CAT 2019 Slot 2 DILR Q18

  • Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
  • Logical Reasoning › Optimization
  • Medium
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2019_SLOT2_DILR_Q18

Data set · questions 17–20

Three doctors, Dr. Ben, Dr. Kane and Dr. Wayne visit a particular clinic Monday to Saturday to see patients. Dr. Ben sees each patient for 10 minutes and charges Rs. 100/-. Dr. Kane sees each patient for 15 minutes and charges Rs. 200/-, while Dr. Wayne sees each patient for 25 minutes and charges Rs. 300/-.

The clinic has three rooms numbered 1, 2 and 3 which are assigned to the three doctors as per the following table.

Room No.Monday & TuesdayWednesday & ThursdayFriday & Saturday
1BenWayneKane
2KaneBenWayne
3WayneKaneBen

The clinic is open from 9 a.m. to 11.30 a.m. every Monday to Saturday.

On arrival each patient is handed a numbered token indicating their position in the queue, starting with token number 1 every day. As soon as any doctor becomes free, the next patient in the queue enters that emptied room for consultation. If at any time, more than one room is free then the waiting patient enters the room with the smallest number. For example, if the next two patients in the queue have token numbers 7 and 8 and if rooms numbered 1 and 3 are free, then patient with token number 7 enters room number 1 and patient with token number 8 enters room number 3.

Question 18

The queue is never empty on one particular Saturday. Which of the three doctors would earn the maximum amount in consultation charges on that day?

  1. A

    Dr. Ben

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    Dr. Wayne

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    Both Dr. Wayne and Dr. Kane

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    Dr. Kane

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (D)

Dr. Kane

Solution

Concept: Revenue Optimization, Fixed-Capacity Serving Rates & Invariant Doctor Earnings

Master State Table

DoctorConsultation Duration (min)Consultation Fee (Rs.)Max Patients (150 min)Max Revenue (Rs.)Room (Mon & Tue)Room (Wed & Thu)Room (Fri & Sat)
Dr. Ben10100151,500Room 1Room 2Room 3
Dr. Kane15200102,000Room 2Room 3Room 1
Dr. Wayne2530061,800Room 3Room 1Room 2
Total / Clinic Capacity——315,300Rooms 1, 2, 3Rooms 1, 2, 3Rooms 1, 2, 3

Question Deduction

• Premise & Full Capacity Utilization on Saturday:

• With the queue "never empty" on Saturday, all three doctors consult without idle downtime throughout the 150-minute150\text{-minute} session (9:00 a.m. to 11:30 a.m.).

• Consultation fees and durations are personal attributes, completely independent of the physical room assigned on Saturday.

• Individual Doctor Earnings Breakdown:

• Dr. Ben: Takes 10 min10\text{ min} at Rs. 100\text{Rs. } 100/patient   ⟹  15010=15 patients  ⟹  15×100=Rs. 1,500\implies \frac{150}{10} = 15\text{ patients} \implies 15 \times 100 = \text{Rs. } 1,500.

• Dr. Kane: Takes 15 min15\text{ min} at Rs. 200\text{Rs. } 200/patient   ⟹  15015=10 patients  ⟹  10×200=Rs. 2,000\implies \frac{150}{15} = 10\text{ patients} \implies 10 \times 200 = \text{Rs. } 2,000.

• Dr. Wayne: Takes 25 min25\text{ min} at Rs. 300\text{Rs. } 300/patient   ⟹  15025=6 patients  ⟹  6×300=Rs. 1,800\implies \frac{150}{25} = 6\text{ patients} \implies 6 \times 300 = \text{Rs. } 1,800.

• Comparative Ranking & Trap Analysis:

• Total revenue ranking: Dr. Kane (Rs. 2,000)>Dr. Wayne (Rs. 1,800)>Dr. Ben (Rs. 1,500)\text{Dr. Kane (Rs. 2,000)} > \text{Dr. Wayne (Rs. 1,800)} > \text{Dr. Ben (Rs. 1,500)}.

• High-Fee Trap: Picking Dr. Wayne because his single-patient fee is highest (Rs. 300\text{Rs. } 300) overlooks his slow 25-minute pace, which limits capacity to 6 patients (Rs. 1,800\text{Rs. } 1,800).

• High-Volume Trap: Picking Dr. Ben because he treats the most patients (1515) overlooks his modest Rs. 100\text{Rs. } 100 fee, capping revenue at Rs. 1,500\text{Rs. } 1,500.

• Dr. Kane strikes the optimal product of pace and fee (10×200=Rs. 2,00010 \times 200 = \text{Rs. } 2,000), earning the absolute maximum.

• Option Matching:

• Dr. Kane earns the maximum amount in consultation charges on that Saturday (Rs. 2,000\text{Rs. } 2,000).

• Matches Option 4.

Topper Take

• Earning Velocity Shortcut: Compare rates per minute: Ben earns 10010=Rs. 10/min\frac{100}{10} = \text{Rs. } 10/\text{min}, Wayne earns 30025=Rs. 12/min\frac{300}{25} = \text{Rs. } 12/\text{min}, and Kane earns 20015=Rs. 13.33/min\frac{200}{15} = \text{Rs. } 13.33/\text{min}. Kane has the highest velocity and dominates over any full session.

• Saturday Distractor: Room assignments on Saturday are purely decorative; individual revenue depends strictly on consultation velocity and fee per patient.

Other questions in this set

  1. Q17. What is the maximum number of patients that the clinic can cater to on any single day?
  2. Q19. Mr. Singh visited the clinic on Monday, Wednesday, and Friday of a particular week, arriving at 8:50 a.m. on each of…
  3. Q20. On a slow Thursday, only two patients are waiting at 9 a.m. After that two patients keep arriving at exact 15 minute…

Optimization questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q18
    If both of them run staid campaigns attacking the other, then what percentage of students will vote in the…
  2. CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q19
    What is the minimum percentage of students who will vote in the election?
  3. CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q20
    If Amiya runs a campaign focusing on issues, then what is the maximum percentage of votes that she can get?
  4. CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q21
    If Ramya runs a campaign attacking Amiya, then what is the minimum percentage of votes that she is…
  5. CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q22
    What is the maximum possible voting margin with which one of the candidates can win?

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc