CAT 2020 Slot 3 DILR Q3

  • Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
  • Logical Reasoning › Grids
  • Easy
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2020_SLOT3_DILR_Q03

Data set · questions 1–4

Sixteen patients in a hospital must undergo a blood test for a disease. It is known that exactly one of them has the disease. The hospital has only eight testing kits and has decided to pool blood samples of patients into eight vials for the tests. The patients are numbered 11 through 1616, and the vials are labelled A, B, C, D, E, F, G, and H. The following table shows the vials into which each patient's blood sample is distributed.

PatientVialsPatientVials
1B, D, F, H9A, D, F, H
2B, D, F, G10A, D, F, G
3B, D, E, H11A, D, E, H
4B, D, E, G12A, D, E, G
5B, C, F, H13A, C, F, H
6B, C, F, G14A, C, F, G
7B, C, E, H15A, C, E, H
8B, C, E, G16A, C, E, G

If a patient has the disease, then each vial containing his/her blood sample will test positive. If a vial tests positive, one of the patients whose blood samples were mixed in the vial has the disease. If a vial tests negative, then none of the patients whose blood samples were mixed in the vial has the disease.

Question 3

Which of the following combinations of test results is NOT possible?

  1. A

    Vial B positive, vials C, F and H negative

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    Vials B and D positive, vials F and H negative

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    Vials A and E positive, vials C and D negative

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    Vials A and G positive, vials D and E negative

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (C)

Vials A and E positive, vials C and D negative

Solution

Concept: Pairwise Exhaustion Principle, Total Coverage Invariants & Contradiction Detection

Master State Table

PatientPair 1 (A/B)Pair 2 (C/D)Pair 3 (E/F)Pair 4 (G/H)
Patient 1BDFH
Patient 2BDFG
Patient 3BDEH
Patient 4BDEG
Patient 5BCFH
Patient 6BCFG
Patient 7BCEH
Patient 8BCEG
Patient 9ADFH
Patient 10ADFG
Patient 11ADEH
Patient 12ADEG
Patient 13ACFH
Patient 14ACFG
Patient 15ACEH
Patient 16ACEG

Question Deduction

• Fundamental Complementary Invariant:

• The 16 patients are partitioned across four disjoint pairs: {A,B}\{A, B\}, {C,D}\{C, D\}, {E,F}\{E, F\}, and {G,H}\{G, H\}, each satisfying total population coverage:

$$A \cup B = C \cup D = E \cup F = G \cup H = \{1, 2, \dots, 16\}$$

• Because exactly one patient has the disease, that patient's blood is in exactly one vial of each pair.

• Within every pair, exactly one vial must test positive and the other must test negative. It is impossible for both vials in any pair to test negative or both to test positive.

• Evaluation of Option 3 (Vials A, E positive; vials C, D negative):

• Option 3 asserts that both Vial C and Vial D test negative simultaneously.

• Vial C pools blood from Patients {5,6,7,8,13,14,15,16}\{5, 6, 7, 8, 13, 14, 15, 16\} and Vial D pools blood from Patients {1,2,3,4,9,10,11,12}\{1, 2, 3, 4, 9, 10, 11, 12\}.

• Because C∪D={1,2,…,16}C \cup D = \{1, 2, \dots, 16\}, both testing negative implies that none of the 16 patients has the disease.

• This directly contradicts the passage premise that exactly one patient has the disease, rendering Option 3 mathematically impossible.

• Feasibility Verification of Valid Options:

• Option 1 (B positive; C, F, H negative): Profile {B,D,E,G}\{B, D, E, G\} corresponds to Patient 4. Feasible.

• Option 2 (B, D positive; F, H negative): Profile {B,D,E,G}\{B, D, E, G\} corresponds to Patient 4. Feasible.

• Option 4 (A, G positive; D, E negative): Profile {A,C,F,G}\{A, C, F, G\} corresponds to Patient 14. Feasible.

• Option Matching:

• The combination in Option 3 is mathematically impossible.

• Matches Option 3 (Vials A and E positive, vials C and D negative).

Topper Take

• Total coverage shortcut: recognize that each pair {A,B}\{A,B\}, {C,D}\{C,D\}, {E,F}\{E,F\}, {G,H}\{G,H\} covers the entire patient population.

• If both vials in any pair test negative (here C and D), no patient could possibly have the disease—an immediate contradiction. Tag Option 3 in 10 seconds.

Other questions in this set

  1. Q1. Suppose vial C tests positive and vials A, E and H test negative. Which patient has the disease?
  2. Q2. Suppose vial A tests positive and vials D and G test negative. Which of the following vials should we test next to…
  3. Q4. Suppose one of the lab assistants accidentally mixed two patients' blood samples before they were distributed to the…

Grids questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2025 Slot 2 DILR Q6
    What was the total number of pings made by B1, B2, and B3?
  2. CAT 2025 Slot 2 DILR Q7
    Which of the following statements about the relative sizes of the balls is NOT NECESSARILY true?
  3. CAT 2025 Slot 2 DILR Q8
    Which of the following statements about the relative sizes of the hoops is true?
  4. CAT 2025 Slot 2 DILR Q9
    What BEST can be said about the total number of pings from all the tests undertaken?
  5. CAT 2025 Slot 3 DILR Q10
    What was the duration of calls (in minutes) from Bijay to Anu?

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc