CAT 2021 Slot 2 VARC Q15
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension › Philosophy
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2021_SLOT2_VARC_Q15
Passage · questions 13–16
Many people believe that truth conveys power. Hence sticking with the truth is the best strategy for gaining power. Unfortunately, this is just a comforting myth. In fact, truth and power have a far more complicated relationship, because in human society, power means two very different things.
On the one hand, power mehaving the ability to manipulate objective realities: to hunt animals, to construct bridges, to cure diseases, to build atom bombs. This kind of power is closely tied to truth. If you believe a false physical theory, you won't be able to build an atom bomb. On the other hand, power also mehaving the ability to manipulate human beliefs, thereby getting lots of people to cooperate effectively. Building atom bombs requires not just a good understanding of physics, but also the coordinated labor of millions of humans. Planet Earth was conquered by Homo sapiens rather than by chimpanzees or elephants, because we are the only mammals that can cooperate in very large numbers. And large-scale cooperation depends on believing common stories. But these stories need not be true. You can unite millions of people by making them believe in completely fictional stories about God, about race or about economics. The dual nature of power and truth results in the curious fact that we humknow many more truths than any other animal, but we also believe in much more nonsense.
When it comes to uniting people around a common story, fiction actually enjoys three inherent advantages over the truth. First, whereas the truth is universal, fictions tend to be local. Consequently if we want to distinguish our tribe from foreigners, a fictional story will serve as a far better identity marker than a true story. The second huge advantage of fiction over truth has to do with the handicap principle, which says that reliable signals must be costly to the signaler. Otherwise, they can easily be faked by cheaters.... If political loyalty is signaled by believing a true story, anyone can fake it. But believing ridiculous and outlandish stories exacts greater cost, and is therefore a better signal of loyalty. Third, and most important, the truth is often painful and disturbing. Hence if you stick to unalloyed reality, few people will follow you. An American presidential candidate who tells the American public the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth about American history has a percent guarantee of losing the elections. An uncompromising adherence to the truth is an admirable spiritual practice, but it is not a winning political strategy.
Even if we need to pay some price for deactivating our rational faculties, the advantages of increased social cohesion are often so big that fictional stories routinely triumph over the truth in human history. Scholars have known this for thousands of years, which is why scholars often had to decide whether they served the truth or social harmony. Should they aim to unite people by making sure everyone believes in the same fiction, or should they let people know the truth even at the price of disunity?
Question 15
Regarding which one of the following quotes could we argue that the author over emphasises the importance of fiction?
Show answer and solution
Answer: (A)
scholars often had to decide whether they served the truth or social harmony. Should they aim to unite people by making sure everyone believes in the same fiction, or should they let people know the truth?
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Critical Evaluation / Author's Rhetoric & Overstatement
-
Passage Reference:
"Scholars have known this for thousands of years, which is why scholars often had to decide whether they served the truth or social harmony. Should they aim to unite people by making sure everyone believes in the same fiction, or should they let people know the truth even at the price of disunity?"
Logical Deduction
The question asks which quote can be critiqued for overemphasizing the necessity or dominance of fiction:
-
In Quote 1, the author establishes an absolute, binary equivalence: serving "social harmony" is equated directly with "making sure everyone believes in the same fiction."
-
This assertion assumes that social unity can only be achieved through collective fiction, and that truth will invariably lead to "disunity." By framing the preservation of harmony as strictly dependent upon belief in fictions, the author discounts the possibility that communities can unite around factual realities, scientific truths, or empirical common ground. This represents an explicit overstatement of the necessity of fiction.
-
In contrast:
-
Quote 2 merely critiques a naive myth about truth automatically conferring power.
-
Quote 3 presents a balanced introductory thesis acknowledging that power encompasses two different dimensions.
-
Quote 4 explicitly affirms the indispensable power of objective truth in mastering physical reality (bridges, medicine, atom bombs).
-
Consequently, Quote 1 is the sole statement where the author overextends the power of fiction into an absolute prerequisite for social cohesion.
Correct Answer: Option 1
- Sets up a hyperbolic binary that equates social harmony entirely with the imposition of shared fictions, ignoring that cooperation and unity can also be founded upon objective truths.
Option Elimination
-
Option 1 (Correct / Rhetorical Overstatement): Presents a reductive dilemma that treats believing in shared fictions as the exclusive mechanism for achieving social unity, overstating fiction's necessity.
-
Option 2 (Textually Balanced Premise): Simply points out that sticking purely to truth is not a guaranteed formula for power; this debunks a myth rather than inflating fiction.
-
Option 3 (Objective Macro-Thesis): Introduces the nuanced dual definition of power in human society in neutral, analytical terms.
-
Option 4 (Direct Emphasis on Truth): Emphasizes the manipulation of objective physical realities, which is rooted entirely in scientific truth—the exact antithesis of overemphasizing fiction.
Detailed explanation
📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure
Central Theme
The intricate, dualistic relationship between truth and power in human society. The author dismantles the comforting myth that truth naturally confers power, demonstrating that power operates on two distinct planes: manipulating objective reality (which strictly requires truth) versus manipulating human beliefs to coordinate large-scale social cooperation (which relies predominantly on shared fictions). The text analyzes the structural evolutionary advantages that fiction holds over truth in cultivating social cohesion, concluding with the historical moral dilemma confronting scholars and leaders: choosing between objective truth and social harmony.
Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary
-
Paragraph 1: Deconstructs the naive assumption that truth is the optimal strategy for gaining power, exposing it as a comforting myth. Posits that truth and power have a complex relationship rooted in the dual meaning of power.
-
Paragraph 2: Bifurcates power into two functional categories:
-
Manipulating objective realities (hunting, engineering, medicine, weapon design), which is inexorably bound to scientific truth.
-
Manipulating human beliefs to achieve mass cooperation, which depends on believing shared narratives that need not be true (e.g., religious, racial, or economic fictions). Explains that large-scale cooperation enables Homo sapiens to dominate the planet, generating the paradox that humans possess unparalleled knowledge of truths while simultaneously harboring profound absurdities.
-
-
Paragraph 3: Elucidates the three competitive advantages of fiction over truth in mobilizing groups:
-
Tribal identity: Truth is universal, whereas localized fictions serve as distinct cultural and political identity markers.
-
The handicap principle: Unquestioning allegiance to bizarre, costly myths provides an unforgeable signal of loyalty, whereas believing obvious truths cannot prove political devotion.
-
Psychological palatability: Objective truth is often harsh, painful, and divisive; an uncompromising adherence to historical truth guarantees political failure, whereas comforting fictions inspire mass devotion.
-
-
Paragraph 4: Asserts that because social unity yields overwhelming collective survival benefits, fictional narratives routinely triumph over truth in history. Concludes by spotlighting the perennial dilemma faced by scholars: whether to champion uncompromising truth at the cost of social discord, or uphold unifying myths to preserve community cohesion.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Academic, Philosophical, Dispassionate, and Analytical.
-
Author's Perspective: Adopts a pragmatic evolutionary and sociological lens, illustrating how human societal power is structurally tethered to fictional mythmaking, while thoughtfully articulating the profound intellectual tension between factual integrity and social solidarity.
Other questions in this set
- Q13. The author implies that, like scholars, successful leaders:
- Q14. The central theme of the passage is about the choice between:
- Q16. The author would support none of the following statements about political power EXCEPT that:
Philosophy questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q11
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q12
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q13
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q14
- CAT 2023 Slot 2 VARC Q1
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc