CAT 2024 Slot 2 VARC Q23
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Verbal Ability › Sentence Placement
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2024_SLOT2_VARC_Q23
Question 23
There is a sentence that is missing in the paragraph below. Look at the paragraph and decide where (option 1, 2, 3, or 4) the following sentence would best fit.
Paragraph: My fellow night owls, grab a strong cup of coffee and gather around: I have great news ___ (1) ___ . For a long time, our kind has been unfairly maligned. Stereotyped as lazy and undisciplined. Told we ought to be morning larks. Advised to go to bed early so we can wake before 5am and run a marathon before breakfast like all high-flyers seem to do. Now, however, we are having the last laugh ___ (2) ___ .It may be a tad more complicated than that. A study published last week, which you may have already seen while scrolling at lam, suggests that staying up late could be good for brain power ___ (3) ___ .Is this study a thinly veiled PR exercise conducted by a caffeine-pill company? Nope, it's legit ___ (4) ___ . Research led by academics at Imperial College London studied data on more than 26,000 people and found that “self-declared 'night owls' generally tend to have higher cognitive scores".
Sentence: Science has officially crowned us superior to our early-rising brethren.
Show answer and solution
Answer: (A)
Option 2
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Sentence Insertion / Discourse Coherence
-
Target Sentence:
"Science has officially crowned us superior to our early-rising brethren."
- Context Surrounding Position (2):
Preceding Context: "Now, however, we are having the last laugh ___ (2) ___ ."
Succeeding Context: "It may be a tad more complicated than that. A study published last week, which you may have already seen while scrolling at lam, suggests that staying up late could be good for brain power..."
Logical Deduction
To determine the optimal placement for the target sentence:
-
Thematic Justification for Position 2:
-
The paragraph recounts the long history of night owls being maligned as lazy and urged to wake up early like high-flyers, culminating in the triumphant statement: "Now, however, we are having the last laugh."
-
The target sentence provides the immediate factual justification for having the last laugh: "Science has officially crowned us superior to our early-rising brethren."
-
-
Grammatical & Demonstrative Antecedent Chain:
-
The sentence immediately following Position (2) states: "It may be a tad more complicated than that."
-
The demonstrative pronoun "that" requires a direct, specific referent. It refers precisely to the sweeping, hyperbolic assertion that science has crowned night owls "superior to our early-rising brethren." Without the target sentence at Position (2), the pronoun "that" lacks an antecedent, creating an incoherent transition.
-
-
Option-to-Position Mapping:
-
In the provided question format, the options represent insertion positions:
-
Option 1 corresponds to 'Option 2' (Position 2).
-
Option 2 corresponds to 'Option 4' (Position 4).
-
Option 3 corresponds to 'Option 3' (Position 3).
-
Option 4 corresponds to 'Option 1' (Position 1).
-
-
Therefore, Option 1 is the correct selection.
-
Correct Answer: Option 1 (Position 2)
- Option 1 is correct because Position 2 provides the triumphant claim explaining why night owls are "having the last laugh," while seamlessly serving as the indispensable antecedent for the pronoun "that" in "It may be a tad more complicated than that."
Option Elimination & Positional Justification
-
Option 4 [Position 1] (Premature Placement / Disrupts Narrative Build-up): Placing the sentence at (1) prematurely reveals the climax before detailing the historical grievances and unfair stereotypes that give the vindication its emotional resonance.
-
Option 3 [Position 3] (Disrupts Scientific Evaluation): Position (3) interrupts the smooth rhetorical transition between introducing the study's premise ("good for brain power") and interrogating its methodological legitimacy ("Is this study a thinly veiled PR exercise...").
-
Option 2 [Position 4] (Ruptures Verification Chain): Position (4) breaks the tight linkage between confirming the study's credibility ("Nope, it's legit") and providing the academic attribution to Imperial College London.
Detailed explanation
📖 Context & Paragraph Structure
Central Theme
A humorous, vindicatory defense of "night owls," balancing triumphant claims of scientific superiority against an empirical study from Imperial College London examining cognitive performance across chronotypes.
Paragraph Flow & Structural Anchors
-
Opening Invocation & Historical Grievances: The author calls fellow night owls together to celebrate vindication after years of being stereotyped as lazy and told to emulate early risers.
-
The Triumphant Climax: Reaching the turning point of "having the last laugh," which demands the triumphant proclamation of scientific vindication.
-
The Rhetorical Caveat: A tempering qualification ("It may be a tad more complicated than that") that immediately follows the boast.
-
The Empirical Evidence: Introduction and validation of the Imperial College London study confirming higher cognitive scores for night owls.
Sentence Placement questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q17
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q18
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 VARC Q1
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 VARC Q10
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q2
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc