CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q18
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Verbal Ability › Sentence Placement
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2025_SLOT1_VARC_Q18
Question 18
The given sentence is missing in the paragraph below. Decide where it best fits among the options 1, 2, 3, or 4 indicated in the paragraph.
Sentence: Historically, silver has been, and still is, an important element in the business of 'show' visible in private houses, churches, government and diplomacy.
Paragraph: ____(1) ____. Timothy Schroder put it succinctly in suggesting that electric light and eating in the kitchen eroded this need. As he explained to the author, 'Silver, when illuminated by flickering candlelight, comes alive and almost dances before the eyes, but when lit by electric light it becomes flat and dead.' ____(2) ____. Domestic and economic changes may have worked against the market, but the London silver trade remained buoyant, thanks to the competition of collectors seeking grand display silver at the top end, and the buyers of 'collectables', like spoons and wine labels and 'novelties', at the bottom. ____(3) ____. Another factor that came into play was the systematic collection building of certain American museums over the period. Boston, Huntington Art Gallery and Williamsburg, among others, were largely supplied by London dealers. ____(4) ____.
Show answer and solution
Answer: (A)
Option 1
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Sentence Insertion / Textual Cohesion
-
Contextual Anchor:
Sentence to Insert: "Historically, silver has been, and still is, an important element in the business of 'show' visible in private houses, churches, government and diplomacy."
Succeeding Sentence: "Timothy Schroder put it succinctly in suggesting that electric light and eating in the kitchen eroded this need."
Logical Deduction
To identify the mandatory location for the missing sentence, we examine anaphoric reference and discourse cohesion:
-
Anaphoric Referent ("this need"): The sentence immediately following Blank (1) begins: "Timothy Schroder put it succinctly in suggesting that electric light and eating in the kitchen eroded this need."
-
The singular demonstrative noun phrase "this need" requires an explicit antecedent establishing a functional requirement or social purpose. The unedited paragraph begins at Blank (1) without defining what "need" was eroded.
-
The target sentence supplies this precise antecedent: silver was historically indispensable in the "business of 'show'" (the cultural need for ostentatious display in residences, churches, and diplomacy). Schroder's thesis explains that electric light and kitchen dining eroded this very need for theatrical candlelight display.
-
Placing the target sentence at Blank (1) resolves the referential ambiguity of "this need" and establishes the foundational premise for the entire paragraph.
-
In the options, the position labeled Blank (1) is listed as "Option 1" (Choice 1).
Correct Answer: Option 1
- Blank (1) establishes silver's historical role in the business of "show," providing the indispensable semantic antecedent for "this need" that was subsequently eroded by electric light and informal dining.
Option Elimination
-
Option 2 (Disruptive Placement / Syntactic Disconnect at Position 3): Position (3) falls between the discussion of private collectors (high-end display silver and low-end novelties) and institutional museum acquisitions ("Another factor that came into play..."), where reintroducing a basic historical definition would disrupt the market analysis.
-
Option 3 (Disruptive Placement / Cohesion Breakdown at Position 2): Position (2) separates Schroder's aesthetic contrast (candlelight vs. electric light) from the structural market pivot ("Domestic and economic changes may have worked against the market..."), interrupting an established evidentiary flow.
-
Option 4 (Disruptive Placement / Redundant Conclusion at Position 4): Position (4) follows a specific list of American museums supplied by London dealers; placing a broad introductory definition of silver's ceremonial role at the very end leaves the antecedent "this need" in sentence 1 completely unresolved.
Detailed explanation
📖 Context & Paragraph Structure
Central Theme
The cultural and commercial trajectory of the London silver trade, examining how shifting domestic lighting and dining habits diminished silver's traditional role in social display, and how elite collector markets and American institutional acquisitions sustained trade vitality.
Key Structural Transitions & Contextual Flow
-
Ostentatious Display & Domestic Erosion (Opening & Blank 1 to 2): Introduces silver's historic function as an instrument of social spectacle ("show"), followed immediately by Timothy Schroder's thesis that electric lighting and informal kitchen dining eroded this display imperative.
-
Market Resilience via Bipolar Collecting (Blank 2 to 3): Contrasts domestic lifestyle shifts against the enduring buoyancy of the London market, driven by top-tier collectors of grand display silver alongside niche buyers of decorative collectibles.
-
Institutional Demand (Blank 3 to 4): Identifies systematic acquisitions by prominent American museums (Boston, Huntington, Williamsburg) as an external pillar sustaining London dealers.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Scholarly, Historical, and Socio-Economic.
-
Author's Perspective: Nuanced art-market historian; reconciles technological and domestic shifts with structural collector demand.
Sentence Placement questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q5
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q23
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q24
- CAT 2024 Slot 2 VARC Q2
- CAT 2024 Slot 2 VARC Q9
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc