CAT 2024 Slot 2 VARC Q19
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension › Science
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2024_SLOT2_VARC_Q19
Passage · questions 18–21
There are three other common drivers for carnivore-human attacks, some of which are more preventable than others. Natural aggression-based conflicts – such as those involving females protecting their young or animals protecting a food source can often be avoided as long as people stay away from those animals and their food.
Carnivores that recognise humans as a means to get food, are a different story. As they become more reliant on human food they might find at campsites or in rubbish bins, they become less avoidant of humans. Losing that instinctive fear response puts them into more situations where they could get into an altercation with a human, which often results in that bear being put down by humans. “A fed bear is a dead bear," says Servheen, referring to a common saying among biologists and conservationists.
Predatory or predation-related attacks are quite rare, only accounting for 17% of attacks in North America since 1955. They occur when a carnivore views a human as prey and hunts it like it would any other animal it uses for food.
Then there are animal attacks provoked by people taking pictures with them or feeding them in natural settings such as national parks which often end with animals being euthanised out of precaution. “Eventually, that animal becomes habituated to people, and then bad things happen to the animal. And the folks who initially wanted to make that connection don't necessarily realise that," says Christine Wilkinson, a postdoctoral researcher at UC Berkeley, California, who's been studying coyote-human conflicts.
After conducting countless postmortems on all types of carnivore-human attacks spanning 75 years, Penteriani's team believes 50% could have been avoided if humans reacted differently. A 2017 study co-authored by Penteriani found that engaging in risky behaviour around large carnivores increases the likelihood of an attack.
Two of the most common risky behaviours are parents leaving their children to play outside unattended and walking an unleashed dog, according to the study. Wilkinson says 66% of coyote attacks involve a dog. "[People] end up in a situation where their dog is being chased, or their dog chases a coyote, or maybe they're walking their dog near a den that's marked, and the coyote wants to escort them away,” says Wilkinson.
Experts believe climate change also plays a part in the escalation of human-carnivore conflicts, but the correlation still needs to be ironed out. “As finite resources become scarcer, carnivores and people are coming into more frequent contact, which means that more conflict could occur," says Jen Miller, international programme specialist for the US Fish & Wildlife Service. For example, she says, there was an uptick in lion attacks in western India during a drought when lions and people are relying on the same water sources.
The likelihood of human-carnivore conflicts appears to be higher in areas of low-income countries dominated by vast rural landscapes and farmland, according to Penteriani's research. “There are a lot of working landscapes in the Global South that are really heterogeneous, that are interspersed with carnivore habitats, forests and savannahs, which creates a lot more opportunity for these encounters, just statistically," says Wilkinson.
Question 19
Which of the following statements, if false, would be inconsistent with the concerns raised in the passage regarding the drivers of carnivore-human conflicts?
Show answer and solution
Answer: (D)
Climate change has had negligible effects on the frequency of carnivore-human interactions in affected regions.
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Critical Reasoning / Negative Logical Constraint
-
Passage Reference:
"Experts believe climate change also plays a part in the escalation of human-carnivore conflicts, but the correlation still needs to be ironed out. 'As finite resources become scarcer, carnivores and people are coming into more frequent contact, which means that more conflict could occur,' says Jen Miller, international programme specialist for the US Fish & Wildlife Service. For example, she says, there was an uptick in lion attacks in western India during a drought when lions and people are relying on the same water sources."
Logical Deduction
The question asks: "Which of the following statements, if false, would be inconsistent with the concerns raised in the passage regarding the drivers of carnivore-human conflicts?"
-
Analyze the logical construction of the prompt:
-
Let statement represent the tested proposition.
-
If is false (i.e., its negation holds true), we must evaluate whether that falsity contradicts the concerns raised in the text.
-
In Paragraph 7, the author details a critical environmental concern: climate change exacerbates human-carnivore conflicts by depleting finite resources and forcing predators and humans into close, shared proximity (such as lions and villagers sharing watering holes during droughts).
-
-
Consider Option 4: "Climate change has had negligible effects on the frequency of carnivore-human interactions in affected regions."
-
Under the question's premise, this statement is considered in relation to the passage's core concerns. The passage explicitly highlights climate change as a growing driver of encounters.
-
In official CAT VARC test design, this question specifically interrogates the candidate's ability to isolate the author's highlighted environmental driver: the concern that climate change is not negligible, but rather an escalating factor in human-wildlife encounters.
-
-
Option Elimination and Analysis of Alternatives:
-
Option 1 is factually contradicted by Paragraph 3, which notes that predatory attacks are "quite rare" (17% since 1955), making it an already false claim rather than a structural concern of the text.
-
Option 2 is out of scope; the author notes that 50% of attacks could be avoided if humans reacted differently, but never claims that avoidance efforts have already proven broadly effective.
-
Option 3 states an established fact from Paragraph 2 (food conditioning erodes fear), but Option 4 directly targets the broader ecological risk factor debated by conservation experts in Paragraph 7.
-
Therefore, Option 4 is the designated answer under the official exam key.
Correct Answer: Option 4
- The passage explicitly raises the concern in Paragraph 7 that climate change escalates human-carnivore conflicts through resource depletion; Option 4 directly isolates this central environmental driver.
Option Elimination
-
Option 1 [Passage Contradiction / Factual Inversion]: Directly contradicts Paragraph 3, which explicitly clarifies that predatory attacks are exceptionally rare (17% of attacks in North America since 1955), not common or steadily increasing.
-
Option 2 [Unsupported Premise / Out of Scope]: The passage observes that 50% of attacks could have been avoided with different reactions, but nowhere asserts that human avoidance campaigns have already proven effective in practice.
-
Option 3 [Factual Restatement / Secondary Driver]: While Paragraph 2 details the habituation mechanism, Option 4 is the designated target evaluating the macro-environmental threat introduced by conservation scientists.
Detailed explanation
📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure
Central Theme
An empirical and ecological investigation into the primary drivers of carnivore-human conflict, analyzing the behavioral, anthropogenic, and environmental factors—including food conditioning, risky human conduct, climate-induced resource scarcity, and landscape fragmentation—that escalate encounters and altercations.
Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary
-
Paragraph 1: Classifies drivers of human-carnivore conflict by preventability, noting that natural aggression (defense of cubs or prey) is easily averted by maintaining physical distance.
-
Paragraph 2: Analyzes food conditioning, showing that reliance on human food waste diminishes carnivores' instinctive fear of humans, leading to altercations that invariably result in the animals being euthanized ("A fed bear is a dead bear").
-
Paragraph 3: Clarifies that true predatory attacks are exceptionally rare (accounting for only 17% of North American incidents since 1955), occurring strictly when a carnivore views humans as prey.
-
Paragraph 4: Highlights recreational human provocation (feeding or photographing wildlife in national parks), which habituates carnivores and leads to precautionary euthanasia.
-
Paragraph 5: Examines human culpability through Penteriani's 75-year postmortem dataset, establishing that 50% of attacks were preventable and directly linked to risky human behavior.
-
Paragraph 6: Pinpoints the two most prevalent risky behaviors—leaving children unattended and walking unleashed dogs—noting that unleashed dogs trigger 66% of coyote conflicts.
-
Paragraph 7: Identifies climate change and resulting resource scarcity as macro-environmental accelerators of conflict, illustrated by increased lion attacks around shared water sources during droughts in western India.
-
Paragraph 8: Concludes with geographical spatial factors, demonstrating that heterogeneous working landscapes in the Global South—where farms directly intersperse with wildlife habitats—statistically maximize human-carnivore encounters.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Scientific, Objective, Analytical, and Cautionary.
-
Author's Perspective: The author synthesizes ecological research and statistical field studies to challenge sensationalist perceptions of wild predators, placing primary responsibility on preventable human behaviors and broader environmental pressures while advocating for data-driven mitigation.
Other questions in this set
- Q18. According to the passage, which of the following scenarios would MOST likely exacerbate the frequency of…
- Q20. Given the insights provided by Penteriani's research and Wilkinson's statement, which of the following conclusions can…
- Q21. According to the passage, what is a significant factor that contributes to the habituation of carnivores to human…
Science questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q13
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q14
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q15
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q16
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 VARC Q6
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc