CAT 2020 Slot 2 DILR Q9
- Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
- Logical Reasoning › Optimization
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2020_SLOT2_DILR_Q09
Data set · questions 5–10
The Humanities department of a college is planning to organize eight seminars, one for each of the eight doctoral students - A, B, C, D, E, F, G and H. Four of them are from Economics, three from Sociology and one from Anthropology department. Each student is guided by one among P, Q, R, S and T. Two students are guided by each of P, R and T, while one student is guided by each of Q and S. Each student is guided by a guide belonging to their department.
Each seminar is to be scheduled in one of four consecutive 30-minute slots starting at 9:00am, 9:30 am, 10:00 am and 10:30 am on the same day. More than one seminars can be scheduled in a slot, provided the guide is free. Only three rooms are available and hence at the most three seminars can be Scheduled in a slot. Students who are guided by the same guide must be scheduled in consecutive slots.
The following additional facts are also known.
- Seminars by students from Economics are scheduled in each of the four slots.
- A's is the only seminar that is scheduled at 10:00 am. A is guided by R.
- F is an Anthropology student whose seminar is scheduled at 10:30 am.
- The seminar of a Sociology student is scheduled at 9:00 am.
- B and G are both Sociology students, whose seminars are scheduled in the same slot. The seminar of an Economics student, who is guided by T, is also scheduled in the same slot.
- P, who is guiding both B and C, has students scheduled in the first two slots.
- A and G are scheduled in two consecutive slots.
Question 9
If E and Q are both scheduled in the same slot, then which of the following statements BEST describes the relationship between D, H, and T?
Show answer and solution
Answer: (A)
At least one of D and H is guided by T.
Solution
Concept: Co-occurrence Branch Analysis & Logical Quantifier Evaluation
Master State Table
| Slot Time | Student | Department | Guide | Slot Total | Governing Invariants & Allocations |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9:00 am (Slot 1) | C | Sociology | P | 2 | Guided by P; paired with an Economics student (2 rooms) |
| 9:00 am (Slot 1) | D / E / H | Economics | T | 2 | Guided by T; T's first consecutive slot |
| 9:30 am (Slot 2) | B | Sociology | P | 3 | Guided by P; maximum room capacity (3 rooms) reached |
| 9:30 am (Slot 2) | G | Sociology | Q or S | 3 | Guided by Q or S; slot immediately precedes A's slot |
| 9:30 am (Slot 2) | D / E / H | Economics | T | 3 | Guided by T; T's second consecutive slot |
| 10:00 am (Slot 3) | A | Economics | R | 1 | Sole seminar in slot; R's first consecutive slot |
| 10:30 am (Slot 4) | F | Anthropology | S or Q | 2 | Sole Anthropology student; paired with an Econ student |
| 10:30 am (Slot 4) | D / E / H | Economics | R | 2 | Guided by R; R's second consecutive slot |
Question Deduction
• Premise Formulation & Feasible Slots:
• Premise: . E is an Economics student from (slots 1, 2, or 4).
• Guide Q guides either G (Slot 2 at 9:30 am) or F (Slot 4 at 10:30 am).
• Thus, the shared slot must be either Slot 2 (9:30 am) or Slot 4 (10:30 am).
• Branch Evaluation across Feasible Slots:
• Case 1: E and Q share Slot 4 (10:30 am).
• Q guides F at 10:30 am; E is the Economics student at 10:30 am (guided by R).
• D and H occupy Slots 1 and 2, both guided by T.
• Hence, in Case 1, BOTH D and H are guided by T.
• Case 2: E and Q share Slot 2 (9:30 am).
• Q guides G at 9:30 am; E is the Economics student at 9:30 am (guided by T).
• T's consecutive slot is Slot 1 (9:00 am). Thus, T guides one of $\{D, H\}$ at 9:00 am, while the other is at 10:30 am (guided by R).
• Hence, in Case 2, EXACTLY ONE of D and H is guided by T.
• Synthesis & Logical Quantifier Match:
• In Case 1: Count of students among guided by T is 2.
• In Case 2: Count of students among guided by T is 1.
• Across both cases, "At least one of D and H is guided by T" holds true without exception.
• Option Matching:
• Option 1: "At least one of D and H is guided by T" — Universally valid across all branches.
• Options 2, 3, and 4: Contradicted or overspecified across the branches.
• Confirms Option 1.
Topper Take
• Quantifier Union Shortcut: Case 1 yields 2 and Case 2 yields 1. When CAT asks for the statement that "BEST describes" a branching outcome, take their logical union (, "at least one"), which isolates Option 1 instantly.
Other questions in this set
- Q5. Which one of the following statements is necessarily true?
- Q6. Who all are NOT guiding any Economics students?
- Q7. Which one of the following statements is necessarily true?
- Q8. If D is scheduled in a slot later than Q's, then which of the following two statement(s) is (are) true? (i) E and H…
- Q10. If D is scheduled in the slot immediately before Q's, then which of the following is NOT necessarily true?
Optimization questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q18
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q19
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q20
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q21
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q22
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc