CAT 2020 Slot 3 VARC Q6

  • Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
  • Reading Comprehension › Philosophy
  • Medium
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2020_SLOT3_VARC_Q06

Passage · questions 6–9

Although one of the most contested concepts in political philosophy, human nature is something on which most people seem to agree. By and large, according to Rutger Bregman in his new book Humankind, we have a rather pessimistic view not of ourselves exactly, but of everyone else. We see other people as selfish, untrustworthy and dangerous and therefore we behave towards them with defensiveness and suspicion. This was how the 17th-century philosopher Thomas Hobbes conceived our natural state to be, believing that all that stood between us and violent anarchy was a strong state and firm leadership.

But in following Hobbes, argues Bregman, we ensure that the negative view we have of human nature is reflected back at us. He instead puts his faith in Jean-Jacques Rousseau, the 18th-century French thinker, who famously declared that man was born free and it was civilisation with its coercive powers, social classes and restrictive laws that put him in chains.

Hobbes and Rousseau are seen as the two poles of the human nature argument and it's no surprise that Bregman strongly sides with the Frenchman. He takes Rousseau's intuition and paints a picture of a prelapsarian idyll in which, for the better part of 300,000 years, Homo sapiens lived a fulfilling life in harmony with nature. Then we discovered agriculture and for the next 10,000 years it was all property, war, greed and injustice.

It was abandoning our nomadic lifestyle and then domesticating animals, says Bregman, that brought about infectious diseases such as measles, smallpox, tuberculosis, syphilis, malaria, cholera and plague. This may be true, but what Bregman never really seems to get to grips with is that pathogens were not the only things that grew with agriculture so did the number of humans. It's one thing to maintain friendly relations and a propertyless mode of living when you're 30 or 40 hunter-gatherers following the food. But life becomes a great deal more complex and knowledge far more extensive when there are settlements of many thousands.

"Civilisation has become synonymous with peace and progress and wilderness with war and decline," writes Bregman. "In reality, for most of human existence, it was the other way around." Whereas traditional history depicts the collapse of civilisations as "dark ages” in which everything gets worse, modern scholars, he claims, see them more as a reprieve, in which the enslaved gain their freedom and culture flourishes. Like much else in this book, the truth is probably somewhere between the two stated positions.

In any case, the fear of civilisational collapse, Bregman believes, is unfounded. It's the result of what the Dutch biologist Frans de Waal calls "veneer theory" – the idea that just below the surface, our bestial nature is waiting to break out. There's a great deal of reassuring human decency to be taken from this bold and thought-provoking book and a wealth of evidence in support of the contention that the sense of who we are as a species has been deleteriously distorted. But it seems equally misleading to offer the false choice of Rousseau and Hobbes when, clearly, humanity encompasses both.

Question 6

The author has differing views from Bregman regarding:

  1. A

    a civilised society being coercive and unjust.

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    a property-less mode of living being socially harmonious.

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    the role of agriculture in the advancement of knowledge.

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    the role of pathogens in the spread of infectious diseases.

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (A)

a civilised society being coercive and unjust.

Solution

🎯 Question Analysis & Solution

  • Question Type: Direct Comprehension / Comparative Analysis

  • Passage Reference:

"He instead puts his faith in Jean-Jacques Rousseau, the 18th-century French thinker, who famously declared that man was born free and it was civilisation with its coercive powers, social classes and restrictive laws that put him in chains... Then we discovered agriculture and for the next 10,000 years it was all property, war, greed and injustice... Like much else in this book, the truth is probably somewhere between the two stated positions... But it seems equally misleading to offer the false choice of Rousseau and Hobbes when, clearly, humanity encompasses both."

Logical Deduction

  1. The question requires identifying the specific issue on which the author diverges from Bregman.

  2. Bregman wholeheartedly adopts Rousseau's viewpoint, characterizing civilised society as an apparatus of coercive powers, social classes, and restrictive laws that ushered in 10,000 years of greed, war, and injustice.

  3. In contrast, the author directly qualifies Bregman's thesis by asserting that "the truth is probably somewhere between the two stated positions," pointing out that settlements also generated extensive knowledge, and concluding that presenting a false dichotomy between Rousseau's condemnation of civilisation and Hobbes's cynical defense of the state is misleading.

  4. Therefore, the depiction of civilized society as unilaterally coercive and unjust is the exact point where the author's view departs from Bregman's.

Correct Answer: Option 1

  • Bregman unequivocally endorses Rousseau's belief that civilisation is fundamentally coercive and unjust, whereas the author rejects this one-sided narrative, maintaining that historical truth is intermediate and that civilization also enabled extensive knowledge and complexity.

Option Elimination

  • Option 2 (Factual Distortion): The author does not differ from Bregman on this point; Paragraph 4 explicitly concedes that hunter-gatherers could indeed maintain "friendly relations and a propertyless mode of living" in small bands.

  • Option 3 (Out of Scope): Although the author observes that knowledge expanded with agricultural settlements, Bregman does not articulate an opposing stance on knowledge; rather, Bregman overlooks it, meaning there is no active debate between them on this subject.

  • Option 4 (Opposite Meaning / Scope Reversal): The author explicitly agrees with Bregman's view regarding pathogens, stating in Paragraph 4 that Bregman's assertion that settled lifestyle and animal domestication brought infectious diseases "may be true."

Detailed explanation

📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure

Central Theme

A critical evaluation of Rutger Bregman's book Humankind, examining his Rousseauian defense of innate human goodness against Hobbesian cynicism, and arguing that human reality is a complex amalgamation of both rather than a reductive dichotomy.

Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary

  • Paragraph 1: Highlights the widespread Hobbesian pessimism regarding the selfishness and untrustworthy nature of others, which historically justified the necessity of a strong state to prevent violent anarchy.

  • Paragraph 2: Outlines Bregman's critique of Hobbesian cynicism as a self-fulfilling negative cycle and introduces his alignment with Rousseau's view that human nature is innately free and corrupted only by civilisational institutions.

  • Paragraph 3: Traces Bregman's Rousseauian narrative of a 300,000-year nomadic idyll lived in harmony with nature, which was purportedly ruined 10,000 years ago by agriculture, property, and institutional injustice.

  • Paragraph 4: Concedes Bregman's claim that animal domestication brought infectious diseases, but critiques his neglect of the fact that agriculture simultaneously fueled massive population growth and extensive knowledge systems.

  • Paragraph 5: Discusses Bregman's historical inversion that civilisational collapse represented a liberating cultural reprieve, noting that historical reality likely lies between traditional and revisionist extremes.

  • Paragraph 6: Mentions Bregman's rejection of Frans de Waal's "veneer theory" and affirms his defense of human decency, but cautions against the misleading binary choice between Rousseau and Hobbes.

Tone and Author's Perspective

  • Tone: Academic, analytical, critically evaluative, and balanced.

  • Author's Perspective: Appreciative of Bregman's empirical defense of human decency, yet critical of his uncritical Rousseauian romanticism and reductive binary framing of human nature.

Other questions in this set

  1. Q7. According to the author, the main reason why Bregman contrasts life in pre- agricultural societies with agricultural…
  2. Q8. According to the passage, the "collapse of civilisations" is viewed by Bregman as:
  3. Q9. None of the following views is expressed in the passage EXCEPT that:

Philosophy questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q11
    All of the following can reasonably be inferred from the passage EXCEPT:
  2. CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q12
    Choose the one option below that comes closest to being the opposite of “utilitarianism”.
  3. CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q13
    Which one of the options below best summarises the passage?
  4. CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q14
    The passage compares ethics to physics, where different theories apply to different aspects of a domain and…
  5. CAT 2023 Slot 2 VARC Q1
    According to this passage, which one of the following statements best describes the significance of…

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc