CAT 2023 Slot 1 VARC Q3
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension › Culture
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2023_SLOT1_VARC_Q03
Passage · questions 1–4
Many human phenomena and characteristics – such as behaviors, beliefs, economies, genes, incomes, life expectancies, and other things - are influenced both by geographic factors and by non-geographic factors. Geographic factors mean physical and biological factors tied to geographic location, including climate, the distributions of wild plant and animal species, soils, and topography. Non-geographic factors include those factors subsumed under the term culture, other factors subsumed under the term history, and decisions by individual people.
The differences between the current economies of North and South Korea cannot be attributed to the modest environmental differences between them. They are instead due entirely to the different government policies. At the opposite extreme, the Inuit and other traditional peoples living north of the Arctic Circle developed warm fur clothes but no agriculture, while equatorial lowland peoples around the world never developed warm fur clothes but often did develop agriculture. The explanation is straightforwardly geographic, rather than a cultural or historical quirk unrelated to geography. Aboriginal Australia remained the sole continent occupied only by hunter/gatherers and with no indigenous farming or herding. The explanation is biogeographic: the Australian continent has no domesticable native animal species and few domesticable native plant species. Instead, the crops and domestic animals that now make Australia a food and wool exporter are all non-native (mainly Eurasian) species such as sheep, wheat, and grapes, brought to Australia by overseas colonists.
Today, no scholar would be silly enough to deny that culture, history, and individual choices play a big role in many human phenomena. Scholars don't react to cultural, historical, and individual-agent explanations by denouncing "cultural determinism," "historical determinism,” or “individual determinism," and then thinking no further. But many scholars do react to any explanation invoking some geographic role, by denouncing "geographic determinism".
Several reasons may underlie this widespread but nonsensical view. One reason is that some geographic explanations advanced a century ago were racist, thereby causing all geographic explanations to become tainted by racist associations in the minds of many scholars other than geographers. But many genetic, historical, psychological, and anthropological explanations advanced a century ago were also racist, yet the validity of newer non-racist genetic etc. explanations is widely accepted today.
Another reason for reflex rejection of geographic explanations is that historians have a tradition, in their discipline, of stressing the role of contingency (a favorite word among historians) based on individual decisions and chance. Often that view is warranted. But often, too, that view is unwarranted. The development of warm fur clothes among the Inuit living north of the Arctic Circle was not because one influential Inuit leader persuaded other Inuit in 1783 to adopt warm fur clothes, for no good environmental reason.
A third reason is that geographic explanations usually depend on detailed technical facts of geography and other fields of scholarship. Most historians and economists don't acquire that detailed knowledge as part of the professional training.
Question 3
All of the following are advanced by the author as reasons why non-geographers disregard geographic influences on human phenomena EXCEPT their:
Show answer and solution
Answer: (C)
dismissal of explanations that involve geographical causes for human behaviour.
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Negative Detail / Causal Identification (Except Question)
-
Passage Reference:
"Several reasons may underlie this widespread but nonsensical view. One reason is that some geographic explanations advanced a century ago were racist, thereby causing all geographic explanations to become tainted by racist associations in the minds of many scholars other than geographers."
"Another reason for reflex rejection of geographic explanations is that historians have a tradition, in their discipline, of stressing the role of contingency (a favorite word among historians) based on individual decisions and chance."
"A third reason is that geographic explanations usually depend on detailed technical facts of geography and other fields of scholarship. Most historians and economists don't acquire that detailed knowledge as part of the professional training."
Logical Deduction
The question stem asks to identify the option that is NOT advanced by the author as an underlying reason why non-geographers disregard geographic influences.
The author explicitly dedicates Paragraphs 4, 5, and 6 to outlining three distinct causal reasons:
-
Reason 1 (Paragraph 4): Historical taint of racism—geographic analyses from a century ago were racist, leading non-geographers to associate all geographic explanations with offensive ideologies. This corresponds directly to Option 4 ("lingering impressions of past geographic analyses that were politically offensive").
-
Reason 2 (Paragraph 5): Disciplinary tradition emphasizing human agency—historians prioritize contingency, chance, and individual choice over environmental conditioning. This corresponds directly to Option 1 ("belief in the central role of humans, unrelated to physical surroundings, in influencing phenomena").
-
Reason 3 (Paragraph 6): Lack of technical training—geographic explanations require specialized technical data from physical sciences, which historians and economists do not acquire during their professional education. This corresponds directly to Option 2 ("disciplinary training which typically does not include technical knowledge of geography").
-
Evaluating Option 3: Option 3 cites their "dismissal of explanations that involve geographical causes for human behaviour." Notice the fatal logical flaw here: dismissing geographical explanations is the phenomenon itself that the author is seeking to explain (the explanandum), NOT an underlying reason or cause (the explanans). Arguing that non-geographers disregard geographic explanations because they dismiss geographic causes is an empty tautology (begging the question). Therefore, Option 3 is not an explanatory reason advanced by the author.
Correct Answer: Option 3
- Option 3 merely restates the very phenomenon under discussion—the dismissal of geographical explanations—rather than identifying an underlying causal reason for that dismissal. It represents a circular tautology rather than an explanatory factor.
Option Elimination
-
Option 1 (True / Textually Validated Cause): Advanced in Paragraph 5 as the second major reason: historians have an institutional bias toward contingency and individual human agency, leading them to discount physical surroundings. Being a valid textual reason, it is eliminated.
-
Option 2 (True / Textually Validated Cause): Advanced in Paragraph 6 as the third major reason: professional training in history and economics typically lacks technical coursework in physical and biological geography. Being a valid textual reason, it is eliminated.
-
Option 3 (Tautological Assertion / Circular Reasoning): Conflates the observed effect with its cause. The dismissal of geographical causes is the exact action being investigated, not one of the three causal mechanisms (racist associations, contingency bias, training gaps) identified by the author. Thus, it is the correct answer.
-
Option 4 (True / Textually Validated Cause): Advanced in Paragraph 4 as the first major reason: 19th-century geographic arguments were tainted by racist doctrines, leaving politically offensive impressions that linger in modern academia. Being a valid textual reason, it is eliminated.
Detailed explanation
📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure
Central Theme
The intellectual validity of geographic and biogeographic explanations in understanding human history, societal institutions, and cultural traits, juxtaposed with the persistent, reflexive bias among non-geographer scholars who dismiss such frameworks as "geographic determinism." While acknowledging that human agency, political decisions, and culture are undeniably pivotal in many historical trajectories (as illustrated by North vs. South Korea), the author argues that physical and biological geography—such as climate, topography, and the distribution of domesticable wild flora and fauna—exert decisive, insurmountable constraints on human development (exemplified by the Arctic Inuit and Aboriginal Australia). The author critically deconstructs the three primary disciplinary and historical reasons underlying scholars' reflex dismissal of geographic causation: lingering stigmas from 19th-century racist theories, historians' dogmatic prioritization of contingency and individual human agency, and scholars' lack of technical training in the physical and biological sciences.
Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary
-
Paragraph 1: Establishes the foundational distinction between geographic factors (climate, topography, soil, native plant/animal distributions) and non-geographic factors (culture, history, individual human choices), asserting that human phenomena across the globe are shaped by the interaction of both dimensions.
-
Paragraph 2: Juxtaposes polar case studies along the causal spectrum. At one extreme, modern divergence between North and South Korea illustrates a case where modest environmental differences play negligible roles compared to government policy. At the opposite extreme, the Inuit's fur clothing and complete absence of agriculture versus equatorial societies prove direct geographic causation. In Aboriginal Australia, the complete absence of indigenous farming or pastoralism is demonstrated to be strictly biogeographic: Australia naturally possessed zero domesticable native animals and virtually no domesticable native plants. Modern Australian agriculture relies entirely on imported Eurasian species brought by overseas colonists.
-
Paragraph 3: Highlights an acute intellectual double standard in modern academia: while scholars readily accept cultural, historical, or individual agency explanations without accusing their proponents of "cultural determinism" or "historical determinism," any explanatory framework invoking a geographic role is reflexively branded and dismissed as "geographic determinism."
-
Paragraph 4: Examines the first underlying reason for this bias: 19th-century geographic explanations often incorporated racist theories, leaving a lingering stigma. The author exposes this intellectual inconsistency by pointing out that historical, genetic, psychological, and anthropological explanations from that same era were equally racist, yet scholars today evaluate modern, non-racist versions of those disciplines on their empirical merits.
-
Paragraph 5: Identifies the second underlying reason: historians' disciplinary addiction to "contingency"—the dogma that individual decisions and random historical chance govern events. While valid in some domains, the author illustrates the absurdity of applying contingency to physical adaptations, noting that the Inuit did not adopt warm fur clothing because a persuasive tribal leader arbitrarily decreed it in 1783.
-
Paragraph 6: Identifies the third underlying reason: geographic explanations require mastery of complex technical empirical data from physical geography, botany, ecology, and climatology—domains entirely absent from the professional graduate training of most historians and economists.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Academic, Analytical, Critical, Evaluative, and Rigorous.
-
Author's Perspective: The author champions a balanced, multi-causal approach to historiography and human anthropology. While fully respecting the influence of political systems, human choices, and culture, the author vigorously defends physical and biological geography against disciplinary chauvinism, exposing the cognitive biases, training deficiencies, and logical fallacies that lead contemporary non-geographers to dismiss geographic causation.
Other questions in this set
- Q1. All of the following can be inferred from the passage EXCEPT:
- Q2. The author criticises scholars who are not geographers for all of the following reasons EXCEPT:
- Q4. The examples of the Inuit and Aboriginal Australians are offered in the passage to show
Culture questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q2
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q3
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q4
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q5
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q16
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc