CAT 2019 Slot 1 VARC Q20
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension › Literature
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2019_SLOT1_VARC_Q20
Passage · questions 20–24
In the past, credit for telling the tale of Aladdin has often gone to Antoine Galland the first European translator of Arabian Nights which started as a series of translations of an incomplete manuscript of a medieval Arabic story collection. But, though those tales were of medieval origin, Aladdin may be a more recent invention. Scholars have not found a manuscript of the story that predates the version published in by Galland, who wrote in his diary that he first heard the tale from a Syrian storyteller from Aleppo named Hanna Diyab.
Despite the fantastical elements of the story, scholars now think the main character may actually be based on a real person's real experiences. Though Galland never credited Diyab in his published translations of the Arabian Nights stories, Diyab wrote something of his own: a travelogue penned in the mid-18th century. In it, he recalls telling Galland the story of Aladdin [and] describes his own hard-knocks upbringing and the way he marveled at the extravagance of Versailles. The descriptions he uses were very similar to the descriptions of the lavish palace that ended up in Galland's version of the Aladdin story. Therefore, author Paulo Lemos Horta believes that "Aladdin might be the young Arab Maronite from Aleppo, marveling at the jewels and riches of Versailles."
For years, scholars thought that the rags-to-riches story of Aladdin might have been inspired by the plots of French fairy tales that came out around the same time, or that the story was invented in that 18th century period as a byproduct of French Orientalism, a fascination with stereotypical exotic Middle Eastern luxuries that was prevalent then. The idea that Diyab might have based it on his own life the experiences of a Middle Eastern man encountering the French, not vice-versa flips the script. According to Horta, "Diyab was ideally placed to embody the overlapping world of East and West, blending the storytelling traditions of his homeland with his youthful observations of the wonder of 18th-century France."
To the scholars who study the tale, its narrative drama isn't the only reason storytellers keep finding reason to return to Aladdin. It reflects not only "a history of the French and the Middle East, but also a story about Middle Easterners coming to Paris and that speaks to our world today," as Horta puts it. "The day Diyab told the story of Aladdin to Galland, there were riots due to food shortages during the winter and spring of to 1709, and Diyab was sensitive to those people in a way that Galland is not. When you read this diary, you see this solidarity among the Arabs who were in Paris at the time. There is little in the writings of Galland that would suggest that he was capable of developing a character like Aladdin with sympathy, but Diyab's memoir reveals a narrator adept at capturing the distinctive psychology of a young protagonist, as well as recognizing the kinds of injustices and opportunities that can transform the path of any youthful adventurer."
Question 20
Which of the following, if true, would invalidate the inversion that the phrase "flips the script" refers to?
Show answer and solution
Answer: (C)
The description of opulence in Hanna Diyab's and Antoine Galland's narratives bore no resemblance to each other.
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Weaken / Invalidation of Core Thesis
-
Passage Reference:
"For 300 years, scholars thought that the rags-to-riches story of Aladdin might have been inspired by the plots of French fairy tales... or that the story was invented... as a byproduct of French Orientalism... The idea that Diyab might have based it on his own life the experiences of a Middle Eastern man encountering the French, not vice-versa flips the script."
"The descriptions he uses were very similar to the descriptions of the lavish palace that ended up in Galland's version of the Aladdin story. Therefore, author Paulo Lemos Horta believes that "Aladdin might be the young Arab Maronite from Aleppo, marveling at the jewels and riches of Versailles.""
Logical Deduction
-
The "script" originally posited that Aladdin was an exoticizing European fantasy created by French writers projecting stereotypical Orientalist tropes onto the East.
-
The inversion ("flips the script") is that Aladdin actually reflects the gaze of a Middle Eastern traveler (Hanna Diyab) observing and marveling at 18th-century France.
-
The primary empirical bridge supporting this inversion is textual: the descriptions of the palace's extravagance in Galland's tale correspond closely to Diyab's own travelogue describing the lavish architecture and jewels of Versailles.
-
If Diyab's descriptions of French opulence bore no resemblance whatsoever to the opulent descriptions in Galland's tale, the textual foundation linking Aladdin's palace to Versailles disintegrates.
-
Without that correlation, the argument that the story reflects a Middle Easterner's impression of French grandeur is severely undermined, invalidating the inversion.
Correct Answer: Option 3
- The entire thesis that Diyab modeled Aladdin's palace on Versailles depends on the strong textual correspondence between his travelogue and Galland's narrative; if they bore no resemblance, the claim of inversion collapses.
Option Elimination
-
Option 1 (Out of Scope): Whether Galland formally acknowledged Diyab in his published volumes affects Galland's academic integrity, but does not invalidate the underlying biographical origin of the narrative.
-
Option 2 (Opposite Meaning / Scope Reversal): If French fairy tales lacked rags-to-riches plots, that would eliminate the competing European hypothesis, thereby strengthening rather than invalidating the inversion.
-
Option 4 (Factual Distortion): Changing the specific French city would still demonstrate a Middle Easterner marveling at French wealth, preserving the fundamental East-encounters-West inversion.
Detailed explanation
📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure
Central Theme
The literary-historical reassessment of the authorship of Aladdin, demonstrating that the tale is neither an ancient medieval relic nor a byproduct of French Orientalist fantasy, but a composite narrative drawn from the autobiographical experiences, cross-cultural encounters, and empathetic social sensibilities of Syrian storyteller Hanna Diyab.
Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary
-
Paragraph 1: Challenges the traditional attribution of Aladdin to European translator Antoine Galland or medieval Arabic manuscripts, revealing that the story first appeared in Galland’s 1712 publication after being related orally by Syrian storyteller Hanna Diyab.
-
Paragraph 2: Presents textual evidence from Diyab’s mid-18th-century travelogue linking Aladdin's opulent palace to Diyab’s personal wonder at Versailles, supporting Paulo Lemos Horta’s thesis that Aladdin mirrors Diyab's own youthful trajectory.
-
Paragraph 3: Overturns the 300-year-old scholarly consensus that Aladdin originated from French fairy tales or French Orientalism, arguing instead that Diyab "flipped the script" by narrating a Middle Eastern traveler's encounter with French culture.
-
Paragraph 4: Explains the enduring contemporary relevance of Aladdin, highlighting Diyab's distinct empathy for marginalized urban populations during the 1708–1709 Parisian food riots and his psychological insight into youthful striving against injustice.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Academic, Scholarly, Revisionist, and Analytical.
-
Author's Perspective: The author strongly endorses revisionist literary scholarship, restoring historical agency and authorship to Hanna Diyab and celebrating Aladdin as a nuanced cross-cultural migrant narrative rather than an exoticized colonial fable.
Other questions in this set
- Q21. The author of the passage is most likely to agree with which of the following explanations for the origins of the…
- Q22. All of the following serve as evidence for the character of Aladdin being based on Hanna Diyab EXCEPT:
- Q23. Which of the following is the primary reason for why storytellers are still fascinated by the story of Aladdin?
- Q24. Which of the following does not contribute to the passage's claim about the authorship of Aladdin?
Literature questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 VARC Q13
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 VARC Q14
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 VARC Q15
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 VARC Q16
- CAT 2023 Slot 1 VARC Q9
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc