CAT 2023 Slot 3 VARC Q2
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension › Philosophy
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2023_SLOT3_VARC_Q02
Passage · questions 1–3
Steven Pinker's new book, "Rationality: What It is, Why it Seems Scarce, Why It Matters," offers a pragmatic dose of measured optimism, presenting rationality as a fragile but achievable ideal in personal and civic life. Pinker's ambition to illuminate such a crucial topic offers the welcome prospect of a return to sanity. It's no small achievement to make formal logic, game theory, statistics and Bayesian reasoning delightful topics full of charm and relevance.
It's also plausible to believe that a wider application of the rational tools he analyzes would improve the world in important ways. His primer on statistics and scientific uncertainty is particularly timely and should be required reading before consuming any news about the COVID pandemic. More broadly, he argues that less media coverage of shocking but vanishingly rare events, from shark attacks to adverse vaccine reactions, would help prevent dangerous overreactions, fatalism and the diversion of finite resources away from solvable but less-dramatic issues, like malnutrition in the developing world.
It's a reasonable critique, and Pinker is not the first to make it. But analyzing the political economy of journalism its funding structures, ownership concentration and increasing reliance on social media shares would have given a fuller picture of why so much coverage is so misguided and what we might do about it.
Pinker's main focus is the sort of conscious, sequential reasoning that can track the steps in a geometric proof or an argument in formal logic. Skill in this domain maps directly onto the navigation of many real-world problems, and Pinker shows how greater mastery of the tools of rationality can improve decision-making in medical, legal, financial and many other contexts in which we must act on uncertain and shifting information.
Despite the undeniable power of the sort of rationality he describes, many of the deepest insights in the history of science, math, music and art strike their originators in moments of epiphany. From the 19th century chemist Friedrich August Kekulé's discovery of the structure of benzene to any of Mozart's symphonies, much extraordinary human achievement is not a product of conscious, sequential reasoning. Even Plato's Socrates who anticipated many of Pinker's points by nearly 2,500 years, showing the virtue of knowing what you do not know and examining all premises in arguments, not simply trusting speakers' authority or charisma attributed many of his most profound insights to dreams and visions. Conscious reasoning is helpful in sorting the wheat from the chaff, but it would be interesting to consider the hidden aquifers that make much of the grain grow in the first place.
The role of moral and ethical education in promoting rational behavior is also underexplored. Pinker recognizes that rationality "is not just a cognitive virtue but a moral one." But this profoundly important point, one subtly explored by ancient Greek philosophers like Plato and Aristotle, doesn't really get developed. This is a shame, since possessing the right sort of moral character is arguably a precondition for using rationality in beneficial ways.
Question 2
According to the author, for Pinker as well as the ancient Greek philosophers, rational thinking involves all of the following EXCEPT:
Show answer and solution
Answer: (D)
the primacy of conscious sequential reasoning as the basis for seminal human achievements.
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Negative Detail / Inference ("EXCEPT")
-
Passage Reference:
"Even Plato's Socrates — who anticipated many of Pinker's points by nearly 2,500 years, showing the virtue of knowing what you do not know and examining all premises in arguments, not simply trusting speakers' authority or charisma — attributed many of his most profound insights to dreams and visions. Conscious reasoning is helpful in sorting the wheat from the chaff, but it would be interesting to consider the hidden aquifers that make much of the grain grow in the first place."
"From the 19th century chemist Friedrich August Kekulé's discovery of the structure of benzene to any of Mozart's symphonies, much extraordinary human achievement is not a product of conscious, sequential reasoning."
Logical Deduction
The question asks for the attribute that is NOT shared by Pinker and the ancient Greek philosophers (or is explicitly rejected as the sole foundation of seminal achievements).
In Paragraph 5, the author demonstrates that seminal human achievements—ranging from scientific discoveries (Kekulé) to artistic creations (Mozart) and philosophical breakthroughs (Socrates)—are frequently born of intuitive epiphanies, dreams, and visions rather than conscious sequential deduction. The author explicitly states that "much extraordinary human achievement is not a product of conscious, sequential reasoning." Furthermore, Socrates himself attributed his profound insights to non-sequential sources like dreams and visions. While Pinker champions sequential reasoning, the ancient Greeks recognized its limits, and the author rejects its primacy as the sole source of seminal breakthroughs.
Conversely:
-
Both recognize the moral dimension of rationality (Paragraph 6: Pinker sees it as a moral virtue, and Plato/Aristotle subtly explored it), validating Option 1.
-
Both emphasize intellectual humility ("knowing what you do not know") and premise scrutiny ("examining all premises in arguments"), validating Option 2.
-
Both demand rational skepticism rather than blind obedience to authority or charisma ("not simply trusting speakers' authority or charisma"), validating Option 3.
Thus, asserting the primacy of conscious sequential reasoning as the basis for seminal achievements is contrary to the author's and Greek philosophers' positions.
Correct Answer: Option 4
- Option 4 is correct because the author explicitly refutes the idea that conscious sequential reasoning forms the sole basis of seminal achievements, observing that monumental discoveries (including those of Socrates) arose from non-sequential epiphanies, dreams, and visions.
Option Elimination
-
Option 1 (Incomplete Fact): Paragraph 6 explicitly confirms that both Pinker (who acknowledges rationality as a "moral virtue") and ancient Greek philosophers like Plato and Aristotle associate rational thought with an ethical dimension; hence, this is a shared belief and cannot be the correct answer for an EXCEPT question.
-
Option 2 (Incomplete Fact): Paragraph 5 explicitly notes that Socrates anticipated Pinker by demonstrating "the virtue of knowing what you do not know" (recognizing gaps in knowledge) and "examining all premises in arguments" (awareness of assumptions); thus, this is an endorsed principle shared by both.
-
Option 3 (Incomplete Fact): Paragraph 5 highlights that both Socrates and Pinker advocate evaluating arguments independently rather than "simply trusting speakers' authority or charisma," meaning arriving at independent conclusions regardless of the speaker is a shared tenet.
Detailed explanation
📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure
Central Theme
The passage reviews Steven Pinker's book Rationality: What It Is, Why It Seems Scarce, Why It Matters, evaluating the efficacy of formal sequential logic in real-world decision-making while offering a nuanced critique of its limitations—specifically highlighting the unaddressed political economy of sensationalist media, the non-sequential and intuitive genesis of seminal human discoveries, and the indispensable foundation of moral and ethical character required to deploy rationality for civic good.
Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary
-
Paragraph 1: Introduces Pinker's book as a pragmatic, measured defense of rationality in personal and civic life, praising his rare ability to render formal logic, game theory, probability statistics, and Bayesian reasoning accessible, engaging, and relevant.
-
Paragraph 2: Outlines the real-world utility of Pinker's rational toolkit, particularly his timely primer on statistics and scientific uncertainty during crises like COVID-19, and echoes his critique that media obsession with rare, sensational hazards diverts critical resources from mundane but solvable global crises like malnutrition.
-
Paragraph 3: Offers a methodological critique of Pinker's media diagnosis, asserting that a thorough examination of the political economy of journalism—concentrated corporate ownership, advertising revenue structures, and algorithmic dependence on social media engagement—is essential to truly comprehend and correct journalistic bias.
-
Paragraph 4: Defines Pinker's central focus as conscious, sequential reasoning (akin to geometric proofs and symbolic logic) and affirms that competence in this domain directly enhances practical decision-making across complex, uncertain legal, medical, and financial landscapes.
-
Paragraph 5: Counterbalances Pinker's thesis by observing that epochal breakthroughs in science, mathematics, and the arts (e.g., Kekulé's benzene ring, Mozart's compositions, and Socrates' insights) originate in intuitive epiphanies, dreams, and visions rather than linear deduction, suggesting conscious reasoning merely refines and tests the fruits of subconscious creativity.
-
Paragraph 6: Concludes by identifying a critical philosophical omission in Pinker's work: the failure to develop the intrinsic moral dimension of rationality explored by classical philosophers such as Plato and Aristotle, arguing that virtuous moral character is a necessary prerequisite for using rationality constructively.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Academic, Balanced, Analytical, and Critically Appreciative.
-
Author's Perspective: The author maintains an intellectually rigorous and appreciative stance toward Pinker's defense of rationality, while systematically probing its theoretical blind spots—demanding structural economic analysis of institutions, acknowledging non-linear cognitive epiphanies, and insisting upon ethical character as an indispensable prerequisite for rational action.
Other questions in this set
- Q1. The author endorses Pinker's views on the importance of logical reasoning as it:
- Q3. The author refers to the ancient Greek philosophers to:
Philosophy questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q11
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q12
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q13
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q14
- CAT 2022 Slot 1 VARC Q1
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc