CAT 2019 Slot 2 VARC Q19

  • Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
  • Reading Comprehension › Culture
  • Medium
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2019_SLOT2_VARC_Q19

Passage · questions 15–20

The magic of squatter cities is that they are improved steadily and gradually by their residents. To a planner's eye, these cities look chaotic. I trained as a biologist and to my eye, they look organic. Squatter cities are also unexpectedly green. They have maximum density-1 million people per square mile in some areas of Mumbai-and have minimum energy and material use. People get around by foot, bicycle, rickshaw, or the universal shared taxi.

Not everything is efficient in the slums, though. In the Brazilian favelas where leave their lights on all day. But in most slums recycling is literally a way of life. The Dharavi slum in Mumbai has 400400 recycling units and 30,00030,000 ragpickers. Six thousand tons of rubbish are sorted every day. In 2007, the Economist reported that in Vietnam and Mozambique, "Waves of gleaners sift the sweepings of Hanoi's streets, just as Mozambiquan children pick over the rubbish of Maputo's main tip. Every city in Asia and Latin America has an industry based on gathering up old cardboard boxes."

In his 19851985 article, Calthorpe made a statement that still jars with most people: "The city is the most environmentally benign form of human settlement. Each city dweller consumes less land, less energy, less water, and produces less pollution than his counterpart in settlements of lower densities." "Green Manhattan" was the inflammatory title of a 20042004 New Yorker article by David Owen. "By the most significant measures," he wrote, "New York is the greenest community in the United States, and one of the greenest cities in the world . . . The key to New York's relative environmental benignity is its extreme compactness. Placing one and a half million people on a twenty-three-square-mile island sharply reduces their opportunities to be wasteful." He went on to note that this very compactness forces people to live in the world's most energy-efficient apartment buildings.

Urban density allows half of humanity to live on 2.82.8 per cent of the land. Consider just the infrastructure efficiencies. According to a 20042004 UN report: "The concentration of population and enterprises in urban areas greatly reduces the unit cost of piped water, sewers, drains, roads, electricity, garbage collection, transport, health care, and schools."

The nationally subsidised city of Manaus in northern Brazil "answers the question" of how to stop deforestation: give people decent jobs. Then they can afford houses, and gain security. One hundred thousand people who would otherwise be deforesting the jungle around Manaus are now prospering in town making such things as mobile phones and televisions.

Of course, fast-growing cities are far from an unmitigated good. They concentrate crime, pollution, disease and injustice as much as business, innovation, education and entertainment. But if they are overall a net good for those who move there, it is because cities offer more than just jobs. They are transformative: in the slums, as well as the office towers and leafy suburbs, the progress is from hick to metropolitan to cosmopolitan electricity is stolen and therefore free, people

Question 19

Which one of the following statements would undermine the author's stand regarding the greenness of cities?

  1. A

    Sorting through rubbish contributes to the rapid spread of diseases in the slums

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    The high density of cities leads to an increase in carbon dioxide and global warming

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    The compactness of big cities in the West increases the incidence of violent crime

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    Over the last decade the cost of utilities has been increasing for city dwellers

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (B)

The high density of cities leads to an increase in carbon dioxide and global warming

Solution

🎯 Question Analysis & Solution

  • Question Type: Critical Reasoning (Weaken / Undermine)

  • Passage Reference:

"The city is the most environmentally benign form of human settlement. Each city dweller consumes less land, less energy, less water, and produces less pollution than his counterpart in settlements of lower densities... The key to New York's relative environmental benignity is its extreme compactness. Placing one and a half million people on a twenty-three-square-mile island sharply reduces their opportunities to be wasteful."

Logical Deduction

The author's core thesis regarding "the greenness of cities" posits that extreme density and compactness reduce per-capita energy, resource consumption, and overall environmental pollution. To undermine this thesis, a statement must demonstrate that high density directly exacerbates environmental destruction. If high urban density actively leads to an increase in carbon dioxide emissions and drives global warming, the author's foundational premise that dense cities are ecologically benign is directly refuted.

Correct Answer: Option 2

  • Option 2 directly invalidates the author's thesis by establishing a causal link between high urban density and increased carbon dioxide emissions driving global warming, refuting the claim that cities are environmentally green.

Option Elimination

  • Option 1 (Out of Scope): Disease transmission in slums relates to public health and sanitation (which the author already concedes in paragraph 6), not the macro-environmental claim of ecological benignity.

  • Option 3 (Out of Scope): Urban violent crime statistics pertain to municipal safety and sociology, leaving the environmental argument regarding resource conservation untouched.

  • Option 4 (Out of Scope): Rising utility bills represent municipal economic and pricing dynamics, having no bearing on the physical efficiency of resource consumption or carbon footprint.

Detailed explanation

📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure

Central Theme

The passage re-evaluates urban density and squatter settlements through an ecological lens, arguing that compact cities—contrary to popular anti-urban intuition—are the most environmentally benign, resource-efficient, and socially transformative form of human settlement.

Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary

  • Paragraph 1: The author introduces squatter settlements as organic, steadily evolving ecosystems characterized by extreme population density, low material consumption, and low-energy transportation.

  • Paragraph 2: The text acknowledges certain localized inefficiencies while highlighting pervasive waste sorting and informal recycling networks across global slums (e.g., Dharavi).

  • Paragraph 3: The author cites Calthorpe and Owen to challenge conventional wisdom, establishing that high-density compact cities (like Manhattan) minimize per-capita energy, water, land use, and emissions.

  • Paragraph 4: Citing a UN report, the text details the macro-infrastructural efficiencies of urban clustering, which drastically reduce the per-unit cost of public utilities and social services.

  • Paragraph 5: The author presents Manaus, Brazil, as empirical evidence of urban conservation, demonstrating that urban manufacturing employment diverts populations from destructive rainforest deforestation.

  • Paragraph 6: The author concedes that rapid urbanization concentrates social and health ills, but concludes that cities remain a net good due to their profound economic and cosmopolitan cultural transformation.

Tone and Author's Perspective

  • Tone: Analytical, Persuasive, and Counter-intuitive.

  • Author's Perspective: The author adopts an ecological and sociological defense of urban density, vigorously challenging anti-urban biases by demonstrating that spatial compactness drives environmental sustainability and human progress.

Other questions in this set

  1. Q15. We can infer that Calthorpe's statement "still jars" with most people because most people:
  2. Q16. From the passage it can be inferred that cities are good places to live in for all of the following reasons EXCEPT…
  3. Q17. In the context of the passage, the author refers to Manaus in order to:
  4. Q18. According to the passage, squatter cities are environment-friendly for all of the following reasons EXCEPT:
  5. Q20. The "long pedigree" of the aim to shift civil servants to improve their living standards implies that this move:

Culture questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q2
    The goal of the author over the course of this passage is to:
  2. CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q3
    What relation does the “communication problem” mentioned in paragraph 2 have to the questions that the…
  3. CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q4
    From the context in which it is placed, the phrase “sui generis” in paragraph 3 suggests which one of the…
  4. CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q5
    The mention of Stravinsky’s description of music in the first paragraph does all the following EXCEPT:
  5. CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q16
    All of the following, if true, would weaken the passage’s claims about the hallucinatory tribal imagination…

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc