CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q20

  • Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
  • Logical Reasoning › Optimization
  • Hard
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2024_SLOT1_DILR_Q20

Data set · questions 18–22

Two students, Amiya and Ramya are the only candidates in an election for the position of class representative. Students will vote based on the intensity level of Amiya's and Ramya's campaigns and the type of campaigns they run. Each campaign is said to have a level of 11 if it is a staid campaign and a level of 22 if it is a vigorous campaign. Campaigns can be of two types, they can either focus on issues, or on attacking the other candidate.

If Amiya and Ramya both run campaigns focusing on issues, then

• The percentage of students voting in the election will be 2020 times the sum of the levels of campaigning of the two students. For example, if Amiya and Ramya both run vigorous campaigns, then 20×(2+2)%20 \times(2+2) \%, that is, 80%80 \% of the students will vote in the election.

• Among voting students, the percentage of votes for each candidate will be proportional to the levels of their campaigns. For example, if Amiya runs a staid (i.e., level 1) campaign while Ramya runs a vigorous (i.e., level 2) campaign, then Amiya will receive 1/31 / 3 of the votes cast, and Ramya will receive the other 2/32 / 3.

The above-mentioned percentages change as follows if at least one of them runs a campaign attacking their opponent.

• If Amiya runs a campaign attacking Ramya and Ramya runs a campaign focusing on issues, then 10%10 \% of the students who would have otherwise voted for Amiya will vote for Ramya, and another 10%10 \% who would have otherwise voted for Amiya, will not vote at all.

• If Ramya runs a campaign attacking Amiya and Amiya runs a campaign focusing on issues, then 20%20 \% of the students who would have otherwise voted for Ramya will vote for Amiya, and another 5%5 \% who would have otherwise voted for Ramya, will not vote at all.

• If both run campaigns attacking each other, then 10%10 \% of the students who would have otherwise voted for them had they run campaigns focusing on issues, will not vote at all.

Question 20

If Amiya runs a campaign focusing on issues, then what is the maximum percentage of votes that she

can get?

  1. A

    40%

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    36%

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    48%

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    44%

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (C)

48%

Solution

Concept: Game-Theoretic Payoff Matrices & Strategic Dominance

Master State Table

CaseAmiya Strategy (LAL_A, Type)Ramya Strategy (LRL_R, Type)Base Turnout T0T_0Amiya Votes VAV_ARamya Votes VRV_RActual Turnout TTNet Margin ∣VA−VR∣\vert V_A - V_R \vertElection Outcome
C01Staid, Issues (1,I1, I)Staid, Issues (1,I1, I)40%20.0%20.0%40.0%0.0%Tie (0.0%)
C02Staid, Issues (1,I1, I)Staid, Attack (1,A1, A)40%24.0%15.0%39.0%9.0%Amiya (+9.0%)
C03Staid, Attack (1,A1, A)Staid, Issues (1,I1, I)40%16.0%22.0%38.0%6.0%Ramya (+6.0%)
C04Staid, Attack (1,A1, A)Staid, Attack (1,A1, A)40%18.0%18.0%36.0%0.0%Tie (0.0%)
C05Staid, Issues (1,I1, I)Vigorous, Issues (2,I2, I)60%20.0%40.0%60.0%20.0%Ramya (+20.0%)
C06Staid, Issues (1,I1, I)Vigorous, Attack (2,A2, A)60%28.0%30.0%58.0%2.0%Ramya (+2.0%)
C07Staid, Attack (1,A1, A)Vigorous, Issues (2,I2, I)60%16.0%42.0%58.0%26.0%Ramya (+26.0%)
C08Staid, Attack (1,A1, A)Vigorous, Attack (2,A2, A)60%18.0%36.0%54.0%18.0%Ramya (+18.0%)
C09Vigorous, Issues (2,I2, I)Staid, Issues (1,I1, I)60%40.0%20.0%60.0%20.0%Amiya (+20.0%)
C10Vigorous, Issues (2,I2, I)Staid, Attack (1,A1, A)60%44.0%15.0%59.0%29.0%Amiya (+29.0%)
C11Vigorous, Attack (2,A2, A)Staid, Issues (1,I1, I)60%32.0%24.0%56.0%8.0%Amiya (+8.0%)
C12Vigorous, Attack (2,A2, A)Staid, Attack (1,A1, A)60%36.0%18.0%54.0%18.0%Amiya (+18.0%)
C13Vigorous, Issues (2,I2, I)Vigorous, Issues (2,I2, I)80%40.0%40.0%80.0%0.0%Tie (0.0%)
C14Vigorous, Issues (2,I2, I)Vigorous, Attack (2,A2, A)80%48.0%30.0%78.0%18.0%Amiya (+18.0%)
C15Vigorous, Attack (2,A2, A)Vigorous, Issues (2,I2, I)80%32.0%44.0%76.0%12.0%Ramya (+12.0%)
C16Vigorous, Attack (2,A2, A)Vigorous, Attack (2,A2, A)80%36.0%36.0%72.0%0.0%Tie (0.0%)

Question Deduction

• Fixed Parameter & Objective: Amiya focuses on issues (TA=IssuesT_A = \text{Issues}). Maximize Amiya's vote share VAV_A.

• Vote Share Structure:

• When Amiya focuses on issues, her own voters never defect or abstain (VA≥VA0V_A \ge V_{A0}).

• Amiya's vote share formula:

• If Ramya focuses on issues: $V_A = V_{A0}$.

• If Ramya attacks: $20\%$ of Ramya's base defects to Amiya ($V_A = V_{A0} + 0.20 V_{R0}$).

• Maximizing VAV_A:

• To maximize VAV_A, Amiya must maximize her own base: choose Vigorous campaign (LA=2  ⟹  VA0=40%L_A = 2 \implies V_{A0} = 40\%).

• To maximize defections received, Ramya must run an Attack campaign with maximum base: choose Vigorous (LR=2  ⟹  VR0=40%L_R = 2 \implies V_{R0} = 40\%).

• Defections gained: 0.20×40%=8%0.20 \times 40\% = 8\%.

• Maximum votes for Amiya: VA=40%+8%=48%V_A = 40\% + 8\% = 48\%.

• Verification: In the Master State Table, Case C14 (Amiya Vigorous Issues, Ramya Vigorous Attack) confirms VA=48.0%V_A = 48.0\%.

• Option Matching:

• Matches Option 3 (48%).

Topper Take

• Additive Defection Rule: An issues candidate absorbs opponent defectors without leaking any base. Maximize both the candidate's own base (40%40\%) and the attacking opponent's base (40%40\%) to get 40%+0.20(40%)=48%40\% + 0.20(40\%) = 48\%.

• Asymmetry Check: Remember Ramya surrenders 20%20\% when attacking, which is double Amiya's penalty (10%10\%).

Other questions in this set

  1. Q18. If both of them run staid campaigns attacking the other, then what percentage of students will vote in the election?
  2. Q19. What is the minimum percentage of students who will vote in the election?
  3. Q21. If Ramya runs a campaign attacking Amiya, then what is the minimum percentage of votes that she is guaranteed to get?
  4. Q22. What is the maximum possible voting margin with which one of the candidates can win?

Optimization questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2023 Slot 1 DILR Q11
    How many UK applications were scheduled on that day? (in numerial value)
  2. CAT 2023 Slot 1 DILR Q12
    What is the maximum possible value of the total time (in minutes, nearest to its integer value) required to…
  3. CAT 2023 Slot 1 DILR Q13
    Which of the following is the closest to the time when Nandini's application process got over?
  4. CAT 2023 Slot 1 DILR Q14
    Which of the following statements is false?
  5. CAT 2023 Slot 1 DILR Q15
    When did the application processing for all US applicants get over on that day?

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc