CAT 2022 Slot 2 VARC Q11

  • Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
  • Reading Comprehension › Culture
  • Hard
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2022_SLOT2_VARC_Q11

Passage · questions 9–12

Humans today make music. Think beyond all the qualifications that might trail after this bald statement: that only certain humans make music, that extensive training is involved, that many societies distinguish musical specialists from nonmusicians, that in today's societies most listen to music rather than making it, and so forth. These qualifications, whatever their local merit, are moot in the face of the overarching truth that making music, considered from a cognitive and psychological vantage, is the province of all those who perceive and experience what is made. We are, almost all of us, musicians – everyone who can entrain (not necessarily dance) to a beat, who can recognize a repeated tune (not necessarily sing it), who can distinguish one instrument or one singing voice from another. I will often use an antique word, recently revived, to name this broader musical experience. Humans are musicking creatures.

The set of capacities that enables musicking is a principal marker of modern humanity. There is nothing polemical in this assertion except a certain insistence, which will figure often in what follows, that musicking be included in our thinking about fundamental human commonalities. Capacities involved in musicking are many and take shape in complicated ways, arising from innate dispositions. Most of these capacities overlap with nonmusical ones, though a few may be distinct and dedicated to musical perception and production. In the area of overlap, linguistic capacities seem to be particularly important, and humans are (in principle) language- makers in addition to music-makers – speaking creatures as well as musicking ones.

Humans are symbol-makers too, a feature tightly bound up with language, not so tightly with music. The species Cassirer dubbed Homo symbolicus cannot help but tangle musicking in webs of symbolic thought and expression, habitually making it a component of behavioral complexes that form such expression. But in fundamental features musicking is neither language- like nor symbol-like, and from these differences come many clues to its ancient emergence.

If musicking is a primary, shared trait of modern humans, then to describe its emergence must be to detail the coalescing of that modernity. This took place, archaeologists are clear, over a very long durée: at least 50,000 years or so, more likely something closer to 200,000, depending in part on what that coalescence is taken to comprise. If we look back 20,000 years, a small portion of this long period, we reach the lives of humans whose musical capacities were probably little different from our own. As we look farther back we reach horizons where this similarity can no longer hold – perhaps 40,000 years ago, perhaps 70,000, perhaps 100,000. But we never cross a line before which all the cognitive capacities recruited in modern musicking abruptly disappear. Unless we embrace the incredible notion that music sprang forth in full-blown glory, its emergence will have to be tracked in gradualist terms across a long period.

This is one general feature of a history of music's emergence. The history was at once sociocultural and biological. The capacities recruited in musicking are many, so describing its emergence involves following several or many separate strands.

Question 11

Which one of the following statements, if true, would weaken the author's claim that humans are musicking creatures?

  1. A

    Musical capacities are primarily socio-cultural, which explains the wide diversity of musical forms.

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    As musicking is neither language-like nor symbol-like, it is a much older form of expression.

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    Nonmusical capacities are of far greater consequence to human survival than the capacity for music.

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    From a cognitive and psychological vantage, musicking arises from unconscious dispositions, not conscious ones.

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (A)

Musical capacities are primarily socio-cultural, which explains the wide diversity of musical forms.

Solution

🎯 Question Analysis & Solution

  • Question Type: Critical Reasoning / Weaken the Argument

  • Passage Reference:

Paragraph 1: "...making music, considered from a cognitive and psychological vantage, is the province of all those who perceive and experience what is made. We are, almost all of us, musicians... Humans are musicking creatures."

Paragraph 2: "The set of capacities that enables musicking is a principal marker of modern humanity... that musicking be included in our thinking about fundamental human commonalities. Capacities involved in musicking are many and take shape in complicated ways, arising from innate dispositions."

Paragraph 5: "The history was at once sociocultural and biological."

Logical Deduction

To weaken the author's central claim that "humans are musicking creatures," an option must challenge the foundational premise supporting this claim:

  1. The author's thesis that all humans are inherently "musicking creatures" relies on the cognitive and biological premise that musicking arises from innate dispositions shared universally across the human species as a fundamental marker of modern humanity.

  2. The author specifically dismisses the view that musicking is merely an elite, learned, cultural specialization (declaring such qualifications "moot").

  3. If Option 1 is true—that musical capacities are primarily socio-cultural—then musicality is not an innate, universal biological/cognitive endowment of the human species, but an acquired, contingent cultural phenomenon that varies from society to society. This would validate the very qualifications the author rejected in Paragraph 1 (e.g., that only certain trained individuals make music), directly striking at the root of the claim that humans as a biological species are innately "musicking creatures."

Correct Answer: Option 1

  • By attributing musical capacities primarily to socio-cultural conditioning rather than innate biological/cognitive dispositions, Option 1 dismantles the universal foundation required to claim that humans as a species are inherently "musicking creatures."

Option Elimination

  • Option 2 (Strengthens / Consistent with Passage): Suggesting that musicking is a much older form of expression because it is non-linguistic and non-symbolic reinforces the author's gradualist timeline of deep, ancient evolutionary emergence across 200,000 years.

  • Option 3 (Irrelevant Comparison / Out of Scope): The relative survival utility of nonmusical versus musical capacities does not negate the universal presence of musical capacities. The author never claims music is the most critical survival faculty, merely that it is an innate commonality.

  • Option 4 (Irrelevant Distinction / Consistent with Passage): Cognitive capacities arising from innate dispositions (e.g., beat entrainment, tonal recognition) frequently operate at pre-conscious or automatic cognitive levels; asserting they are unconscious does not diminish their status as universal human endowments.

Detailed explanation

📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure

Central Theme

The evolutionary, cognitive, and biocultural emergence of human musicality ("musicking") as a foundational trait defining modern humanity. The author argues that music-making is not an elite specialization reserved for trained performers, but an innate cognitive endowment shared by virtually all humans who perceive and cognitively process musical forms. Musicking coalesced alongside modern human capacities over an evolutionary longue durée (50,000 to 200,000 years) through a gradualist, multifaceted biocultural process that overlaps significantly with linguistic faculties while retaining distinct non-symbolic, non-linguistic primitives.

Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary

  • Paragraph 1: Reframes music-making by discarding conventional qualifications (elite training, professional specialization, active performance vs. passive listening). Evaluated from a cognitive and psychological vantage point, music-making encompasses anyone who perceives, entrains to a beat, recognizes tunes, or distinguishes instruments/voices. Revives Christopher Small's antique term "musicking" to establish that humans are inherently "musicking creatures."

  • Paragraph 2: Posits that the cognitive capacities enabling musicking constitute a principal marker of modern humanity and a fundamental human commonality. These capacities arise from innate dispositions, primarily overlapping with nonmusical domains—most critically linguistic capacities—demonstrating that humans are language-makers and music-makers in tandem.

  • Paragraph 3: Distinguishes musicking from symbol-making. While humans (Homo symbolicus, Ernst Cassirer) naturally entangle musicking within complex webs of symbolic culture and behavioral expression, musicking in its primitive, fundamental mechanisms is neither language-like nor symbol-like. These essential differences offer vital clues to its deep evolutionary origins.

  • Paragraph 4: Traces the evolutionary timeline of musicking, asserting that detailing its emergence mirrors detailing the coalescence of modern humanity. This unfolded over a very long durée (50,000 to 200,000 years). Reaching back 20,000 years reveals capacities virtually identical to modern humans; pushing further back (40,000 to 100,000 years) shows divergence, yet without an abrupt vanishing point. The author explicitly rejects catastrophic emergence ("music sprang forth in full-blown glory") in favor of a gradualist evolutionary model.

  • Paragraph 5: Synthesizes the dual biocultural character of music's emergence. Tracking its history demands unraveling interconnected sociocultural and biological strands rather than seeking a singular evolutionary catalyst.

Tone and Author's Perspective

  • Tone: Academic, Analytical, Evolutionary, and Persuasive.

  • Author's Perspective: Biocultural and cognitive. The author democratizes the ontology of music (equating cognitive perception with musicality) and advocates a nuanced, gradualist evolutionary framework linking music to the dawn of modern human cognition.

Other questions in this set

  1. Q9. Which one of the following sets of terms best serves as keywords to the passage?
  2. Q10. Based on the passage, which one of the following statements is a valid argument about the emergence of music/musicking?
  3. Q12. "Think beyond all the qualifications that might trail after this bald statement " In the context of the passage, what…

Culture questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q2
    The goal of the author over the course of this passage is to:
  2. CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q3
    What relation does the “communication problem” mentioned in paragraph 2 have to the questions that the…
  3. CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q4
    From the context in which it is placed, the phrase “sui generis” in paragraph 3 suggests which one of the…
  4. CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q5
    The mention of Stravinsky’s description of music in the first paragraph does all the following EXCEPT:
  5. CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q16
    All of the following, if true, would weaken the passage’s claims about the hallucinatory tribal imagination…

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc