CAT 2024 Slot 2 VARC Q13
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension › Science
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2024_SLOT2_VARC_Q13
Passage · questions 10–13
The job of a peer reviewer is thankless. Collectively, academics spend around 70 million hours every year evaluating each other's manuscripts on the behalf of scholarly journals – and they usually receive no monetary compensation and little if any recognition for their effort. Some do it as a way to keep abreast with developments in their field; some simply see it as a duty to the discipline. Either way, academic publishing would likely crumble without them.
In recent years, some scientists have begun posting their reviews online, mainly to claim credit for their work. Sites like Publons allow researchers to either share entire referee reports or simply list the journals for whom they've carried out a review.
The rise of Publons suggests that academics are increasingly placing value on the work of peer review and asking others, such as grant funders, to do the same. While that's vital in the publish-or-perish culture of academia, there's also immense value in the data underlying peer review. Sharing peer review data could help journals stamp out fraud, inefficiency, and systemic bias in academic publishing.
Peer review data could also help root out bias. Last year, a study based on peer review data for nearly 24,000 submissions to the biomedical journal eLife found that women and non-Westerners were vastly underrepresented among peer reviewers. Only around one in every five reviewers was female, and less than two percent of reviewers were based in developing countries. Openly publishing peer review data could perhaps also help journals address another problem in academic publishing: fraudulent peer reviews. For instance, a minority of authors have been known to use phony email addresses to pose as an outside expert and review their own manuscripts.
Opponents of open peer review commonly argue that confidentiality is vital to the integrity of the review process; referees may be less critical of manuscripts if their reports are published, especially if they are revealing their identities by signing them. Some also hold concerns that open reviewing may deter referees from agreeing to judge manuscripts in the first place, or that they'll take longer to do so out of fear of scrutiny.
Even when the content of reviews and the identity of reviewers can't be shared publicly, perhaps journals could share the data with outside researchers for study. Or they could release other figures that wouldn't compromise the anonymity of reviews but that might answer important questions about how long the reviewing process takes, how many researchers editors have to reach out to on average to find one who will carry out the work, and the geographic distribution of peer reviewers.
Of course, opening up data underlying the reviewing process will not fix peer review entirely, and there may be instances in which there are valid reasons to keep the content of peer reviews hidden and the identity of the referees confidential. But the norm should shift from opacity in all cases to opacity only when necessary.
Question 13
According to the passage, some are opposed to making peer reviews public for all the following reasons EXCEPT that it
Show answer and solution
Answer: (C)
leaves the reviewers unexposed to unwarranted and unjustified criticism or comments from others.
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Negative Factual / Detail-Oriented (Except)
-
Passage Reference:
"Opponents of open peer review commonly argue that confidentiality is vital to the integrity of the review process; referees may be less critical of manuscripts if their reports are published, especially if they are revealing their identities by signing them. Some also hold concerns that open reviewing may deter referees from agreeing to judge manuscripts in the first place, or that they'll take longer to do so out of fear of scrutiny."
Logical Deduction
Paragraph 5 outlines the primary objections raised by opponents of making peer reviews public:
-
Referees might dilute critical rigor or withhold candid appraisals if reviews are published and signed ("referees may be less critical of manuscripts if their reports are published" -> Option 1).
-
The review timeline might be prolonged because reviewers take longer out of fear of being scrutinized ("take longer to do so out of fear of scrutiny" -> Option 2).
-
Potential reviewers might be deterred from agreeing to evaluate manuscripts altogether ("deter referees from agreeing to judge manuscripts in the first place" -> Option 4).
Now examine Option 3: "leaves the reviewers unexposed to unwarranted and unjustified criticism or comments from others."
-
This statement is logically inverted: opponents fear that open review will expose referees to scrutiny. Leaving reviewers unexposed is the alleged benefit of traditional confidential review, not a reason to oppose making reviews public.
-
Furthermore, the specific qualification "unwarranted and unjustified criticism" is absent from the passage, which simply mentions "fear of scrutiny."
-
Thus, Option 3 is an inverted, structurally incoherent reason for opposing open peer review.
Correct Answer: Option 3
- Leaving reviewers unexposed to scrutiny is the perceived benefit of the traditional confidential model, not an argument against making reviews public; opponents fear that open reviews will expose referees to scrutiny.
Option Elimination
-
Option 1 (Textually Supported / Opponent Concern): Paragraph 5 explicitly confirms that opponents argue published reviews will compromise integrity because referees "may be less critical of manuscripts."
-
Option 2 (Textually Supported / Opponent Concern): Paragraph 5 explicitly notes concerns that referees will "take longer to do so out of fear of scrutiny," causing delays in evaluation.
-
Option 3 (Correct Answer): Inverted logic. Making reviews public exposes reviewers to scrutiny rather than leaving them "unexposed"; thus, shielding reviewers from exposure is a defence of confidentiality, not an objection against open review.
-
Option 4 (Textually Supported / Opponent Concern): Paragraph 5 explicitly cites the fear that open reviewing "may deter referees from agreeing to judge manuscripts in the first place.
Detailed explanation
📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure
Central Theme
An evaluation of the systemic flaws and hidden labor in academic peer review, advocating for a decisive institutional transition from default opacity to transparency and open data sharing to counteract demographic bias, procedural inefficiencies, and fraudulent practices.
Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary
-
Paragraph 1: Highlights the massive, uncompensated labor of peer reviewers (~70 million hours annually) sustaining academic publishing, driven primarily by professional duty and keeping abreast of disciplinary developments.
-
Paragraph 2: Explains how researchers have begun using platforms like Publons to claim career credit for reviewing by posting referee reports or documenting verified journal service.
-
Paragraph 3: Argues that beyond individual credit recognition, the aggregate data underlying peer review possesses tremendous systemic value for eliminating fraud, inefficiency, and bias.
-
Paragraph 4: Demonstrates the reformative power of peer review data by citing the eLife study revealing severe gender and geographic underrepresentation, while noting its capacity to expose fraudulent self-reviews.
-
Paragraph 5: Acknowledges counterarguments from defenders of confidentiality, who fear that open reviews could diminish reviewer candor, deter referee participation, and prolong review durations.
-
Paragraph 6: Proposes pragmatic intermediate solutions, suggesting that journals share anonymized aggregate data with independent researchers to investigate review timelines, editorial burdens, and geographic demographics.
-
Paragraph 7: Concludes that while confidentiality may be warranted in specific exceptions, the foundational norm of academic publishing must shift from universal opacity to opacity only when strictly necessary.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Academic, persuasive, analytical, balanced, and reform-oriented.
-
Author's Perspective: Constructively critical and progressive; the author validates the indispensable contributions of reviewers, thoughtfully addresses legitimate confidentiality concerns, and champions systemic transparency as an imperative standard.
Other questions in this set
- Q10. All of the following are listed as reasons why academics choose to review other scholars' work EXCEPT:
- Q11. Based on the passage we can infer that the author would most probably support
- Q12. According to the passage, which of the following is the only reason NOT given in favour of making peer review data…
Science questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q13
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q14
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q15
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q16
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 VARC Q6
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc