CAT 2021 Slot 3 DILR Q20
- Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
- Logical Reasoning › Math Puzzles
- Hard
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2021_SLOT3_DILR_Q20
Data set · questions 17–20
Each of the bottles mentioned in this question contains 50 ml of liquid. The liquid in any bottle can be 100% pure content (P) or can have certain amount of impurity (I). Visually it is not possible to distinguish between P and I. There is a testing device which detects impurity, as long as the percentage of impurity in the content tested is 10% or more.
For example, suppose bottle 1 contains only P, and bottle 2 contains 80% P and 20% I. If content from bottle 1 is tested, it will be found out that it contains only P. If content of bottle 2is tested, the test will reveal that it contains some amount of I. If 10 ml of content from bottle 1is mixed with 20 ml content from bottle 2, the test will show that the mixture has impurity, and hence we can conclude that at least one of the two bottles has I. However, if 10 ml of content from bottle 1 is mixed with 5 ml of content from bottle 2. the test will not detect any impurity in the resultant mixture.
Question 20
There are four bottles. It is known that either one or two of these bottles contain(s)only P, while the remaining ones contain 85% P and 15% I. What is the minimum number of tests required to ascertain the exact number of bottles containing only P?
Show answer and solution
Answer: (B)
1
Solution
Concept: Mixture Concentration, Detection Thresholds & Group Testing Logic
Master State Table
| Parameter / Rule | Passage Invariant | Mathematical Expression | Analytical Implication |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bottle Capacity | Uniform 50 ml per bottle | Total liquid in each full bottle is 50 ml | |
| Composition | Pure liquid () and Impurity () | () | Homogeneous; sample retains parent concentration |
| Concentration | Proportion of in bottle | ; Pure bottle has | |
| Mixture Rule | Pooled sample volumes | Weighted average concentration of mixture | |
| Positive Test | Device detects impurity | Confirms presence of in tested sample | |
| Negative Test | Device detects no impurity | Impurity absent () or diluted below |
Question Deduction
• Formulating Hypotheses and Objective:
• Four bottles total, with two mutually exclusive scenarios:
• **Case 1**: Exactly 1 bottle has only $P$ ($0\% I$); remaining 3 have $15\% I$.
• **Case 2**: Exactly 2 bottles have only $P$ ($0\% I$); remaining 2 have $15\% I$.
• Objective: Determine whether Case 1 or Case 2 holds. Visual inspection is impossible, so .
• Equal-Volume Pooling Analysis:
• Pool from all four bottles ():
• Under Case 1 (1 pure, 3 impure):
• Impurity volume: $I_{\text{mix}} = 3 \times (10\text{ ml} \times 15\%) = 4.5\text{ ml}$.
• Concentration: $C_{\text{mix}} = \frac{4.5\text{ ml}}{40\text{ ml}} = 11.25\% \ge 10\%$ (detected).
• Under Case 2 (2 pure, 2 impure):
• Impurity volume: $I_{\text{mix}} = 2 \times (10\text{ ml} \times 15\%) = 3.0\text{ ml}$.
• Concentration: $C_{\text{mix}} = \frac{3.0\text{ ml}}{40\text{ ml}} = 7.5\% < 10\%$ (not detected).
• Decisive Single-Test Separation:
• The detection threshold strictly separates the two outcomes ().
• Positive result () proves Case 1; negative result () proves Case 2.
• Exactly 1 test is necessary and sufficient.
• Option Matching:
• Option 1 is "2", Option 2 is "1", Option 3 is "3", Option 4 is "4".
• The minimum number of tests is 1, corresponding to Option 2.
• Matches Option 2 (1).
Topper Take
• Pooling equal volumes from all 4 bottles gives impurity for 1 pure bottle and for 2 pure bottles.
• Because sits directly between and , 1 test decisively differentiates the two cases. Matches Option 2 (value: 1).
Other questions in this set
- Q17. 5 ml of content from bottle A is mixed with 5 ml of content from bottle B. The resultant mixture, when tested, detects…
- Q18. There are four bottles. Each bottle is known to contain only P or only I. They will be considered to be “collectively…
- Q19. There are four bottles. It is known that three of these bottles contain only P, while the remaining one contains 80% P…
Math Puzzles questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q9
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q10
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q11
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q12
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q13
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc