CAT 2020 Slot 2 VARC Q5

  • Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
  • Reading Comprehension › Economy
  • Hard
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2020_SLOT2_VARC_Q05

Passage · questions 5–9

In a low-carbon world, renewable energy technologies are hot business. For investors looking to redirect funds, wind turbines and solar panels, among other technologies, seem a straightforward choice. But renewables need to be further scrutinized before being championed as forging a path toward a low-carbon future. Both the direct and indirect impacts of renewable energy must be examined to ensure that a climate-smart future does not intensify social and environmental harm. As renewable energy production requires land, water, and labor, among other inputs, it imposes costs on people and the environment. Hydropower projects, for instance, have led to community dispossession and exclusion .Renewable energy supply chains are also intertwined with mining, and their technologies contribute to growing levels of electronic waste. Furthermore, although renewable energy can be produced and distributed through small-scale, local systems, such an approach might not generate the high returns on investment needed to attract capital.

Although an emerging sector, renewables are enmeshed in long-standing resource extraction through their dependence on minerals and metals. Scholars document the negative consequences of mining even for mining operations that commit to socially responsible practices[:] "many of the world's largest reservoirs of minerals like cobalt, copper, lithium, [and] rare earth minerals"—the ones needed for renewable technologies—"are found in fragile states and under communities of marginalized peoples in Africa, Asia, and Latin America. "Since the demand for metals and minerals will increase substantially in a renewable - powered future. This intensification could exacerbate the existing consequences of extractive activities.

Among the connections between climate change and waste, O'Neill highlights that "devices developed to reduce our carbon footprint, such as lithium batteries for hybrid and electric cars or solar panels, become potentially dangerous electronic waste at the end of their productive life." The disposal of toxic waste has long perpetuated social injustice through the flows of waste to the Global South and to marginalized communities in the Global North.

While renewable energy is a more recent addition to financial portfolios, investments in the sector must be considered in light of our understanding of capital accumulation. As agricultural finance reveals, the concentration of control of corporate activity facilitates profit generation. For some climate activists, the promise of renewables rests on their ability not only to reduce emissions but also to provide distributed, democratized access to energy .But Burke and Stephens caution that "renewable energy systems offer a possibility but nota certainty for more democratic energy futures." Small-scale, distributed forms of energy are only highly profitable to institutional investors if control is consolidated somewhere in the financial chain. Renewable energy can be produced at the household or neighborhood level. However, such small-scale, localized production is unlikely to generate high returns for investors. For financial growth to be sustained and expanded by the renewable sector, production and trade in renewable energy technologies will need to be highly concentrated, and large asset management firms will likely drive those developments.

Question 5

Which one of the following statements, if false, could be seen as best supporting the arguments in the passage?

  1. A

    Renewable energy systems have little or no environmental impact.

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    Renewable energy systems are as expensive as non-renewable energy systems.

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    Renewable energy systems are not as profitable as non-renewable energy systems.

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    The production and distribution of renewable energy through small-scale, local systems is not economically sustainable.

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (A)

Renewable energy systems have little or no environmental impact.

Solution

🎯 Question Analysis & Solution

  • Question Type: Critical Reasoning / Argument Evaluation

  • Passage Reference:

"Both the direct and indirect impacts of renewable energy must be examined to ensure that a climate-smart future does not intensify social and environmental harm. As renewable energy production requires land, water, and labor, among other inputs, it imposes costs on people and the environment."

Logical Deduction

The question employs a reverse-logic condition: identifying which proposition, when rendered false (negated), best strengthens the passage's argument. If a statement's falsity supports the author, the original statement must directly oppose the passage's core thesis. The central thesis of the passage is that renewable energy systems are far from benign; they generate extensive and severe environmental and social costs (such as resource consumption, mining degradation, and electronic waste). Consequently, if the claim "Renewable energy systems have little or no environmental impact" is false (meaning renewables do inflict substantial environmental harm), it directly corroborates and strengthens the author's primary argument.

Correct Answer: Option 1

  • If Option 1 is false, it asserts that renewable energy systems have significant environmental impacts, directly validating the author's central contention that renewables impose substantial direct and indirect ecological harms.

Option Elimination

  • Option 2 (Out of Scope): The passage does not evaluate whether renewables are as expensive as non-renewable systems; negating an unaddressed financial comparison provides no logical support to the author's thesis.

  • Option 3 (Out of Scope): The author's critique centers on corporate concentration and capital accumulation rather than a profitability comparison with fossil fuels; proving this claim false does not advance the passage's argument.

  • Option 4 (Opposite Meaning / Scope Reversal): If Option 4 were false, it would indicate that small-scale local systems are economically sustainable, directly contradicting the author's observation that localized production struggles to generate high returns to attract capital.

Detailed explanation

📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure

Central Theme

While renewable energy technologies are championed as benign, low-carbon solutions, their rapid expansion entails severe socio-environmental costs—including intensified mineral extraction, toxic electronic waste displacement, and capital-driven corporate concentration that undermines democratic access.

Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary

  • Paragraph 1: The author introduces the commercial enthusiasm surrounding renewable technologies, cautioning that both direct and indirect socio-environmental externalities—such as land consumption, community dispossession, mining dependency, and e-waste—require rigorous scrutiny before renewables are embraced uncritically.

  • Paragraph 2: The author highlights how the renewable sector remains tethered to destructive extractive industries, as critical mineral reserves (cobalt, lithium, rare earths) reside predominantly in fragile states and beneath marginalized communities in the Global South, where surging demand risks compounding historical exploitation.

  • Paragraph 3: The discussion examines the terminal lifecycle of clean technologies, demonstrating how hazardous electronic waste disproportionately burdens vulnerable populations across the Global South and marginalized pockets of the Global North, thereby perpetuating structural environmental injustice.

  • Paragraph 4: The author analyzes the political economy of green investments, observing that institutional capital accumulation necessitates consolidated corporate control, creating a stark contradiction between activists' aspirations for democratized, local energy systems and the financial sector's drive toward centralized monopolization.

Tone and Author's Perspective

  • Tone: Critical, Analytical, and Cautionary.

  • Author's Perspective: The author adopts a critical academic perspective, challenging the uncritical, technocratic optimism surrounding the green transition by exposing its hidden socio-environmental costs, structural inequities, and corporate consolidation.

Other questions in this set

  1. Q6. All of the following statements, if true, could be seen as supporting the arguments in the passage, EXCEPT:
  2. Q7. Which one of the following statements, if true, could be an accurate inference from the first paragraph of the passage?
  3. Q8. Which one of the following statements best captures the main argument of the last paragraph of the passage?
  4. Q9. Based on the passage, we can infer that the author would be most supportive of which one of the following practices?

Economy questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q19
    The passage refers to "democratization". Choose the one option below that comes closest to the opposite of…
  2. CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q20
    The primary function of the three-part case for a positive income inequality–economic growth link in the…
  3. CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q21
    Which one of the options below best summarises the passage?
  4. CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q22
    According to the incentive or moral hazard argument, which one of the designs below is most consistent with…
  5. CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q16
    In the first paragraph the author is making the point that economists like Becker

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc