CAT 2022 Slot 1 VARC Q7
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension › Philosophy
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2022_SLOT1_VARC_Q07
Passage · questions 5–8
Stoicism was founded in 300 BC by the Greek philosopher Zeno and survived into the Roman era until about AD 300. According to the Stoics, emotions consist of two movements. The first movement is the immediate feeling and other reactions (e.g., physiological response) that occur when a stimulus or event occurs. For instance, consider what could have happened if an army general accused Marcus Aurelius of treason in front of other officers. The first movement for Marcus may have been (internal) surprise and anger in response to this insult, accompanied perhaps by some involuntary physiological and expressive responses such as face flushing and a movement of the eyebrows. The second movement is what one does next about the emotion. Second movement behaviors occur after thinking and are under one's control. Examples of second movements for Marcus might have included a plot to seek revenge, actions signifying deference and appeasement, or perhaps proceeding as he would have proceeded whether or not this event occurred: continuing to lead the Romans in a way that Marcus Aurelius believed best benefited them. In the Stoic view, choosing a reasoned, unemotional response as the second movement is the only appropriate response.
The Stoics believed that to live the good life and be a good person, we need to free ourselves of nearly all desires such as too much desire for money, power, or sexual gratification. Prior to second movements, we can consider what is important in life. Money, power, and excessive sexual gratification are not important. Character, rationality, and kindness are important. The Epicureans, first associated with the Greek philosopher Epicurus, held a similar view, believing that people should enjoy simple pleasures, such as good conversation, friendship, food, and wine, but not be indulgent in these pursuits and not follow passion for those things that hold no real value like power and money. As Oatley (2004) states, "the Epicureans articulated a view-enjoyment of relationship with friends, of things that are real rather than illusory, simple rather than artificially inflated, possible rather than vanishingly unlikely that is certainly relevant today". In sum, these ancient Greek and Roman philosophers saw emotions, especially strong ones, as potentially dangerous. They viewed emotions as experiences that needed to be reined in and controlled.
As Oatley (2004) points out, the Stoic idea bears some similarity to Buddhism. Buddha, living in India in the 6th century BC, argued for cultivating a certain attitude that decreases the probability of (in Stoic terms) destructive second movements. Through meditation and the right attitude, one allows emotions to happen to oneself (it is impossible to prevent this), but one is advised to observe the emotions without necessarily acting on them; one achieves some distance and decides what has value and what does not have value. Additionally, the Stoic idea of developing virtue in oneself, of becoming a good person, which the Stoics believed we could do because we have a touch of the divine, laid the foundation for the three monotheistic religions: Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. As with Stoicism, tenets of these religions include controlling our emotions lest we engage in sinful behavior.
Question 7
"Through meditation and the right attitude, one allows emotions to happen to oneself (it is impossible to prevent this), but one is advised to observe the emotions without necessarily acting on them; one achieves some distance and decides what has value and what does not have value." In the context of the passage, which one of the following is not a possible implication of the quoted statement?
Show answer and solution
Answer: (D)
D) Meditation allows certain out-of-body experiences that permit us to gain the distance necessary to control our emotions.
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Negative Inference / Conceptual Implication (Except)
-
Passage Reference:
""Through meditation and the right attitude, one allows emotions to happen to oneself (it is impossible to prevent this), but one is advised to observe the emotions without necessarily acting on them; one achieves some distance and decides what has value and what does not have value.""
"According to the Stoics, emotions consist of two movements. The first movement is the immediate feeling and other reactions... The second movement is what one does next about the emotion. Second movement behaviors occur after thinking and are under one's control."
Logical Deduction
The question asks to identify which option is NOT a legitimate implication of the quoted excerpt on Buddhist mindfulness and emotional regulation.
In the excerpt, achieving "some distance" is a psychological and cognitive metaphor for cultivating objective, mindful detachment—stepping back mentally from involuntary feelings (first movements) before deciding how to respond (second movements). Option 4 (D) interprets this figurative mental distance with absurd literalness, claiming that meditation induces "out-of-body experiences" (astral projection or parapsychological disembodiment). This represents a gross factual distortion and pseudo-scientific literalization that finds zero support in the passage.
Correct Answer: Option 4
- Falsely and absurdly literalizes the psychological metaphor of gaining cognitive "distance" as supernatural or physical "out-of-body experiences," which is entirely alien to the passage.
Option Elimination
-
Option 1 (A) ([Valid Implication / Scope Match]): Valid implication; by acknowledging that "one allows emotions to happen to oneself" because "it is impossible to prevent this," the passage indicates that at the initial threshold of experience, consciousness must adopt a receptive, non-resistant posture toward involuntary first movements.
-
Option 2 (B) ([Valid Implication / Structural Correspondence]): Valid implication; observing emotions and consciously deciding what has value before acting corresponds directly to the deliberative, controlled cognitive processing of the "second movement" defined in paragraph 1.
-
Option 3 (C) ([Valid Implication / Logical Premise]): Valid implication; the statement that one must gain distance in order to "decide what has value and what does not have value" necessarily implies that raw, unmediated emotional reactivity impedes rational discrimination between valuable and valueless experiences.
Detailed explanation
📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure
Central Theme
A comparative philosophical inquiry into the nature, taxonomy, and regulation of human emotions. The passage contrasts the two-stage emotional model of Stoicism (involuntary first-movement physiological impulses versus controllable second-movement cognitive responses) with Epicurean temperance, Buddhist mindfulness, and monotheistic morality, exploring how ancient philosophies converge on the necessity of reining in destructive emotions to achieve virtue and well-being.
Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary
-
Paragraph 1: Details the historical lineage and psychological model of Stoicism (founded ~300 BC by Zeno), which divides emotion into two movements: an immediate, involuntary physiological reaction (first movement) and a subsequent, deliberate cognitive choice (second movement); uses the hypothetical example of Marcus Aurelius responding to a treason accusation to illustrate that only a reasoned, unemotional second movement is appropriate.
-
Paragraph 2: Outlines the Stoic ethical imperative to eliminate destructive desires (money, power, excessive sex) in favor of virtue (character, rationality, kindness), drawing parallels with Epicurean philosophy, which advocated enjoying simple, natural pleasures (friendship, conversation, food) without indulgence, while both traditions concurred that strong passions are hazardous and must be governed.
-
Paragraph 3: Synthesizes the Stoic framework with Eastern and religious traditions via Keith Oatley (2004); connects Stoic second movements to Buddhist mindfulness (which permits involuntary first movements through meditation but prevents destructive reactions by cultivating non-judgmental detachment) and traces how Stoic concepts of divine inner virtue influenced emotional self-control in Judaism, Christianity, and Islam to prevent sinful conduct.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Academic, expository, comparative, and pedagogical.
-
Author's Perspective: The author adopts an informative, interdisciplinary perspective, highlighting universal themes of emotional regulation across Western classical philosophy, Eastern contemplative practices, and major world religions without asserting ideological dogmatism.
Other questions in this set
- Q5. On the basis of the passage, which one of the following statements can be regarded as true?
- Q6. Which one of the following statements would be an accurate inference from the example of Marcus Aurelius?
- Q8. Which one of the following statements, if false, could be seen as contradicting the facts/arguments in the passage?
Philosophy questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q11
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q12
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q13
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q14
- CAT 2023 Slot 2 VARC Q1
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc