CAT 2021 Slot 2 VARC Q9
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension › Culture
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2021_SLOT2_VARC_Q09
Passage · questions 9–12
It's easy to forget that most of the world's languages are still transmitted orally with no widely established written form. While speech communities are increasingly involved in projects to protect their languages in print, on air and online - orality is fragile and contributes to linguistic vulnerability. But indigenous languages are about much more than unusual words and intriguing grammar: They function as vehicles for the transmission of cultural traditions, environmental understandings and knowledge about medicinal plants, all at risk when elders die and livelihoods are disrupted.
Both push and pull factors lead to the decline of languages. Through war, famine and natural disasters, whole communities can be destroyed, taking their language with them to the grave, such as the indigenous populations of Tasmania who were wiped out by colonists. More commonly, speakers live on but abandon their language in favor of another vernacular, a widespread process that linguists refer to as "language shift" from which few languages are immune. Such trading up and out of a speech form occurs for complex political, cultural and economic reasons sometimes voluntary for economic and educational reasons, although often amplified by state coercion or neglect. Welsh, long stigmatized and disparaged by the British state, has rebounded with vigor.
Many speakers of endangered, poorly documented languages have embraced new digital media with excitement. Speakers of previously exclusively oral tongues are turning to the web as a virtual space for languages to live on. Internet technology offers powerful ways for oral traditions and cultural practices to survive, even thrive, among increasingly mobile communities. I have watched as videos of traditional wedding ceremonies and songs are recorded on smartphones in London by Nepali migrants, then uploaded to YouTube and watched an hour later by relatives in remote Himalayan villages.
Globalization is regularly, and often uncritically, pilloried as a major threat to linguistic diversity. But in fact, globalization is as much process as it is ideology, certainly when it comes to language. The real forces behind cultural homogenization are unbending beliefs, exchanged through a globalized delivery system, reinforced by the historical monolingualism prevalent in much of the West.
Monolingualism, the condition of being able to speak only one language, is regularly accompanied by a deep-seated conviction in the value of that language over all others. Across the largest economies that make up the G8, being monolingual is still often the norm, with multilingualism appearing unusual and even somewhat exotic. The monolingual mindset stands in sharp contrast to the lived reality of most the world, which throughout its history has been more multilingual than unilingual. Monolingualism, then, not globalization, should be our primary concern.
Multilingualism can help us live in a more connected and more interdependent world. By widening access to technology, globalization can support indigenous and scholarly communities engaged in documenting and protecting our shared linguistic heritage. For the last 5,000 years, the rise and fall of languages was intimately tied to the plow, sword and book. In our digital age, the keyboard, screen and web will play a decisive role in shaping the future linguistic diversity of our species.
Question 9
The author mentions the Welsh language to show that:
Show answer and solution
Answer: (D)
languages can revive even after their speakers have gone through a “language shift”
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Purpose of an Example / Rhetorical Function
-
Passage Reference:
"More commonly, speakers live on but abandon their language in favor of another vernacular, a widespread process that linguists refer to as 'language shift' from which few languages are immune. Such trading up and out of a speech form occurs for complex political, cultural and economic reasons sometimes voluntary for economic and educational reasons, although often amplified by state coercion or neglect. Welsh, long stigmatized and disparaged by the British state, has rebounded with vigor."
Logical Deduction
To understand why the author cites Welsh, one must analyze its immediate rhetorical context in Paragraph 2:
-
The author introduces the phenomenon of "language shift"—the widespread process wherein speakers survive but abandon their native tongue in favor of another dominant vernacular due to economic, educational, or political factors.
-
The author notes that this shift is often "amplified by state coercion or neglect."
-
Directly following this explanation of language shift and state suppression, the author observes: "Welsh, long stigmatized and disparaged by the British state, has rebounded with vigor."
-
Welsh serves as an empirical counter-example demonstrating that language shift and state disparagement do not inevitably lead to permanent extinction; even after undergoing severe decline and speaker abandonment, an endangered language possesses the capacity to revive.
Consequently, Welsh is cited to demonstrate that languages can rebound even after their speech communities have experienced a language shift.
Correct Answer: Option 4
- The author cites Welsh immediately after explicating "language shift" and state hostility to illustrate that vulnerable languages can successfully rebound and revive despite their speakers having traded out their native tongue.
Option Elimination
-
Option 1 (Premature Synthesis / Structural Misplacement): Although the author later discusses globalization's positive role in linguistic preservation (Paragraphs 3, 4, and 6), Paragraph 2 makes no mention of globalization; Welsh is cited strictly in the context of language shift and state disparagement.
-
Option 2 (Factual Distortion / Unwarranted Extrapolation): The passage notes that Welsh was historically "stigmatized and disparaged by the British state," not that modern integration efforts have proven "fruitless."
-
Option 3 (Direct Contradiction / Opposite Meaning): The text explicitly states that the British state "stigmatized and disparaged" Welsh; thus, Welsh rebounded despite state hostility rather than "with state effort."
-
Option 4 (Correct): Directly aligns with the paragraph's logical flow, demonstrating that languages subjected to language shift and disparagement can nevertheless make a vigorous recovery.
Detailed explanation
📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure
Central Theme
The vulnerability, preservation, and revitalization of indigenous and endangered languages in an interconnected digital era. The author reframes the conventional discourse surrounding linguistic extinction by arguing that while oral traditions face severe push and pull pressures—most notably "language shift"—modern digital technologies and globalization serve as unexpected instruments of linguistic survival. Ultimately, the author contends that the primary existential threat to global linguistic diversity is not globalization itself, but the pervasive Western ideology of monolingualism.
Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary
-
Paragraph 1: Establishes that the majority of global languages exist solely in oral form, rendering them structurally fragile. Explains that indigenous languages carry invaluable cultural traditions, environmental understandings, and botanical/medicinal lore that risk permanent extinction upon the demise of community elders and disruption of traditional livelihoods.
-
Paragraph 2: Delineates the push and pull factors catalyzing linguistic decline: physical catastrophe (colonization, war, famine, natural disasters wiping out entire populations, as in colonial Tasmania) versus the far more prevalent socioeconomic process of "language shift" (speakers voluntarily or coercively abandoning their native tongue for a dominant vernacular). Cites the revival of the Welsh language despite historical British state disparagement as proof of potential linguistic resilience.
-
Paragraph 3: Highlights how marginalized and diasporic communities actively harness digital media (smartphones, the web, YouTube) to sustain and transmit endangered oral practices across geographic boundaries (e.g., London-based Nepali migrants sharing traditional wedding ceremonies with Himalayan villages).
-
Paragraph 4: Critiques the reflexive scapegoating of globalization as the chief enemy of linguistic diversity. Clarifies that globalization operates merely as a neutral delivery system; cultural homogenization is instead propelled by rigid ideological convictions rooted in historical Western monolingualism.
-
Paragraph 5: Analyzes the pathology of monolingualism—the parochial conviction that one's sole tongue is intrinsically superior—dominant within G8 economies yet profoundly anomalous when measured against humanity's historically multilingual reality. Reallocates the locus of primary concern from globalization to monolingualism.
-
Paragraph 6: Advocates for universal multilingualism to enrich an interdependent world. Argues that just as earlier linguistic shifts were driven by the plow, sword, and book, the contemporary digital toolkit (keyboard, screen, and web) must now be leveraged by indigenous and scholarly communities to protect global linguistic heritage.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Academic, Analytical, Persuasive, and Advocatory.
-
Author's Perspective: The author champions linguistic diversity and multilingualism, critically refuting simplistic anti-globalization narratives by showing how digital media can empower vulnerable speech communities against institutional monolingualism.
Other questions in this set
- Q10. From the passage, we can infer that the author is in favour of:
- Q11. We can infer all of the following about indigenous languages from the passage EXCEPT that.
- Q12. The author lists all of the following as reasons for the decline or disappearance of a language EXCEPT
Culture questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q2
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q3
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q4
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q5
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q16
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc