CAT 2022 Slot 1 VARC Q14
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension › Culture
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2022_SLOT1_VARC_Q14
Passage · questions 13–16
The Chinese have two different concepts of a copy. Fangzhipin are imitations where the difference from the original is obvious. These are small models or copies that can be purchased in a museum shop, for example. The second concept for a copy is fuzhipin. They are exact reproductions of the original, which, for the Chinese, are of equal value to the original. It has absolutely no negative connotations. The discrepancy with regard to the understanding of what a copy is has often led to misunderstandings and arguments between China and Western museums. The Chinese often send copies abroad instead of originals, in the firm belief that they are not essentially different from the originals. The rejection that then comes from the Western museums is perceived by the Chinese as an insult.
The Far Eastern notion of identity is also very confusing to the Western observer. The Ise Grand Shrine in Japan is 1,300 years old for the millions of Japanese people who go there on pilgrimage every year. But in reality this temple complex is completely rebuilt from scratch every 20 years.
The cathedral of Freiburg Minster in southwest Germany is covered in scaffolding almost all year round. The sandstone from which it is built is a very soft, porous material that does not withstand natural erosion by rain and wind. After a while, it crumbles. As a result, the cathedral is continually being examined for damage, and eroded stones are replaced. And in the cathedral's dedicated workshop, copies of the damaged sandstone figures are constantly being produced. Of course, attempts are made to preserve the stones from the Middle Ages for as long as possible. But at some point they, too, are removed and replaced with new stones.
Fundamentally, this is the same operation as with the Japanese shrine, except in this case the production of a replica takes place very slowly and over long periods of time. In the field of art as well, the idea of an unassailable original developed historically in the Western world. Back in the 17th century in the West, excavated artworks from antiquity were treated quite differently from today. They were not restored in a way that was faithful to the original. Instead, there was massive intervention in these works, changing their appearance.
It is probably this intellectual position that explains why Asians have far fewer scruples about cloning than Europeans. The South Korean cloning researcher Hwang Woo-suk, who attracted worldwide attention with his cloning experiments in 2004, is a Buddhist. He found a great deal of support and followers among Buddhists, while Christians called for a ban on human cloning. Hwang legitimised his cloning experiments with his religious affiliation: 'I am Buddhist, and I have no philosophical problem with cloning. And as you know, the basis of Buddhism is that life is recycled through reincarnation. In some ways, I think, therapeutic cloning restarts the circle of life.'
Question 14
The value that the modern West assigns to "an unassailable original" has resulted in all of the following EXCEPT:
Show answer and solution
Answer: (D)
it discourages them from carrying out human cloning
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Direct Factual / Negative Identification (EXCEPT)
-
Passage Reference:
"The discrepancy with regard to the understanding of what a copy is has often led to misunderstandings and arguments between China and Western museums... The rejection that then comes from the Western museums is perceived by the Chinese as an insult." (Paragraph 1)
"And in the cathedral's dedicated workshop, copies of the damaged sandstone figures are constantly being produced." (Paragraph 3)
"In the field of art as well, the idea of an unassailable original developed historically in the Western world. Back in the 17th century in the West... They were not restored in a way that was faithful to the original. Instead, there was massive intervention..." (Paragraph 4)
"He found a great deal of support and followers among Buddhists, while Christians called for a ban on human cloning. Hwang legitimised his cloning experiments with his religious affiliation: 'I am Buddhist, and I have no philosophical problem with cloning...'" (Paragraph 5)
Logical Deduction
The question asks which outcome has NOT resulted from the modern Western valuation of an "unassailable original":
-
In the art world, the modern Western sanctity of the original discourages exhibiting copies alongside originals (Option 1) and prevents intrusive modifications to ancient art (Option 2).
-
In architectural preservation, maintaining fidelity to original stone figures at Freiburg Minster ensures sustained, continuous employment for specialized masons copying damaged statues (Option 3).
-
In bioethics (Paragraph 5), European opposition to cloning is explicitly linked to Christian theology and religious doctrine, rather than the secular art-historical aesthetic standard of an "unassailable original." Connecting opposition to human cloning directly to the art-historical value of an unassailable original commits a causal fallacy. Thus, Option 4 is the exception.
Correct Answer: Option 4
- Option 4 is the correct exception because Paragraph 5 explicitly grounds European opposition to human cloning in Christian religious and theological objections, rather than the art-historical construct of an "unassailable original."
Option Elimination
-
Option 1 (Textually Valid Consequence): Directly follows from the Western museum philosophy in Paragraph 1, where copies lack the unassailable authenticity of originals and are rejected from exhibition.
-
Option 2 (Textually Valid Consequence): Directly follows from Paragraph 4, where the emergence of the unassailable original led modern restorers to abandon the massive aesthetic interventions practiced in the 17th century.
-
Option 3 (Textually Valid Consequence): Directly follows from Paragraph 3, which notes that dedicated workshops continually employ craftsmen to produce sandstone replicas of medieval figures.
Detailed explanation
📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure
Central Theme
A comparative cross-cultural inquiry into the ontology of authenticity, copies, and identity between Eastern (specifically Chinese and Japanese) and Western traditions. The passage explores how cultural divergence—from Chinese concepts of reproduction (fangzhipin vs. fuzhipin) and the Shinto cyclic reconstruction of the Ise Shrine to the Western architectural conservation of Freiburg Minster and the historical emergence of the "unassailable original"—shapes divergent metaphysical worldviews, which ultimately extend to contemporary bioethical stances on human cloning.
Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary
-
Paragraph 1: Introduces the dual Chinese taxonomy of copies: fangzhipin (obvious imitations/models sold in gift shops) versus fuzhipin (exact reproductions carrying zero negative stigma and possessing identical ontological and aesthetic value to the original). Contrasts this with the Western veneration of original artifacts, explaining how cultural friction arises when Chinese museums lend fuzhipin to Western institutions, perceiving Western rejection as an insult.
-
Paragraph 2: Illustrates the Far Eastern concept of identity through the Ise Grand Shrine in Japan. To millions of pilgrims, the shrine is 1,300 years old, yet the physical wooden complex is cyclically dismantled and rebuilt from scratch every 20 years, demonstrating that identity resides in continuous form and ritual rather than original material substance.
-
Paragraph 3: Introduces the Western architectural counterpart: the Freiburg Minster cathedral in Germany. Built from soft, porous sandstone that constantly erodes, its damaged medieval stones and figures are continually copied in dedicated masonry workshops and replaced. Although medieval stones are preserved as long as possible, they are eventually substituted with new replicas.
-
Paragraph 4: Synthesizes the comparison between the Ise Shrine and Freiburg Minster, noting that both involve replacing physical matter with replicas—the shrine in rapid 20-year cycles and the cathedral slowly over centuries. Observes that the modern Western fixation on an "unassailable original" is a historically contingent development; in the 17th century, Western restorers radically altered ancient artworks rather than remaining faithful to original intent.
-
Paragraph 5: Extends this philosophical divergence to modern bioethics and cloning. Explains that the Eastern acceptance of replicated forms and cyclical regeneration informs why Asians have far fewer moral scruples regarding cloning than Europeans. Highlights South Korean researcher Hwang Woo-suk, whose therapeutic cloning experiments were supported by Buddhists via the lens of reincarnation and the cyclical renewal of life, whereas Christians demanded a total ban.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Academic, Philosophical, Comparative, and Culturally Analytical.
-
Author's Perspective: The author maintains an objective, intercultural perspective, elucidating how deeply ingrained philosophical traditions regarding material continuity, reproduction, and reincarnation govern seemingly unrelated domains—from museum curation and architectural heritage to biomedical technology.
Other questions in this set
- Q13. Which one of the following scenarios is unlikely to follow from the arguments in the passage?
- Q15. Based on the passage, which one of the following copies would a Chinese museum be unlikely to consider as having less…
- Q16. Which one of the following statements does not correctly express the similarity between the Ise Grand Shrine and the…
Culture questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q2
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q3
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q4
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q5
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q16
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc