CAT 2022 Slot 2 VARC Q6
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension › Culture
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2022_SLOT2_VARC_Q06
Passage · questions 5–8
When we teach engineering problems now, we ask students to come to a single "best" solution defined by technical ideals like low cost, speed to build, and ability to scale. This way of teaching primes students to believe that their decision-making is purely objective, as it is grounded in math and science. This is known as technical-social dualism, the idea that the technical and social dimensions of engineering problems are readily separable and remain distinct throughout the problem-definition and solution process.
Nontechnical parameters such as access to a technology, cultural relevancy or potential harms are deemed political and invalid in this way of learning. But those technical ideals are at their core social and political choices determined by a dominant culture focused on economic growth for the most privileged segments of society. By choosing to downplay public welfare as a critical parameter for engineering design, we risk creating a culture of disengagement from societal concerns amongst engineers that is antithetical to the ethical code of engineering.
In my field of medical devices, ignoring social dimensions has real consequences. Most FDA-approved drugs are incorrectly dosed for people assigned female at birth, leading to unexpected adverse reactions. This is because they have been inadequately represented in clinical trials.
Beyond physical failings, subjective beliefs treated as facts by those in decision-making roles can encode social inequities. For example, spirometers, routinely used devices that measure lung capacity, still have correction factors that automatically assume smaller lung capacity in Black and Asian individuals. These racially based adjustments are derived from research done by eugenicists who thought these racial differences were biologically determined and who considered nonwhite people as inferior. These machines ignore the influence of social and environmental factors on lung capacity.
Many technologies for systemically marginalized people have not been built because they were not deemed important such as better early diagnostics and treatment for diseases like endometriosis, a disease that afflicts 10 percent of people with uteruses. And we hardly question whether devices are built sustainably, which has led to a crisis of medical waste and health care accounting for 10 percent of U.S. greenhouse gas emissions.
Social justice must be made core to the way engineers are trained. Some universities are working on this. Engineers taught this way will be prepared to think critically about what problems we choose to solve, how we do so responsibly and how we build teams that challenge our ways of thinking.
Individual engineering professors are also working to embed societal needs in their pedagogy. Darshan Karwat at the University of Arizona developed activist engineering to challenge engineers to acknowledge their full moral and social responsibility through practical self- reflection. Khalid Kadir at the University of California, Berkeley, created the popular course Engineering, Environment, and Society that teaches engineers how to engage in place-based knowledge, an understanding of the people, context and history, to design better technical approaches in collaboration with communities. When we design and build with equity and justice in mind, we craft better solutions that respond to the complexities of entrenched systemic problems.
Question 6
The author gives all of the following reasons for why marginalised people are systematically discriminated against in technology-related interventions EXCEPT
Show answer and solution
Answer: (C)
"And we hardly question whether devices are built sustainably, which has led to a crisis of medical waste and health care accounting for 10 percent of U.S. greenhouse gas emissions."
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Negative Detail / Categorical Exception (EXCEPT Question)
-
Passage Reference:
"But those technical ideals are at their core social and political choices determined by a dominant culture focused on economic growth for the most privileged segments of society."
"Beyond physical failings, subjective beliefs treated as facts by those in decision-making roles can encode social inequities."
"These racially based adjustments are derived from research done by eugenicists who thought these racial differences were biologically determined and who considered nonwhite people as inferior."
"And we hardly question whether devices are built sustainably, which has led to a crisis of medical waste and health care accounting for 10 percent of U.S. greenhouse gas emissions."
Logical Deduction
The question asks to identify the statement that does NOT serve as an explanatory reason for why marginalized populations face systematic discrimination in technological interventions:
-
Option 1: Explains that technical ideals reflect choices made by a dominant culture oriented toward the economic interests of privileged segments, thereby directly explaining why non-privileged, marginalized groups are marginalized. (Valid reason -> Eliminated).
-
Option 2: Explains that subjective biases held by decision-makers are treated as objective facts, directly causing engineering systems to encode social inequities. (Valid reason -> Eliminated).
-
Option 4: Explains that racial correction factors in diagnostic devices (spirometers) derive from racist eugenicist theories that classified nonwhite individuals as inferior, directly explaining technological discrimination against racial minorities. (Valid reason -> Eliminated).
-
Option 3: Discusses environmental sustainability, medical waste, and the healthcare sector's contribution to US greenhouse gas emissions. While this identifies a critical negative consequence of ignoring broader responsibilities, it concerns ecological degradation and environmental sustainability, NOT the systematic discrimination experienced by marginalized human populations. Therefore, Option 3 is the correct exception.
Correct Answer: Option 3
- This excerpt highlights environmental sustainability and medical waste/greenhouse gas emissions rather than providing an explanatory reason for systematic discrimination against marginalized people.
Option Elimination
-
Option 1 (Textually Substantiated Reason / Contrary to Question Stem): Directly explains how technological priorities are dictated by the dominant culture to serve the privileged at the expense of marginalized communities; being a valid reason for discrimination, it is eliminated.
-
Option 2 (Textually Substantiated Reason / Contrary to Question Stem): Directly explains the mechanism through which decision-makers' unexamined subjective beliefs encode social inequities into technical systems; being a valid reason, it is eliminated.
-
Option 3 (Category Mistake / Topical Misattribution): Conflates environmental and ecological critiques with social discrimination; medical waste and greenhouse emissions do not explain systemic discrimination against marginalized groups.
-
Option 4 (Textually Substantiated Reason / Contrary to Question Stem): Directly identifies historical eugenicist ideology as the root cause of racially biased diagnostic algorithms in medical devices like spirometers; being a valid reason, it is eliminated.
Detailed explanation
📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure
Central Theme
A critique of contemporary engineering education grounded in "technical-social dualism"—the flawed doctrine that technical problem-solving (focused on low cost, build speed, and scalability) is purely objective and completely distinct from societal contexts. The author demonstrates how this artificial bifurcation encodes systemic inequities, causes physical harm (particularly in medicine and healthcare devices), and neglects marginalized communities, arguing for a reformed pedagogy centered on social justice, place-based knowledge, and community collaboration.
Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary
-
Paragraph 1: Defines "technical-social dualism" in current engineering pedagogy: students are trained to optimize for single "best" technical metrics (low cost, speed, scalability) under the illusion that mathematical and scientific foundations make their decisions purely objective and value-neutral.
-
Paragraph 2: Critiques the political foundations of technical ideals. Nontechnical parameters (technology access, cultural relevance, potential harms) are dismissed as "political" and invalid, yet technical ideals themselves reflect political choices favoring economic growth for privileged elites. Warns that marginalizing public welfare breeds professional disengagement, violating engineering ethics.
-
Paragraph 3: Demonstrates tangible harms in medical devices and pharmaceuticals: FDA-approved medications are improperly dosed for people assigned female at birth due to systematic underrepresentation in clinical trials.
-
Paragraph 4: Explores how subjective biases masquerading as objective facts encode racial disparities into medical technology. For instance, diagnostic spirometers incorporate race-based correction factors rooted in 19th-century eugenics, ignoring environmental and socioeconomic drivers of lung health.
-
Paragraph 5: Highlights systemic neglect and ecological failure: technologies addressing marginalized conditions (such as endometriosis, affecting 10% of people with uteruses) remain underdeveloped, while unexamined manufacturing practices generate massive medical waste and contribute to 10% of US greenhouse gas emissions.
-
Paragraph 6: Advocates integrating social justice into core engineering training to cultivate critical reflection regarding problem selection, ethical responsibility, and cognitive diversity in engineering teams.
-
Paragraph 7: Showcases pedagogical pioneers reforming engineering education: Darshan Karwat's "activist engineering" (moral and social self-reflection) and Khalid Kadir's "Engineering, Environment, and Society" (place-based knowledge and community collaboration), concluding that equity-centered design yields superior solutions for entrenched systemic issues.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Academic, Critical, Persuasive, Normative, and Reformist.
-
Author's Perspective: An insider practitioner (medical device engineer and educator) arguing passionately against the artificial divide between technical execution and social justice, urging engineering institutions to center public welfare, equity, and environmental ethics.
Other questions in this set
- Q5. In this passage, the author is making the claim that:
- Q7. All of the following are examples of the negative outcomes of focusing on technical ideals in the medical sphere…
- Q8. We can infer that the author would approve of a more evolved engineering pedagogy that includes all of the following…
Culture questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q2
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q3
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q4
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q5
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q16
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc