CAT 2020 Slot 3 DILR Q2
- Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
- Logical Reasoning › Grids
- Easy
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2020_SLOT3_DILR_Q02
Data set · questions 1–4
Sixteen patients in a hospital must undergo a blood test for a disease. It is known that exactly one of them has the disease. The hospital has only eight testing kits and has decided to pool blood samples of patients into eight vials for the tests. The patients are numbered through , and the vials are labelled A, B, C, D, E, F, G, and H. The following table shows the vials into which each patient's blood sample is distributed.
| Patient | Vials | Patient | Vials |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | B, D, F, H | 9 | A, D, F, H |
| 2 | B, D, F, G | 10 | A, D, F, G |
| 3 | B, D, E, H | 11 | A, D, E, H |
| 4 | B, D, E, G | 12 | A, D, E, G |
| 5 | B, C, F, H | 13 | A, C, F, H |
| 6 | B, C, F, G | 14 | A, C, F, G |
| 7 | B, C, E, H | 15 | A, C, E, H |
| 8 | B, C, E, G | 16 | A, C, E, G |
If a patient has the disease, then each vial containing his/her blood sample will test positive. If a vial tests positive, one of the patients whose blood samples were mixed in the vial has the disease. If a vial tests negative, then none of the patients whose blood samples were mixed in the vial has the disease.
Question 2
Suppose vial A tests positive and vials D and G test negative. Which of the following vials should we test next to identify the patient with the disease?
Show answer and solution
Answer: (D)
Vial E
Solution
Concept: Information Entropy, Unresolved Coordinate Identification & Sequential Diagnostic Strategy
Master State Table
| Patient | Pair 1 (A/B) | Pair 2 (C/D) | Pair 3 (E/F) | Pair 4 (G/H) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Patient 1 | B | D | F | H |
| Patient 2 | B | D | F | G |
| Patient 3 | B | D | E | H |
| Patient 4 | B | D | E | G |
| Patient 5 | B | C | F | H |
| Patient 6 | B | C | F | G |
| Patient 7 | B | C | E | H |
| Patient 8 | B | C | E | G |
| Patient 9 | A | D | F | H |
| Patient 10 | A | D | F | G |
| Patient 11 | A | D | E | H |
| Patient 12 | A | D | E | G |
| Patient 13 | A | C | F | H |
| Patient 14 | A | C | F | G |
| Patient 15 | A | C | E | H |
| Patient 16 | A | C | E | G |
Question Deduction
• Candidate Pruning via Invariant Pairs:
• The 8 vials form 4 complementary pairs: , , , and .
• With exactly one diseased patient, knowing the status of one vial in a pair fully determines the other:
• **Vial A positive**: Patient $\in \{9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16\}$ (Vial B is negative).
• **Vial D negative**: Patient $\notin D \implies$ patient $\in C$, narrowing suspects to $\{13, 14, 15, 16\}$ (Vial C is positive).
• **Vial G negative**: Patient $\notin G \implies$ patient $\in H$ (odd-numbered patients), narrowing suspects to $\{13, 15\}$ (Vial H is positive).
• Isolating the Remaining Ambiguity:
• The two remaining candidate patients are Patient 13 and Patient 15:
• Patient 13 has assigned vials $\{A, C, F, H\}$.
• Patient 15 has assigned vials $\{A, C, E, H\}$.
• Both share identical assignments in three pairs (vials A, C, and H). They differ solely in Pair 3 (): Patient 13 has F, whereas Patient 15 has E.
• Neither vial E nor vial F has been tested yet, leaving Pair 3 as the sole unresolved coordinate.
• Diagnostic Power of the Next Test:
• Testing vial E immediately discriminates between the two candidates: if E is positive, Patient 15 is diseased; if E is negative, Patient 13 is diseased.
• Distractor check: Vials C, H, and B are already known (C and H positive, B negative), providing zero new diagnostic information.
• Option Matching:
• Vial E is the only choice belonging to the untested pair that resolves the patient identity.
• Matches Option 4 (Vial E).
Topper Take
• Pair triage: Pairs 1 (A/B), 2 (C/D), and 4 (G/H) are already fully resolved by the given tests.
• The only unresolved pair is Pair 3 (). Scan the answer choices directly for E or F—Option 4 (Vial E) is the immediate pick.
Other questions in this set
- Q1. Suppose vial C tests positive and vials A, E and H test negative. Which patient has the disease?
- Q3. Which of the following combinations of test results is NOT possible?
- Q4. Suppose one of the lab assistants accidentally mixed two patients' blood samples before they were distributed to the…
Grids questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 DILR Q6
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 DILR Q7
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 DILR Q8
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 DILR Q9
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 DILR Q10
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc