CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q14

  • Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
  • Reading Comprehension › Science
  • Hard
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2025_SLOT1_VARC_Q14

Passage · questions 13–16

Understanding the key properties of complex systems can help us clarify and deal with many new and existing global challenges, from pandemics to poverty . . . A recent study in Nature Physics found transitions to orderly states such as schooling in fish (all fish swimming in the same direction), can be caused, paradoxically, by randomness, or ‘noise’ feeding back on itself. That is, a misalignment among the fish causes further misalignment, eventually inducing a transition to schooling. Most of us wouldn’t guess that noise can produce predictable behaviour. The result invites us to consider how technology such as contact-tracing apps, although informing us locally, might negatively impact our collective movement. If each of us changes our behaviour to avoid the infected, we might generate a collective pattern we had aimed to avoid: higher levels of interaction between the infected and susceptible, or high levels of interaction among the asymptomatic.

Complex systems also suffer from a special vulnerability to events that don’t follow a normal distribution or ‘bell curve’. When events are distributed normally, most outcomes are familiar and don’t seem particularly striking. Height is a good example: it’s pretty unusual for a man to be over 7 feet tall; most adults are between 5 and 6 feet, and there is no known person over 9 feet tall. But in collective settings where contagion shapes behaviour – a run on the banks, a scramble to buy toilet paper – the probability distributions for possible events are often heavy-tailed. There is a much higher probability of extreme events, such as a stock market crash or a massive surge in infections. These events are still unlikely, but they occur more frequently and are larger than would be expected under normal distributions.

What’s more, once a rare but hugely significant ‘tail’ event takes place, this raises the probability of further tail events. We might call them second-order tail events; they include stock market gyrations after a big fall and earthquake aftershocks. The initial probability of second-order tail events is so tiny it’s almost impossible to calculate – but once a first-order tail event occurs, the rules change, and the probability of a second-order tail event increases.

The dynamics of tail events are complicated by the fact that they result from cascades of other unlikely events. When COVID-19 first struck, the stock market suffered stunning losses followed by an equally stunning recovery. Some of these dynamics are potentially attributable to former sports bettors, with no sports to bet on, entering the market as speculators rather than investors. The arrival of these new players might have increased inefficiencies and allowed savvy long-term investors to gain an edge over bettors with different goals. . . .

One reason a first-order tail event can induce further tail events is that it changes the perceived costs of our actions and changes the rules that we play by. This game-change is an example of another key complex systems concept: nonstationarity. A second, canonical example of nonstationarity is adaptation, as illustrated by the arms race involved in the coevolution of hosts and parasites [in which] each has to ‘run’ faster, just to keep up with the novel solutions the other one presents as they battle it out in evolutionary time.

Question 14

The passage suggests that contact tracing apps could inadvertently raise risky interactions by altering local behaviour. Which one of the assumptions below is most necessary for that suggestion to hold?

  1. A

    Individuals base movement choices partly on observed infections and on the behaviour of others. So, local responses interact, which turns many small adjustments into large scale patterns that can frustrate the intended aim of risk reduction.

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    Most users uninstall apps within a week, which leaves only highly exposed individuals participating. This neutralises any systematic bias in routing decisions and prevents any predictable change in aggregate contact patterns.

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    Urban networks have uniform traffic conditions at all hours, which allows perfectly predictable routing independent of personal choices, social signals, or crowd reactions and, therefore, makes interdependence negligible in city movement decisions.

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    App alerts always include precise location to within one metre and deliver real time updates for all users, which ensures that the data feed is perfectly accurate regardless of privacy settings, power limits, or network conditions.

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (A)

Individuals base movement choices partly on observed infections and on the behaviour of others. So, local responses interact, which turns many small adjustments into large scale patterns that can frustrate the intended aim of risk reduction.

Solution

🎯 Question Analysis & Solution

  • Question Type: Critical Reasoning / Necessary Assumption

  • Passage Reference:

Paragraph 1: "The result invites us to consider how technology such as contact-tracing apps, although informing us locally, might negatively impact our collective movement. If each of us changes our behaviour to avoid the infected, we might generate a collective pattern we had aimed to avoid: higher levels of interaction between the infected and susceptible, or high levels of interaction among the asymptomatic."

Logical Deduction

The passage hypothesizes that contact-tracing apps could perversely increase risky interactions because individual local adjustments aggregate into counterproductive collective patterns:

  1. Underlying Premise: Individuals receive local alerts, observe infection data, and adjust their movement paths accordingly to avoid transmission zones.

  2. Necessary Bridge: For these isolated local decisions to produce an aggregate outcome that contradicts the intended goal (i.e., paradoxically concentrating susceptible and infected individuals), individual movement choices must be interdependent. If individuals' choices were isolated or failed to interact dynamically, their adjustments could not aggregate into an emergent macro-level pattern of heightened transmission.

  3. Assumption Formulation: Individuals base movement decisions on observed infections and peer behavior, and these local reactions dynamically interact to generate large-scale systemic patterns that frustrate risk reduction.

  4. Applying the Negation Test: If individuals do not base movement on observed infections or others' behavior, or if local responses do not interact to form systemic patterns, the apps cannot induce the unintended macro-level contact surge described by the author. Thus, the argument collapses without this assumption.

Correct Answer: Option 1

  • Identifies the indispensable systemic assumption: individual routing adjustments are interdependent and interact dynamically, aggregating small behavioral shifts into counterproductive macro-level contact patterns.

Option Elimination

  • Option 2 (Reversed Logic / Weakening Premise): If users quickly uninstall the app and no systematic behavioral bias or predictable aggregate pattern emerges, the mechanism generating the adverse collective outcome is dismantled entirely.

  • Option 3 (Direct Contradiction / Contrary to Premise): Claiming traffic conditions are uniform and movement is independent of personal choices or social signals directly negates the complex-systems premise of behavioral interdependence and feedback loops.

  • Option 4 (Out of Scope / Irrelevant Technical Detail): Hyper-accurate GPS data (to within one meter) is neither mentioned nor logically necessary; the perverse macro-pattern stems from behavioral feedback and emergent dynamics, not hardware telemetry precision.

Detailed explanation

📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure

Central Theme

The structural dynamics and behavioral anomalies of complex systems across epidemiology, financial markets, and evolutionary biology. The author argues that complex systems exhibit emergent order generated paradoxically from randomness ("noise"), extreme vulnerability to heavy-tailed probability distributions where rare catastrophes are amplified by contagion, and structural rule changes—termed nonstationarity—where an initial shock permanently alters actor incentives and triggers cascades of subsequent tail events.

Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary

  • Paragraph 1: Explores how complex systems can generate macroscopic order from randomness ("noise" feeding back on itself, such as fish schooling); applies this paradox to contact-tracing apps, cautioning that uncoordinated local risk avoidance can perversely aggregate into heightened collective infection rates.

  • Paragraph 2: Contrasts familiar Gaussian normal distributions (e.g., adult human height) with the heavy-tailed distributions governing contagion-driven collective phenomena (bank runs, panic buying, stock crashes, epidemic surges), where extreme tail events occur far more frequently and with greater magnitude than bell curves predict.

  • Paragraph 3: Formulates the concept of "second-order tail events" (such as post-crash equity gyrations or earthquake aftershocks), explaining that an initial severe shock rewrites the system's underlying dynamics and exponentially raises the probability of subsequent disruptions.

  • Paragraph 4: Examines how tail events arise from cascading sequences of improbable occurrences, using the post-COVID financial crash and rebound—potentially driven by displaced sports bettors entering equities as speculators—to illustrate behavioral market inefficiencies.

  • Paragraph 5: Synthesizes the core mechanism of cascading tail events through "nonstationarity"—a systemic game-change where early shocks permanently alter actor incentives and governing rules—canonically exemplified by the coevolutionary arms race between hosts and parasites.

Tone and Author's Perspective

  • Tone: Academic, Analytical, Systems-Theoretic, and Cautionary.

  • Author's Perspective: Systems-theoretic and interdisciplinary. The author challenges linear, Gaussian forecasting models in social and biological systems, advocating for a sophisticated appreciation of feedback loops, heavy tails, and dynamic adaptation.

Other questions in this set

  1. Q13. Which one of the options below best summarises the passage?
  2. Q15. All of the following inferences are supported by the passage EXCEPT that:
  3. Q16. Which one of the following observations would most strengthen the passage’s claim that a first-order tail event raises…

Science questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q12
    According to the text, the western barred bandicoots now have a flattering name because they have
  2. CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q13
    The text uses the word ‘exclosures’ because Wild Deserts has adopted a measure of
  3. CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q14
    Which one of the following options does NOT represent the characteristics of the western barred bandicoot?
  4. CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q15
    Which one of the following statements provides a gist of this passage?
  5. CAT 2024 Slot 2 VARC Q10
    All of the following are listed as reasons why academics choose to review other scholars' work EXCEPT:

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc