CAT 2021 Slot 1 VARC Q15
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension › Culture
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2021_SLOT1_VARC_Q15
Passage · questions 13–16
For the Maya of the Classic period, who lived in Southern Mexico and Central America between 250 and 900 CE, the category of 'persons' was not coincident with human beings, as it is for us. That is, human beings were persons but other, nonhuman entities could be persons, too. In order to explore the slippage of categories between 'humans' and 'persons', I examined a very specific category of ancient Maya images, found painted in scenes on ceramic vessels. I sought out instances in which faces (some combination of eyes, nose, and mouth) are shown on inanimate objects. Consider my iPhone, which needs to be fed with electricity every night, swaddled in a protective bumper, and enjoys communicating with other fellow phone beings. Does it have personhood (if at all) because it is connected to me, drawing this resource from me as an owner or source? For the Maya (who did have plenty of other communicating objects, if not smartphones), the answer was no. Nonhuman persons were not tethered to specific humans, and they did not derive their personhood from a connection with a human. It's a profoundly democratising way of understanding the world. Humans are not more important persons – we are just one of many kinds of persons who inhabit this world.
The Maya saw personhood as 'activated' by experiencing certain bodily needs and through participation in certain social activities. For example, among the faced objects that I examined, persons are marked by personal requirements (such as hunger, tiredness, physical closeness), and by community obligations (communication, interaction, ritual observance). In the images I examined, we see, for instance, faced objects being cradled in humans' arms; we also see them speaking to humans. These core elements of personhood are both turned inward, what the body or self of a person requires, and outward, what a community expects of the persons who are a part of it, underlining the reciprocal nature of community membership.
Personhood was a nonbinary proposition for the Maya. Entities were able to be persons while also being something else. The faced objects I looked at indicate that they continue to be functional, doing what objects do (a stone implement continues to chop, an incense burner continues to do its smoky work). Furthermore, the Maya visually depicted many objects in ways that indicated the material category to which they belonged – drawings of the stone implement show that a person-tool is still made of stone. One additional complexity: the incense burner (which would have been made of clay, and decorated with spiky appliques representing the sacred ceiba tree found in this region) is categorised as a person but also as a tree. With these Maya examples, we are challenged to discard the person/nonperson binary that constitutes our basic ontological outlook. The porousness of boundaries that we have seen in the Maya world points towards the possibility of living with a certain uncategorisability of the world.
Question 15
Which one of the following best explains the "additional complexity" that the example of the incense burner illustrates regarding personhood for the Classic Maya?
Show answer and solution
Answer: (B)
The example adds a new layer to the nonbinary understanding of personhood by bringing in a third category that shares a similar relation with the previous two.
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Author's Argument / Passage Structure
-
Passage Reference:
"Personhood was a nonbinary proposition for the Maya. Entities were able to be persons while also being something else. The faced objects I looked at indicate that they continue to be functional, doing what objects do (a stone implement continues to chop, an incense burner continues to do its smoky work). Furthermore, the Maya visually depicted many objects in ways that indicated the material category to which they belonged – drawings of the stone implement show that a person-tool is still made of stone. One additional complexity: the incense burner (which would have been made of clay, and decorated with spiky appliques representing the sacred ceiba tree found in this region) is categorised as a person but also as a tree. With these Maya examples, we are challenged to discard the person/nonperson binary that constitutes our basic ontological outlook."
Logical Deduction
In Paragraph 3, the author first establishes a dual, nonbinary classification using the stone implement: it is simultaneously (1) a functional tool and (2) a person. The author then introduces an "additional complexity" with the incense burner. The incense burner is not merely an artifact/tool and a person; it incorporates a third taxonomic dimension: (3) a sacred ceiba tree.
Importantly, this third category does not disrupt or contradict the established framework. Instead, it shares the exact same porous, fluid, nonbinary relation as the first two categories—the entity coexists harmoniously across all three categories (ceramic vessel/tool, person, and tree) at once. Thus, it adds a new layer to nonbinary ontology by introducing a third category that shares a similar relational dynamic with the existing categories.
Correct Answer: Option 2
- Option 2 accurately explains the rhetorical and conceptual function of the incense burner: it adds a third overlapping category (the ceiba tree) to the entity's identity, which shares the same fluid, nonbinary relation as the tool and person categories.
Option Elimination
-
Option 1 (Out of Scope / Factual Distortion): While the text mentions that the ceiba tree was "sacred," the author does not construct an argument concerning the theological division between "the divine and the profane"; the focus remains strictly ontological and taxonomic.
-
Option 3 (Factual Distortion / Opposite Meaning): The incense burner is not an anomalous "exception" that disproves nonbinary personhood; rather, it provides further compelling evidence of how expansive and multi-layered nonbinary personhood truly was.
-
Option 4 (Factual Distortion): The third category (tree) does not have a "dissimilar relation" to the other two; it is integrated into the entity's multi-layered personhood through the exact same porous, nonbinary logic.
Detailed explanation
📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure
Central Theme
The passage explores the Classic Maya ontology of personhood, demonstrating that for the Maya, "persons" was not synonymous with or restricted to human beings, but included nonhuman entities and inanimate objects. Maya personhood was fundamentally autonomous (not derived from human attachment or utility), activated through inward bodily needs and reciprocal outward community participation, and nonbinary (entities simultaneously possessed personhood alongside functional and natural identities). This porous, fluid worldview fundamentally destabilizes modern Western anthropocentrism and rigid binary categories.
Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary
-
Paragraph 1: Contrasts the contemporary Western conflation of "humans" and "persons" with the Classic Maya worldview (250–900 CE), where nonhuman entities were recognized as persons. Examining painted ceramic vessels depicting "faced" inanimate objects, the author introduces a modern smartphone analogy to emphasize that Maya nonhuman persons did not derive personhood from their relationship to human owners. Highlights the radically egalitarian, democratizing nature of this cosmology, where humans are merely one of many coexisting kinds of persons.
-
Paragraph 2: Explains the operational criteria for how personhood was "activated" in Maya thought: through experiencing internal bodily needs (such as hunger, fatigue, physical affection/cradling) and fulfilling external community obligations (communication, dialogue, ritual observance). Emphasizes that personhood represents a reciprocal, two-way relationship between an entity's inward self and outward social expectations.
-
Paragraph 3: Elaborates on the nonbinary and porous structure of Maya personhood. Entities maintained multiple simultaneous identities: a stone implement remained functionally a chopping tool and materially stone while being a person. An incense burner added further taxonomic complexity by being simultaneously an artifact, a person, and a sacred ceiba tree. Concludes that Maya ontology challenges modern Western binary thinking, inviting us to embrace ontological porousness and the world's inherent uncategorizability.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Academic, Philosophical, Inquisitive, and Re-evaluative.
-
Author's Perspective: The author approaches the Classic Maya archaeological record with profound philosophical respect, endorsing its relational, non-anthropocentric, and nonbinary ontology as an enlightening challenge to contemporary Western dualisms.
Other questions in this set
- Q13. On the basis of the passage, which one of the following worldviews can be inferred to be closest to that of the…
- Q14. Which one of the following, if true, would not undermine the democratising potential of the Classic Maya worldview?
- Q16. Which one of the following, if true about the Classic Maya, would invalidate the purpose of the iPhone example in the…
Culture questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q2
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q3
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q4
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q5
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q16
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc