to assert that the world has much to learn from the premodern notions of liberty as self-mastery and self-denial... But he is wrong to argue that the only way for people to liberate themselves from the contradictions of liberalism is 'liberation from liberalism itself'."
Logical Deduction
The question requires identifying the statement that the author does NOT fault Deneen for:
-
In Paragraph 2, the author faults Deneen for adopting a reductionist, narrow definition of liberalism limited to "freeing individuals from constraints" (Option 4).
-
In Paragraph 3, the author faults Deneen for his "failure to recognise liberalism's ability to reform itself" and ignoring late 19th-century historical precedents where declining liberalism reversed its decline (Option 1).
-
In Paragraph 4, the author faults Deneen's fatalistic conclusion predicting total collapse and treating the book as an apocalyptic "funeral oration" (Option 2).
-
In sharp contrast, Paragraph 4 explicitly affirms Deneen on one point: "He is also right to assert that the world has much to learn from the premodern notions of liberty as self-mastery and self-denial."
Because the author explicitly agrees with Deneen's reliance on premodern notions of liberty rather than criticizing him for it, Option 3 is the credited exception.
Correct Answer: Option 3
- The author explicitly endorses Deneen's view that modern society has much to learn from premodern notions of liberty as self-mastery, making this an area of agreement rather than a stated fault.
Option Elimination
-
Option 1 (Factual Distortion of Question Mandate): Paragraph 3 explicitly identifies Deneen's failure to recognize historical instances of liberal self-reform as the "second big problem of his book."
-
Option 2 (Factual Distortion of Question Mandate): Paragraph 4 explicitly critiques Deneen's fatalism, arguing his book should be read as a call to action rather than an apocalyptic "funeral oration" or fatalistic prediction of death.
-
Option 4 (Factual Distortion of Question Mandate): Paragraph 2 explicitly faults Deneen's reductionist view that liberalism is narrowly confined to liberating individuals from constraints.
Detailed explanation
📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure
Central Theme
A critical review of political theorist Patrick Deneen's provocative book Why Liberalism Failed. While endorsing Deneen's acute diagnosis of contemporary Western malaise—marked by meritocratic arrogance, democratic decay, and rampant commercial greed—the author refutes Deneen's fatalistic conclusion that liberalism is intrinsically unviable and destined for extinction. The author argues that liberalism is a multifaceted intellectual tradition possessing a proven historical resilience and capacity for institutional self-reform (exemplified by the American Progressive Era), concluding that current crises demand internal liberal revitalization rather than ideological abandonment.
Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary
-
Paragraph 1: Introduces Patrick Deneen's central thesis: after four centuries of triumphing over rival ideologies, liberalism is collapsing under the weight of its own hubris and internal contradictions. Details the symptoms identified by Deneen: a self-serving meritocratic aristocracy lacking noblesse oblige, democracy reduced to absurd theater, technology converting work into meaningless drudgery, and an unbearable gap between egalitarian claims and lived reality—symbolized by 1,000 private jets flying to Davos to discuss a "shared future."
-
Paragraph 2: Acknowledges Deneen's impressive ability to capture widespread contemporary disillusionment across both left- and right-wing political spectra. However, the author identifies Deneen's first major error: an essentialist, reductive definition of liberalism limited strictly to "freeing individuals from constraints," ignoring liberalism's rich internal diversity that historically balanced individual rights with civic duties and collective institutions.
-
Paragraph 3: Pinpoints the second fundamental defect of Deneen's thesis: failing to acknowledge liberalism's proven historical capacity for self-correction. Drawing parallels to late 19th-century America—which confronted nearly identical crises of robber-baron monopolies, corporate power, political corruption, and extreme inequality—the author highlights how liberal reformers (Theodore Roosevelt, the Progressives, educational modernizers) revitalized society from within rather than abandoning liberalism.
-
Paragraph 4: Provides the author's concluding synthesis. Concedes that liberalism's recent track record is dismal, validates the recovery of premodern notions of liberty as self-mastery, and identifies "old-fashioned greed" among the Davos elite as the true enemy of liberal democracy. Crucially rejects Deneen's call for "liberation from liberalism itself," recasting the book not as a funeral oration, but as an urgent call to action for liberal self-renewal.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Critical, Nuanced, Evaluative, Persuasive, and Reformist.
-
Author's Perspective: Writing from an enlightened liberal standpoint, the author defends liberalism as an adaptable, self-correcting political tradition. Rejecting conservative defeatism, the author argues that the remedies to liberalism's current crises lie within its own historical tradition of institutional reform and ethical renewal.
Other questions in this set
- Q6. The author of the passage refers to "the Davos elite" to illustrate his views on:
- Q7. All of the following statements are evidence of the decline of liberalism today, EXCEPT:
- Q8. The author of the passage is likely to disagree with all of the following statements, EXCEPT:
Politics questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q5
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q6
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q7
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q8
- CAT 2024 Slot 3 VARC Q16
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc