CAT 2020 Slot 3 DILR Q10
- Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
- Logical Reasoning › Games & Tournaments
- Hard
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2020_SLOT3_DILR_Q10
Data set · questions 5–10
The Hi-Lo game is a four-player game played in six rounds. In every round, each player chooses to bid Hi or Lo. The bids are made simultaneously. If all four bid Hi, then all four lose 1 point each. If three players bid Hi and one bids Lo, then the players bidding Hi gain 1 point each and the player bidding Lo loses 3 points. If two players bid Hi and two bid Lo, then the players bidding Hi gain 2 points each and the players bidding Lo lose 2 points each. If one player bids Hi and three bid Lo, then the player bidding Hi gains 3 points and the players bidding Lo lose 1 point each. If all four bid Lo, then all four gain 1 point each.
Four players Arun, Bankim, Charu, and Dipak played the Hi-Lo game. The following facts are known about their game:
- At the end of three rounds, Arun had scored 6 points, Dipak had scored 2 points, Bankim and Charu had scored -2 points each.
- At the end of six rounds, Arun had scored 7 points, Bankim and Dipak had scored -1 point each, and Charu had scored -5 points.
- Dipak's score in the third round was less than his score in the first round but was more than his score in the second round.
- In exactly two out of the six rounds, Arun was the only player who bid Hi.
Question 10
In which of the following rounds, was Arun DEFINITELY the only player to bid Hi?
Show answer and solution
Answer: (A)
Second
Solution
Concept: Uniqueness vs Permutation Analysis, Sole-Bidder Isolation & Definite State Identification
Master State Table
| Round | Arun (Bid / Pts) | Bankim (Bid / Pts) | Charu (Bid / Pts) | Dipak (Bid / Pts) | Round Profile (k Hi) | Round Sum |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Round 1 | Hi (+2) | Lo (-2) | Lo (-2) | Hi (+2) | 2 Hi, 2 Lo | 0 |
| Round 2 | Hi (+3) | Lo (-1) | Lo (-1) | Lo (-1) | 1 Hi, 3 Lo (Arun only) | 0 |
| Round 3 | Lo (+1) | Lo (+1) | Lo (+1) | Lo (+1) | 0 Hi, 4 Lo (All Lo) | +4 |
| Subtotal (R1–R3) | 6 | -2 | -2 | 2 | — | +4 |
| R4–R6 (Round X) | Hi (+3) | Lo (-1) | Lo (-1) | Lo (-1) | 1 Hi, 3 Lo (Arun only) | 0 |
| R4–R6 (Round Y) | Lo (-1) | Hi (+3) | Lo (-1) | Lo (-1) | 1 Hi, 3 Lo (Bankim only) | 0 |
| R4–R6 (Round Z) | Hi (-1) | Hi (-1) | Hi (-1) | Hi (-1) | 4 Hi, 0 Lo (All Hi) | -4 |
| Final Total (R1–R6) | 7 | -1 | -5 | -1 | — | 0 |
Question Deduction
• Sole-Bidder Criterion from Clue 4:
• Clue 4 states: "In exactly two out of the six rounds, Arun was the only player who bid Hi."
• When a player is the sole Hi bidder (), that player gains points, while the three Lo bidders each score .
• Evaluating Rounds 1, 2, and 3:
• Round 1: Arun and Dipak both bid Hi (), each scoring points. Arun was not the only player to bid Hi.
• Round 2: Arun bid Hi and scored points, while Bankim, Charu, and Dipak all bid Lo and scored point each ().
• Round 3: All four players bid Lo (), each gaining point. Arun did not bid Hi.
• Therefore, Round 2 (the Second round) is conclusively and definitely a round where Arun was the only player who bid Hi.
• Evaluating Rounds 4, 5, and 6:
• In Rounds 4–6, Arun was the sole Hi bidder in exactly one round (Round X, scoring ).
• However, the chronological order of the three rounds in R4–R6—Round X (Arun sole Hi), Round Y (Bankim sole Hi), and Round Z (all four Hi)—is unconstrained by the passage.
• Round X could have occurred in Round 4, Round 5, or Round 6.
• Consequently, Arun was not definitely the only player to bid Hi in the Fourth round.
• Option Matching:
• Matches Option 1 (Second).
• Distractor check:
• Option 2 (Fourth) fails because Round 4 is merely possible, not definite.
• Option 3 (Third) fails because all four players bid Lo in Round 3.
• Option 4 (First) fails because both Arun and Dipak bid Hi in Round 1.
Topper Take
• Note the keyword 'DEFINITELY': Rounds 4–6 are symmetric permutations where sole-Hi could occur in round 4, 5, or 6.
• Round 2 is fixed chronologically by Dipak's monotonicity and Arun's payoff, making 'Second' the only definite choice.
Other questions in this set
- Q5. What were the bids by Arun, Bankim, Charu and Dipak, respectively in the first round?
- Q6. In how many rounds did Arun bid Hi?
- Q7. In how many rounds did Bankim bid Lo?
- Q8. In how many rounds did all four players make identical bids?
- Q9. In how many rounds did Dipak gain exactly 1 point?
Games & Tournaments questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q14
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q15
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q16
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q17
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q18
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc