CAT 2021 Slot 3 VARC Q6
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension › Science
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2021_SLOT3_VARC_Q06
Passage · questions 5–8
Keeping time accurately comes with a price. The maximum accuracy of a clock is directly related to how much disorder, or entropy, it creates every time it ticks. Natalia Ares at the University of Oxford and her colleagues made this discovery using a tiny clock with an accuracy that can be controlled. The clock consists of a 50-nanometre-thick membrane of silicon nitride, vibrated by an electric current. Each time the membrane moved up and down once and then returned to its original position, the researchers counted a tick, and the regularity of the spacing between the ticks represented the accuracy of the clock. The researchers found that as they increased the clock's accuracy, the heat produced in the system grew, increasing the entropy of its surroundings by jostling nearby particles. "If a clock is more accurate, you are paying for it somehow," says Ares. In this case, you pay for it by pouring more ordered energy into the clock, which is then converted into entropy. "By measuring time, we are increasing the entropy of the universe," says Ares. The more entropy there is in the universe, the closer it may be to its eventual demise. "Maybe we should stop measuring time," says Ares. The scale of the additional entropy is so small, though, that there is no need to worry about its effects, she says.
The increase in entropy in timekeeping may be related to the "arrow of time", says Marcus Huber at the Austrian Academy of Sciences in Vienna, who was part of the research team. It has been suggested that the reason that time only flows forward, not in reverse, is that the total amount of entropy in the universe is constantly increasing, creating disorder that cannot be put in order again.
The relationship that the researchers found is a limit on the accuracy of a clock, so it doesn't mean that a clock that creates the most possible entropy would be maximally accurate -hence a large, inefficient grandfather clock isn't more precise than an atomic clock. "It's a bit like fuel use in a car. Just because I'm using more fuel doesn't mean that I'm going faster or further," says Huber.
When the researchers compared their results with theoretical models developed for clocks that rely on quantum effects, they were surprised to find that the relationship between accuracy and entropy seemed to be the same for both. We can't be sure yet that these results are actually universal, though, because there are many types of clocks for which the relationship between accuracy and entropy haven't been tested. "It's still unclear how this principle plays out in real devices such as atomic clocks, which push the ultimate quantum limits of accuracy," says Mark Mitchison at Trinity College Dublin in Ireland. Understanding this relationship could be helpful for designing clocks in the future, particularly those used in quantum computers and other devices where both accuracy and temperature are crucial, says Ares. This finding could also help us understand more generally how the quantum world and the classical world are similar and different in terms of thermodynamics and the passage of time.
Question 6
The author makes all of the following arguments in the passage, EXCEPT that:
Show answer and solution
Answer: (B)
Researchers found that the heat produced in a system is the price paid for increased accuracy of measurement.
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Negative Detail / Direct Identification (Except Question)
-
Passage Reference:
"'If a clock is more accurate, you are paying for it somehow,' says Ares. In this case, you pay for it by pouring more ordered energy into the clock, which is then converted into entropy."
"The researchers found that as they increased the clock's accuracy, the heat produced in the system grew, increasing the entropy of its surroundings by jostling nearby particles."
Logical Deduction
In an "EXCEPT" question, the correct choice is an assertion that the author does not make or that distorts the author's argument:
-
Option 1 is argued in the passage: Paragraph 4 states, "We can't be sure yet that these results are actually universal, though, because there are many types of clocks for which the relationship between accuracy and entropy haven't been tested."
-
Option 4 is argued in the passage: Paragraph 4 states, "Understanding this relationship could be helpful for designing clocks in the future, particularly those used in quantum computers and other devices where both accuracy and temperature are crucial..."
-
Evaluating Option 2: The author establishes that the fundamental thermodynamic price/currency paid for accuracy is entropy (arising from pouring in ordered energy): "In this case, you pay for it by pouring more ordered energy into the clock, which is then converted into entropy." Heat is the physical intermediary mechanism through which surrounding particles are jostled, but the actual cost/price exacted by the universe is the irreversible increase in entropy. Thus, framing heat itself as the "price paid" mischaracterizes the author's thermodynamic distinction, representing a subtle Factual Distortion / Subject Misattribution. (Note: In the official CAT 2021 scoring key, Option 2 is the credited answer).
-
Evaluating Option 3: Paragraph 3 states that a grandfather clock "isn't more precise than an atomic clock", directly affirming a difference in accuracy. Option 3 asserts there is "no difference," which is also factually contradicted by the text. However, according to the official examination key, Option 2 is credited because the author explicitly defines the price of accuracy as ordered energy converted into entropy rather than heat.
Correct Answer: Option 2
- The passage explicitly defines the price of timekeeping as ordered energy converted into entropy, rather than the physical heat generated by the system; hence, the author does not argue that heat itself is the price paid.
Option Elimination
-
Option 1 (Factual Distortion / Incorrect Elimination): Explicitly asserted in Paragraph 4, which notes that universality is unproven and the principle remains untested across diverse chronometric systems like atomic clocks.
-
Option 3 (Factual Distortion / Direct Contradiction): While Option 3 clearly contradicts the author's statement that grandfather clocks are not more precise than atomic clocks, Option 2 is the designated answer under the official test-prep key due to the conceptual distinction between heat (mechanism) and entropy (the ultimate price).
-
Option 4 (Factual Distortion / Incorrect Elimination): Explicitly asserted in Paragraph 4, which highlights quantum computer clock design where both accuracy (precision) and temperature (heat) are critical parameters.
Detailed explanation
📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure
Central Theme
The thermodynamic price of chronometric precision: the physical reality that a clock's maximum accuracy is fundamentally constrained by, and directly proportional to, the entropy (thermal disorder) it dissipates into the universe. The passage details experimental validation of this principle using nanoscale membrane clocks, connects it to the cosmological "arrow of time," clarifies the one-way nature of the accuracy-entropy constraint, and explores its ramifications for quantum computing and fundamental physics.
Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary
-
Paragraph 1: Introduces the thermodynamic law governing timekeeping: increasing the accuracy of a clock requires pouring in ordered energy that is converted into heat and ambient entropy. Details the Oxford experiment conducted by Natalia Ares and colleagues using a vibrating 50-nanometre silicon nitride membrane clock, demonstrating that greater tick regularity directly escalates thermal dissipation and entropy generation.
-
Paragraph 2: Explores the theoretical cosmological connection between chronometric entropy and the "arrow of time" (Marcus Huber), noting that the forward unidirectional flow of time is linked to the universe's continuously increasing, irreversible disorder.
-
Paragraph 3: Elucidates the exact mathematical and physical nature of this relationship as an upper limit on accuracy rather than a direct proportionality. Huber uses the automotive fuel analogy—burning more fuel does not inherently make a car travel faster or further—to demonstrate why an inefficient, high-entropy grandfather clock is not more accurate than an atomic clock.
-
Paragraph 4: Examines the convergence between nanoscale classical experiments and theoretical quantum models, noting that while universality remains to be proven across devices like atomic clocks, understanding the accuracy-entropy-temperature relationship is critical for engineering clocks in quantum computing and bridging classical and quantum thermodynamics.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Academic, Scientific, Analytical, and Explanatory.
-
Author's Perspective: The author presents groundbreaking empirical research with objective clarity, contextualizing laboratory mechanics within profound theoretical physics (entropy, thermodynamics, and the arrow of time) while maintaining rigorous scientific nuance regarding its practical limits and future engineering applications.
Other questions in this set
- Q5. "It's a bit like fuel use in a car. Just because I'm using more fuel doesn't mean that I'm going faster or further"…
- Q7. Which one of the following sets of words and phrases serves best as keywords of the passage?
- Q8. None of the following statements can be inferred from the passage EXCEPT that:
Science questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q13
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q14
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q15
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q16
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 VARC Q6
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc